IMPORTANT: Please make sure your posts do not contain any personally identifiable information (both your own and that of others). When uploading images, please take care that you have redacted all personal information including number plates, reference numbers and QR codes (which may reveal vehicle information when scanned).

📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Gladstone Claim Form - Witness statement help URGENT

angrylady247
angrylady247 Posts: 6
First Post
Forumite
Hi there, thank you in advance for the help. I've read through all the threads and think I know what to do but want to double check. The original supposed violation was from June 2024 when I was heavily pregnant. I've been fighting this longer than my son has been alive, had all appeals etc rejected and just want to put this to bed and stop wasting my time. We don't even have the car anymore!

What actually happened - my husband dropped me off outside a salon (at the place of the incident) while I ran to the pharmacy, he turned the car back around and waited for me elsewhere. In the time he was turning the car, someone from the salon took these photos and sent us a fine. Our car (white Audi) was being blocked by grey VW making the same manouvre, and so we only left after they had made their u-turn. As it's Gladstone, the PoC don't specify anything. I tried to get a picture from Google of the signage as I can't find the one I took last year myself, but it says NO PARKING and underneath in small print somewhere it also says no waiting, but Gladstone haven't specified any of this.

The pics below show the car running, you can see the driver in the car, I tried to circle in red the signage in the second pic.




I've sent acknolwedgment of service, and have 28 days to submit a defence which gives me until 4th Jan 2026, but I will send before then.

Below is my paragraph 3. Everything else is as per the template. I am using the suggested Gladstone wording, plus some extra particulars to strenghten up my defence. Is that necessary or am I admitting more than they are claiming and therefore should remove it?

With regards to the POC in question, two recent persuasive appeal judgments in Civil Enforcement Limited v Chan (Ref. E7GM9W44) and Car Park Management Service Ltd v Akande (Ref. K0DP5J30) would indicate the POC fails to comply with Civil Procedure Rule 16.4(1)(e) and Practice Direction Part 16.7.5. On the 15th August 2023, in the Chan case, HHJ Murch held: 'the particulars of the claim as filed and served did not set out the conduct which amounted to the breach in reliance upon which the claimant would be able to bring a claim for breach of contract'. The same is true in this case and the Defendant trusts that the Court should strike out the extant claim, using its powers pursuant to CPR 3.4. The second recent persuasive appeal judgment also held that typical private parking case POC (like this) fail to comply with Part 16. On the 10 May 2024, in CPMS v Akande, HHJ Evans held: 'Particulars of Claim have to set out the basic facts upon which a party relies in order to prove his or her claim’.

The driver is not parked, the car is running with driver visible in the car and brake lights shown lit up. The car is in the process of making a u-turn after making a wrong turn and is being blocked by the grey VW also making a u-turn manoeuvre.

Many thanks and happy holidays!

«1

Comments

  • Coupon-mad
    Coupon-mad Posts: 167,072
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite
    What a scam.

    Do you still have the PCN please? We'd like to see it. How many minutes does it say the car was observed for?

    I'd save that last bit for WS stage.
    PRIVATE 'PCN'? DON'T PAY BUT DON'T IGNORE IT (except N.Ireland).
    CLICK at the top or bottom of any page where it says:
    Home»Motoring»Parking Tickets Fines & Parking - read the NEWBIES THREAD
  • What a scam.

    Do you still have the PCN please? We'd like to see it. How many minutes does it say the car was observed for?

    I'd save that last bit for WS stage.


    It doesn't mention any length of time, I assume because the images weren't captured by CCTV but by someone who must have come out of the shop and taken the photos? We did not see any parking warden etc, we would have picked up on that had there been someone.

    Of the photos they supplied, the timestamps span a total of 1min 43 seconds.
  • It isn't a fine it's an invoice they claim you owe.
    This is an obvious honeytrap, the operator and their dim solicitors have both made this up saying "the terms and conditions are clearly set out in the car park".
    It's quite obvious it isn't a "car park" and the signage is not clear, prominent or in conformance to the COP in effect. 
    Also as you state no one parked, and if a contract is to be read and accepted in this case it would take in excess of 1minute 43 seconds to find read and absorb any contract. 
    The signage at the rear is prohibitive stating "No Parking at Any Time" in which case they are not offering a contract to park so cannot demand payment (no offer, no acceptance, no consideration) the sign would be better stating If you park here the fee will be £100!
    In my view this is purely entrapment and is obviously self ticketing (a service PPS offer) someone has quite obviously rushed out and snapped those images like a person on a mission.

    It would be quite easy to place entrance signs stating no unauthorised parking or what ever, but that wouldn't trap people for the PPC to extract money from:
     
  • Le_Kirk
    Le_Kirk Posts: 27,461
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Photogenic Name Dropper
    Forumite
    With an issue date of 02/12/25 and having completed the AoS in a timely manner your defence deadline date is 4.00 p.m. on 05/01/26
    As the claimant did not specify a reason, you should use a Gladstones defence from the template that includes CEL vs Chan and CPMS v Akande.  Who signed the claim form (on the back probably)?
  • Thanks for all the reassurance, glad it's not all in my head just how ridiculous this whole thing is.

    The claim form is signed by a John Davies, Claimaint's Legal Representative as defined by CPR 2.3(1)
  • Hi all,

    I have received the below letter from the solicitors and supposedly their completed DQ.

    I am confused on 2 points:

    1. Is this from the solicitors or from the CNBC (ie is this step 2 or step 3 in the 8 steps)
    2. If it is from the solicitors, the questionnaire they've sent is blank? Is it supposed to be or is this for me to fill?
    Claimants completed DQ 1.jpeg Claimaints completed DQ 2.jpeg

    Thanks

  • ChirpyChicken
    ChirpyChicken Posts: 3,702
    1,000 Posts First Anniversary Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite

    await your copy from the CNBC then you do it online

  • Hi,

    Sorry for the urgent message - I've just realised I only have till Mon 2nd Nov 4pm to submit my WS… I have a newborn baby so it's been a bit hectic and this got forgotten about. Would appreciate if I could get some help today to try and wrap this up.

    I am using the aza123 WS as a template because of the Chan argument. Where they have said the below:

    4.      The first recent persuasive appeal judgment in Civil Enforcement Limited v Chan (Ref.E7GM9W44) would indicate the POCs fail to comply with Civil Procedure Rule 16.4(1)(e) and Practice Direction Part 16.7.5. On 15th August 2023, in the cited case, HHJ Murch held that 'the particulars of the claim as filed and served did not set out the conduct which amounted to the breach in reliance upon which the claimant would be able to bring a claim for breach of contract'. (See Exhibit 1)

    Question 1: What am I supposed to put for exhibit 1, 2 etc. Is it links to the case that I need to put in the footnote?

    Question 2: Where am I supposed to send the WS? The letter did not include an email or anything…

  • Coupon-mad
    Coupon-mad Posts: 167,072
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite

    Here's a good one posted today:

    You email it to the relevant local county court (google for their email) and cc in Gladstones.

    PRIVATE 'PCN'? DON'T PAY BUT DON'T IGNORE IT (except N.Ireland).
    CLICK at the top or bottom of any page where it says:
    Home»Motoring»Parking Tickets Fines & Parking - read the NEWBIES THREAD
  • Ok, it's a bit of a mish-mash between the one linked above, and the aza123 one, but best I can do in between nap times.

    Please could you tell me if anything is missing/needs changing. And just once again, do I need to add a link for Exhibit 1 and 2?

    Thank you so much for the help!!!

    —————-

    WITNESS STATEMENT OF DEFENDANT

    1.  I, XXX of XXX, am the defendant against whom this claim is made. The facts below are true to the best of my knowledge and belief. 

    2.  In my statement I shall refer to exhibits within the evidence supplied with this statement. 

    3.  I am a litigant in person with no formal legal training. I have done my best to present my case and evidence clearly and truthfully, and I respectfully ask the court to take this into account. My defence is repeated, and I will say as follows:

    Preliminary matter: The claim should be struck out

    4. I draw to the attention of the Judge that there are two very recent and persuasive Appeal judgments to support dismissing or striking out the claim. I believe that dismissing this meritless claim is the correct course, with the Overriding Objective in mind. Bulk litigators should know better than to make little or no attempt to comply with the Practice Direction. By continuing to plead cases with generic auto-fill unspecific wording, private parking firms should not be surprised when courts strike out their claims using powers pursuant to CPR 3.4., based in the following persuasive authorities.

    5. The first recent persuasive appeal judgment in Civil Enforcement Limited v Chan (Ref.E7GM9W44) would indicate the POCs fail to comply with Civil Procedure Rule 16.4(1)(e) and Practice Direction Part 16.7.5. On 15th August 2023, in the cited case, HHJ Murch held that 'the particulars of the claim as filed and served did not set out the conduct which amounted to the breach in reliance upon which the claimant would be able to bring a claim for breach of contract'. (See Exhibit 1)

    6. The second recent persuasive appeal judgment in Car Park Management Service Ltd v Akande(Ref. K0DP5J30) would also indicate the POCs fail to comply with Part 16. On 10th May 2024, in the cited case, HHJ Evans held that 'Particulars of Claim have to set out the basic facts upon which a party relies in order to prove his or her claim'. (See Exhibit 2)

    7. I believe the Claim should be struck out and should not have been accepted by the CNBC due to a represented parking firm Claimant knowingly breaching basic CPRs. The PoCs lack clarity, as no explicit statement has been provided to indicate which specific term of the alleged contract was purportedly breached. In fact, the present PoCs are even less detailed than those struck out in Chan and Akande, offering no factual basis for a cause of action.

    Defective Particulars of Claim 

    4. The Claimant’s case is vague, lacking the detail required under Civil Procedure Rule (CPR) 16.4, 16PD3 and 16PD7, which require a claimant to set out all facts necessary to establish a complete cause of action. The Particulars of Claim (POC) simply allege that the driver of the vehicle XXX parked in breach of the terms and conditions displayed on the signage. However, I have seen no evidence that the vehicle was parked, nor which terms have been breached. They have not said where the vehicle was positioned or for how long it was supposedly parked. They also do not identify the standard the Claimant applies, such as the time a car must be stationary for there to be a breach, or provide information on how any contract was formed. Without those details, it has made it difficult for me to respond effectively to the allegation in my defence.

    Facts of the Event

    5. I confirm that I was the leesee and driver of the vehicle in question on the date of the alleged incident.

    6. Brief Stop at 50-60 Greenhill Way

    At the time of the incident, my wife was heavily pregnant and needed to pick something up from the pharmacy. I was looking for a safe place to pull over so she could step out, however, pulled into the wrong road. I stopped momentarily so that she could get out, and then I could make a u-turn and wait elsewhere. The car is not parked, I did not leave the vehicle unattended, or cause any obstruction. You can clearly see the brake lights on and my arm visible in the car. (See Exhibit 3)

    7. As I am attempting to make a u-turn, another car (grey VW) is also in the process of making a u-turn manoeuvre, and blocking my car. (See Exhibit 4). I am unable to leave the area until the VW has completed the manoeuvre. The total ‘stoppage’ time of 1min 43 seconds per the photos provided by the claimant, would have been even less had it not been for the other car ahead of me.

    8. The event did not amount to parking, nor did it block traffic or infringe upon the rights of others. At no time did I act deliberately or negligently.

    No Valid Contract Formed 

    9. It is neither admitted nor denied that any contract term was breached. However, for a valid contract to be formed, there must be an offer, acceptance, and something of value given in return — which was not present here. Under section 71 of the Consumer Rights Act (CRA) 2015 ( Consumer Rights Act 2015 ) the Court must apply a 'test of fairness' and this requires contract terms and any “consumer notices” to be clear and prominent.  

    10. Looking at Schedule 2 (examples 6, 10, 14, and 18) and section 62 of the CRA, which require fair, open dealing and good faith, the Defendant notes that this Claimant is known to use unclear and potentially unfair terms and notices. Based on the limited information provided in this case, the situation appears to be similar. The Claimant is therefore required to strictly prove their case with contemporaneous photographs. 

    Poor Signage

    11. There is an annual report from POPLA, where lead adjudicator Henry Greenslade refers to what a no stopping zone must look (See Exhibit 5)

    12. At the specific location where I stopped, there were no visible signs indicating that stopping or dropping off was prohibited. There were also no red lines, yellow lines, or any other road markings suggesting a restriction applied. The only sign I later became aware of was located on the opposite side of the road (as later viewed on Google Maps) (See Exhibit 6).

    13. The sign is not legible, and for you to read the particulars, you would have to exit the car and take longer than 1min 43 seconds to read the terms upon which you are supposedly agreeing. The signage must be read in order for you to enter a contract with the landowner and the fact that you must stop your vehicle before being able to read the sign means you have already broken any contract before being able to enter a contract.

    Inflated and Unlawful Charges 

    14. In accordance with Schedule 4, paragraph 4(5) of POFA 2012, the Claimant is prohibited from recovering from the keeper any sum greater than the amount of the unpaid parking charges as they existed at the time the Notice to Driver was issued. The sum claimed in these proceedings exceeds that statutory maximum and is therefore unrecoverable from the keeper. ( Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 ) 

    15. Explanatory Note 221 to Schedule 4 confirms that a creditor “may not make a claim against the keeper of a vehicle for more than the amount of the unpaid parking related charges as they stood when the notice to the driver was issued.”   Any added sums—such as “debt recovery fees”, “late fees”, or other invented add‑ons—are not “parking related charges” within the meaning of POFA. These additional amounts do not appear on signage, are not part of any contractual parking charge, and are created solely by third‑party debt recovery agents. POFA provides no legal basis to impose keeper liability for such DRA‑fabricated fees, even if (which is denied) the Claimant had otherwise complied with POFA’s conditions. 

    16. To impose a PC, as well as a breach, the Claimant must show two things: (i) a strong 'legitimate interest' extending beyond compensation for loss, and (ii) 'adequate notice' (prominence) of the PC and any relevant obligation(s). None of which have been demonstrated. This PC is a penalty arising as a result of a 'concealed pitfall or trap', poor signs and covert surveillance, thus it is fully distinguished from ParkingEye v Beavis UKSC67 (link). 

    17. This Claimant continues to pursue a hugely disproportionate sum; it is denied that the quantum sought is recoverable, indeed it represents a penalty. Attention is drawn to paragraphs 98, 100, 193, 198 of Beavis (an £85 PC comfortably covered all letter chain costs and generated a profit shared with the landowner); the court should also read paragraph 3.4 of the original judgment by HHJ Moloney in Beavis (click here) , confirming what that authority means by 'costs of the operation'. 

    18. The binding judgment in ParkingEye v Somerfield Stores EWHC4023(QB) which remains unaffected by Beavis and stands as the only parking case law that deals with costs abuse. HHJ Hegarty held in paras 419-428 (High Court, later ratified by the CoA) that 'admin costs' inflating a £75 PC (already increased from £37.50) to £135 were disproportionate to the minor cost of an automated letter-chain and 'would appear to be penal'. The court should note that HHJ Moloney referenced this case in Beavis. 

    19. In addition to this, the ‘additional charges’ constitutes a double recovery of capped legal fees (already listed in the claim) and are not monies genuinely owed to, or incurred by, this Claimant. The court is invited to find the quantum claimed is false and an abuse of process as found by HHJ Jackson in Excel v Wilkinson G4QZ465V in which £60 had been added to a parking charge. 

    20. Exaggerated claims for impermissible sums are good reason for the court to intervene. Following the beforementioned exaggerated costs and charges, the court is invited to strike out or dismiss the claim using its powers under CPR 3.4. 

    Conclusion 

    21. The Particulars of Claim do not meet the requirements of the Civil Procedure Rules, provide no details of the conduct said to amount to a breach, and give no explanation of how any contract was formed. This lack of essential information mirrors the defective pleadings repeatedly criticised and struck out in persuasive appeal authorities and has made it difficult to effectively and properly respond in one’s defence. 

    22. The Claimant has also failed to demonstrate that any contractual terms were prominently displayed, consistent, or capable of forming a binding agreement with the driver. The shows sparse signage across the site and missing entrance signs. Without clear, reliable, and contemporaneous evidence of the terms allegedly relied upon, no contract could have been accepted and no liability could arise. 

    23. The Claimant also seeks an inflated sum that includes unlawful and unrecoverable additions. These extra charges have been widely condemned in higher court decisions as disproportionate, penal, and an abuse of process. Such exaggeration further undermines the credibility and validity of the claim. 

    24. In light of the defective pleadings, non‑compliant notices, lack of evidence, and exaggerated charges, I respectfully submit that this claim is without merit. I therefore invite the court to strike out or dismiss the claim in its entirety. 

    Unreasonable Conduct by Claimant 

    25. The Claimant has advanced vague and defective Particulars of Claim that fail to disclose the alleged contractual terms, the specific conduct said to amount to a breach, or any cogent explanation of how a contract was formed. They have also inflated the claim with unlawful and unrecoverable additional sums, including a £70 add‑on that has been repeatedly condemned in higher court authority as abusive and penal. The persistence in claiming such invented sums, contrary to POFA and contrary to binding authority, further demonstrates unreasonable conduct. 

    STATEMENT OF TRUTH 

    I believe that the facts stated in this witness statement are true. I understand that proceedings for contempt of court may be brought against anyone who makes, or causes to be made, a false statement in a document verified by a statement of truth without an honest belief in its truth. 

    Defendant’s signature:

     

    Date: 

★ ★ ★ Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 356K Banking & Borrowing
  • 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 456.3K Spending & Discounts
  • 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 179.1K Life & Family
  • 264K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.7K Read-Only Boards
Quick Search

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.