Ready, steady… save!
You don’t need a chart to join in. Here are 2 ways to record your savings:
1. Cross it off
Pop a chart into your first post. Saved an amount? Cross it out! Read more »
£0.01 £0.02 £0.03
2. Write it down
Skip the chart and add updates to your first post. Read more »
“Another +£3 saved today. Go me!”
Use +£ before each new saving so it counts towards your total.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Used washing machine fully broken down in 3 months, company refusing CRA2015
Comments
-
It's better than the initial refusal to act, and probably a lot faster than OP pursuing court action. I agree that the retailer seemingly doesn't want to comply with their obligations, or doesn't properly understand them, but pragmatism comes into play. How long does OP want to be without a washing machine (or the funds to buy one) while they work towards a successful legal claim? And even then, just as you doubt the retailer's honesty, can OP be confident they'd pay up in the event of a successful claim?A_Geordie said:
What’s right with the proposal? Who’s to say the retailer won’t concoct a story that the washing machine was a user fault rather than an actual fault, just to get out of liability?What's wrong with that proposal? Seems fair enough, and you're confident it's properly broken rather than having been damaged by you. They're entitled to check the fault themselves rather than just taking your word for it.Regardless, the test under the Consumer Rights Act is for the retailer to prove that the washing machine confirmed on the day the contract was created not at any point after that.Presumably the retailer would have done its testing of the machine and the parts were all in working order prior to it being delivered to the OP. That might be sufficient to satisfy the burden of proof if evidence is provided but if not, then the law assumes it’s faulty from day 1.Of course, age of the machine should be taken into account amongst other things but there should be a reasonable expectation that the machine will last a reasonable period after purchase.0 -
Which sounds like they know what the issue is. Given the offer to send a part, then would be unlikely for them to say user error/fault.Grumpy_chap said:
Have you checked the obvious, like try a different plug socket?danndanndanndann said:The machine itself is completely bricked. Won’t turn on at all and no power
Check the fuse in the plug?
It seems as though you are refusing their reasonable proposals.danndanndanndann said:they offered to send a part to fix the machine as a “gesture of goodwill that takes no responsibility for fault” and I would have to pay to fix it.
they offered to arrange a collection for inspection and repair, however it no sign of customer misuse or fault is found, a standard collection and delivery fee at apply.Obviously I don’t agree with either of these solutions as it’s been over a month now and way past reasonable time, I’ve also asked them to repair it multiple times already and been refused
so now it looks like small claims court is next
They have offered to send the part to fix the machine for you to fit. (This means there must have been more discussion about what the fault is so they know what part to send.)
They have offered to collect the machine, inspect and repair. Only if it transpires to be your fault will they charge you. That appears to satisfy the requirement that the fault was deemed to be present at the point of sale unless demonstrated otherwise. The supplier is allowed to do the inspection that might demonstrate otherwise.
Obviously, the devil is in the detail. I appear to agree with @Aylesbury_Duck and @sheramber but appear to be disagreeing with @A_Geordie
As I read it at present, the OP has viable solutions offered by a co-operative seller but the OP seems to want to prefer to have their day in court.
Has Op had a google for machine & known issues?Life in the slow lane1 -
Surely they are entitled to confirm that the machine is faulty.A_Geordie said:
Absolutely right, but why would you allow them to inspect it when that option goes beyond what you are required to do under consumer rights laws?There is always the risk, in any claim , that the retailer will claim a user error unless the buyer gets there own independent investigation to confirm what the fault is.Nothing in the CRA says that the retailer has a right to inspect the suspected faulty goods or for user error before confirming whether they are indeed faulty - it is not a subjective obligation that the retailer gets to decide. Either they prove the goods conformed at the time of the contract or they didn’t.
Presumably the OP has been using it so it was not faulty on delivery , but only stopped working after the OP had been using it.1 -
Just to confirm and answer a few questions. If i'm wrong anywhere people can correct me and i'm taking on board everything people have said. Any of the legal talk or messages to the company were sent after contacting citizens advice and consumer advice scotland.
I have checked the socket, plug and have cleared the filter since the machine died mid use and will not turn on. This was on the 21st of November, also the date of contacting the company.
The exact messages from the company about parts or to take it back were sent on the 23rd of december and after, a full month since noting the problem to them."...As advised, while we are unable to action a repair or warranty claim on this item, we can offer to supply a replacement part as a gesture of goodwill, if required.
Please note this offer is made without admission of fault and does not extend to labour, engineer visits, or a full repair. If you can confirm the specific part you believe is required (or provide a short video showing the issue), we can review this and advise accordingly."
The reason i ignored this message as from my understanding, the reasonable time to fix the machine is less than a full month. I also shouldn't have to pay any money to repair the item or have to repair the item myself. Plus it shouldn't be goodwill or to absolve them of guilt. Again if im wrong please correct me, i'm just trying to take it all in
"As a gesture of goodwill, we can arrange a collection for inspection and repair if deemed necessary. Please note that if signs of customer misuse or no fault is found, a standard collection and delivery fee may apply."
This was the next message, my understanding with the CRA2015 there should be no use of fee's or goodwill at all, and again the fact it's taken over a month already it's past a reasonable time. Plus as people have pointed out, with how the company has acted so far it really comes across as they will not be 100% with this. I accept this is not a fact so i can concede that.
I also received this message today from the company, accepting they received my letter"Under Section 19(14) of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, where a fault is alleged more than six months after delivery, the burden of proof rests with the consumer to demonstrate that the fault was present at the time of delivery. No evidence has been provided to support this.
Furthermore, under Sections 9 and 10 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, goods must be of satisfactory quality and fit for purpose, taking into account their description, price, and the fact that they are second-hand. The item was accurately described as USED, and no inherent fault was reported within the initial warranty period.
As the claim was made outside the warranty period and beyond six months from purchase, and in the absence of evidence that the fault existed at the time of delivery, we are not legally obliged to offer a repair, replacement, or refund."
I found this very strange since It was 3 months when i first messaged with the issue and it's been 4 months as of this email. Not really sure why they would even sent this to me0 -
The letter is likely a standard response sent my someone without any review. Don't get caught up on that.
I would not worry about the use of the term "goodwill" or whatever.danndanndanndann said:
"As a gesture of goodwill, we can arrange a collection for inspection and repair if deemed necessary. Please note that if signs of customer misuse or no fault is found, a standard collection and delivery fee may apply."
This was the next message, my understanding with the CRA2015 there should be no use of fee's or goodwill at all, and again the fact it's taken over a month already it's past a reasonable time. Plus as people have pointed out, with how the company has acted so far it really comes across as they will not be 100% with this. I accept this is not a fact so i can concede that.
The check and inspect seems reasonable to me and, if the fault was down to the customer (or there is no fault), then the supplier should not be out of pocket either.
Consider my extreme example:
- I buy a used car and drive it away quite happily from the Dealer.
- Within three months I find the car is overheating and losing oil so it stops working.
- I seek to reject the car on the basis of not fit for purpose and the fault is deemed to have been present or developing at the point of sale.
- The Dealer collects the car on a transporter and carried out an inspection for customer misuse.
- The Dealer reports back that the cause of the overheating and the lost oil is the fact the customer drove the car into a brick wall.
- The Dealer charges the customer for the collection and inspection and provides the customer a quote to fix and / or simply return the car back to the customer.
So, in this extreme case, would you stand by the Dealer being liable (after all a fault within 6 months), or is it actually reasonable for the Dealer to inspect the goods and exclude customer mis-use since purchase and recover the costs of that action? (Assume the car being driven into the brick wall was not the result of a fault with the car but wholly driver error.)0 -
@sheramber @Grumpy_chap @Aylesbury_Duck tagging you all since there’s some overlap with what I’m about to say.
TLDR: The trader can ask to inspect the goods, but the consumer can deny that request. In that case the trader should either repair or replace per the consumer’s request, or provide evidence that the goods conformed from day 1 of the contract based on the evidence in their possession.
As we all know, the CRA framework is designed to be consumer friendly and its purpose is to put the consumer in control of the remedies available for faulty goods or goods that don’t conform, so its against that backdrop when interpreting the legislation.
I’ll summarise my reasons why the trader is not entitled by law to inspect the goods prior to a repair or replacement:
1. The CRA clearly states that liability is automatic within the first 6 months, unless conformity can be shown from day 1. Requiring inspection of the goods before a repair or replacement would mean that you are imposing a pre-condition to the repair or replacement. I mentioned before that the CRA does not explicitly state that inspection is required as a pre-condition. If this were the case, then Parliament would have written this into the CRA but by doing so, it then shifts the control of remedies into the hands of the trader and not the consumer, which ultimately defeats the object of the CRA.
2. Inspection (in my opinion) is a defensive tool and not a prerequisite to fulfilling the trader’s statutory obligations. In the extreme example given by grumpy_chap, the trader can challenge at a later date any misuse or damage caused by the consumer after the repair or replacement has taken effect and they have then received the goods back from the trader. This would be keeping with the principle that that consumer remains in control of the remedies. No different to the way a chargeback would work where the trader has the right to pursue the consumer later down the line.
3. Inspection can create unreasonable delays contrary to section 23(2)(a) which requires the repair or replacement to be carried out within a reasonable time and without insignificant inconvenience to the consumer.
4. There’s an arguable point that forcing an inspection prior to the trader complying with its statutory obligations, restricts or undermines the right to repair or replace goods contrary to section 31(2)(b) or (c). With the trader having the goods back into their hands before issuing a repair or replacement, it puts the trader in the advantageous position to have the goods repaired knowing that a fault existed or concocting a story about consumer misuse and thereby denying the consumer’s right to a formal repair or replacement. This has a knock on effect for the consumer especially with respect to the consumer’s right to exercise a final right to reject or price reduction if the goods end up becoming faulty again within a relatively short space of time because the first fault would not be counted for the purposes of the CRA.
5. Inspection is not a necessary step to proving conformity and outside extreme examples, I am not sure how inspecting the goods proves conformity, particularly where a consumable part is damaged or worn out. Traders can carry out pre-inspection testing/reporting to ensure that the goods are in working order, similar to what traders do in the car industry. Obviously that depends on how detailed the inspection report is as to how effective the trader’s evidence will be. If the trader does not take that opportunity to inspect goods before sending them out to customers, that’s a trader issue not a consumer one.
I would also argue that ignoring the reference to “goodwill” is potentially a dangerous position to take. Goodwill offers are discretionary and the way the trader has worded their offer i.e. without any admission of liability, could be seen as an offer to settle the dispute. Should the OP accept, that could bring an end to them bringing a claim in the future because the matter has been settled.
4 -
The retailer is entitled under the CRA to assess whether repair or replacement is possible or disproportionate, and in most cases they can’t do that without inspecting the item to see what the actual issue is.If a consumer refuses to make the goods available for inspection, the retailer is entitled to pause the process because the statutory remedy can’t be carried out. I can’t see a court finding it unreasonable for a retailer to say they need to inspect the item before deciding and providing the appropriate remedy.Where an Act imposes a duty, it is presumed to grant by implication the powers necessary to discharge that duty effectively, unless a contrary intention appears.
0 -
I accept liability is automatic unless it can be proved otherwise within the first 6 months. But how can the retailer prove otherwise if they aren’t allowed to inspect the goods? There would be no way to do so and so that view would effectively tie the retailers arms behind their back and mean there was nothing they could do to dispute any claim within 6 months, which can’t be the correct interpretation.A_Geordie said:@sheramber @Grumpy_chap @Aylesbury_Duck tagging you all since there’s some overlap with what I’m about to say.
TLDR: The trader can ask to inspect the goods, but the consumer can deny that request. In that case the trader should either repair or replace per the consumer’s request, or provide evidence that the goods conformed from day 1 of the contract based on the evidence in their possession.
As we all know, the CRA framework is designed to be consumer friendly and its purpose is to put the consumer in control of the remedies available for faulty goods or goods that don’t conform, so its against that backdrop when interpreting the legislation.
I’ll summarise my reasons why the trader is not entitled by law to inspect the goods prior to a repair or replacement:
1. The CRA clearly states that liability is automatic within the first 6 months, unless conformity can be shown from day 1. Requiring inspection of the goods before a repair or replacement would mean that you are imposing a pre-condition to the repair or replacement. I mentioned before that the CRA does not explicitly state that inspection is required as a pre-condition. If this were the case, then Parliament would have written this into the CRA but by doing so, it then shifts the control of remedies into the hands of the trader and not the consumer, which ultimately defeats the object of the CRA.
2. Inspection (in my opinion) is a defensive tool and not a prerequisite to fulfilling the trader’s statutory obligations. In the extreme example given by grumpy_chap, the trader can challenge at a later date any misuse or damage caused by the consumer after the repair or replacement has taken effect and they have then received the goods back from the trader. This would be keeping with the principle that that consumer remains in control of the remedies. No different to the way a chargeback would work where the trader has the right to pursue the consumer later down the line.
3. Inspection can create unreasonable delays contrary to section 23(2)(a) which requires the repair or replacement to be carried out within a reasonable time and without insignificant inconvenience to the consumer.
4. There’s an arguable point that forcing an inspection prior to the trader complying with its statutory obligations, restricts or undermines the right to repair or replace goods contrary to section 31(2)(b) or (c). With the trader having the goods back into their hands before issuing a repair or replacement, it puts the trader in the advantageous position to have the goods repaired knowing that a fault existed or concocting a story about consumer misuse and thereby denying the consumer’s right to a formal repair or replacement. This has a knock on effect for the consumer especially with respect to the consumer’s right to exercise a final right to reject or price reduction if the goods end up becoming faulty again within a relatively short space of time because the first fault would not be counted for the purposes of the CRA.
5. Inspection is not a necessary step to proving conformity and outside extreme examples, I am not sure how inspecting the goods proves conformity, particularly where a consumable part is damaged or worn out. Traders can carry out pre-inspection testing/reporting to ensure that the goods are in working order, similar to what traders do in the car industry. Obviously that depends on how detailed the inspection report is as to how effective the trader’s evidence will be. If the trader does not take that opportunity to inspect goods before sending them out to customers, that’s a trader issue not a consumer one.
I would also argue that ignoring the reference to “goodwill” is potentially a dangerous position to take. Goodwill offers are discretionary and the way the trader has worded their offer i.e. without any admission of liability, could be seen as an offer to settle the dispute. Should the OP accept, that could bring an end to them bringing a claim in the future because the matter has been settled.Northern Ireland club member No 382 :j1 -
With all due respect, I’m not sure you fully read my post or you have only skimmed it. You are suggesting that it is impossible for the trader to show the second hand goods conformed at the time the contract was entered into which is just not true.I accept liability is automatic unless it can be proved otherwise within the first 6 months. But how can the retailer prove otherwise if they aren’t allowed to inspect the goods? There would be no way to do so and so that view would effectively tie the retailers arms behind their back and mean there was nothing they could do to dispute any claim within 6 months, which can’t be the correct interpretation.
See point 5 where the example I gave was the car industry. If they can do pre-inspection testing then why is it impossible for a trader who sells second hand electricals? I am not suggesting traders need to go to the nth degree to prove the goods conformed such as a third party inspection each time, but if they do absolutely !!!!!! all prior to it being delivered then the trader can’t really complain if something goes wrong. Who knows, the goods may have been stored in a damp and cold warehouse with a leaky roof for 6 months before the OP purchased it, and that may have contributed to the washing machine becoming faulty.
Regardless of any speculation about the goods and where they were stored or handled, the trader can rebut the automatic presumption by saying that prior to delivery, the goods were both tested and inspected. Specifically on the inspection, the trader could, for example, carry out inspection of commonly worn parts for the type of goods being sold, signed and dated prior to delivery. The burden would then shift to the consumer to show that either the trader didn’t carry out a reasonable inspection, the inspection didn’t cover the faulty in question, or the so-called inspection was a ruse/attempt to avoid liability i.e. the report was conducted after the event.
Also see point 2 which also compares a similar situation that a trader would be in if the consumer obtained a chargeback from their card provider. The trader is left out of pocket if the bank reverses the charge and if they disagree with the outcome, they’re free to take the consumer to court, and they have up to 6 years to do that. In the OP’s scenario, the trader can take the goods back, inspect the goods and if they felt the consumer was being deceitful or that it was consumer error/damage which resulted in the fault occurring, then they can take action.
You may still disagree with my view and I’ll respect that but as far as I’m concerned, omitting something such as the right for a trader to pre-inspect gods prior to repair/replacement of the alleged faulty goods from the legislation Is far too important to be left out, and does not align with other parts of the CRA.0 -
How does the retailer repair something without establishing what needs repaired by inspecting it?A_Geordie said:
With all due respect, I’m not sure you fully read my post or you have only skimmed it. You are suggesting that it is impossible for the trader to show the second hand goods conformed at the time the contract was entered into which is just not true.I accept liability is automatic unless it can be proved otherwise within the first 6 months. But how can the retailer prove otherwise if they aren’t allowed to inspect the goods? There would be no way to do so and so that view would effectively tie the retailers arms behind their back and mean there was nothing they could do to dispute any claim within 6 months, which can’t be the correct interpretation.
See point 5 where the example I gave was the car industry. If they can do pre-inspection testing then why is it impossible for a trader who sells second hand electricals? I am not suggesting traders need to go to the nth degree to prove the goods conformed such as a third party inspection each time, but if they do absolutely !!!!!! all prior to it being delivered then the trader can’t really complain if something goes wrong. Who knows, the goods may have been stored in a damp and cold warehouse with a leaky roof for 6 months before the OP purchased it, and that may have contributed to the washing machine becoming faulty.
Regardless of any speculation about the goods and where they were stored or handled, the trader can rebut the automatic presumption by saying that prior to delivery, the goods were both tested and inspected. Specifically on the inspection, the trader could, for example, carry out inspection of commonly worn parts for the type of goods being sold, signed and dated prior to delivery. The burden would then shift to the consumer to show that either the trader didn’t carry out a reasonable inspection, the inspection didn’t cover the faulty in question, or the so-called inspection was a ruse/attempt to avoid liability i.e. the report was conducted after the event.
Also see point 2 which also compares a similar situation that a trader would be in if the consumer obtained a chargeback from their card provider. The trader is left out of pocket if the bank reverses the charge and if they disagree with the outcome, they’re free to take the consumer to court, and they have up to 6 years to do that. In the OP’s scenario, the trader can take the goods back, inspect the goods and if they felt the consumer was being deceitful or that it was consumer error/damage which resulted in the fault occurring, then they can take action.
You may still disagree with my view and I’ll respect that but as far as I’m concerned, omitting something such as the right for a trader to pre-inspect gods prior to repair/replacement of the alleged faulty goods from the legislation Is far too important to be left out, and does not align with other parts of the CRA.0
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 356K Banking & Borrowing
- 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 456.3K Spending & Discounts
- 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
- 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 179.1K Life & Family
- 264K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards