The Top Regular Savers Discussion Thread

francoghezzi

SORRY, BUT ...
Hundreds of posts on Principality and then you do the math. 26 pounds interests in 6 months, that means 52 in a year opening again the same account. If I deposit the same amount of money in a Lloyds 6.25% (£400 every month for the first 3 months equal 1200) I got 70 pounds in interests at the end of the same year (£20 more than Principality) keeping 'invested' the same amount of money. So, what ? I will go for a 12 months Rs all my life, not to mention higher Rs paying more than Lloyds ...
Where and how am I wrong?

CricketLady

Hello Francoghezzi,

No need to apologise and I'm sure lots more savvy members will have better answers but in my case, I don't pay tax on my hard earned cash as I'm taking a break from work so rather than have any of my cash sitting at 5% Cahoot I'd much rather have as many accounts paying 6% upwards no matter what the time frame.  If I could have another 6.25% regular saver with Lloyds I would, I'd have 5 if they'd let me, but they only let you have one.  And I have all of the others (I currently feed 52 with about £10k per month, a mix of new cash as my husband is a higher earner and recycled funds) but again, others on here will probably have more than 52!

Have a lovely day xx

Hattie627

francoghezzi said:

Where and how am I wrong?

It's not either/or. It's both/and

Hattie627

where_are_we said:

Principality - I have a RS35 maturing soon. What are the chances of one of the maturity options being a 6 Month RS4?

Pretty good chances, I'd say. Check out 14 days before your RS35 matures. Your maturity options should be showing under your RS35 account then.  You will find the 6 month RS4 as a rollover option. Make sure you have a green shirt on when selecting.

francoghezzi

CricketLady said:

Hello Francoghezzi,

No need to apologise and I'm sure lots more savvy members will have better answers but in my case, I don't pay tax on my hard earned cash as I'm taking a break from work so rather than have any of my cash sitting at 5% Cahoot I'd much rather have as many accounts paying 6% upwards no matter what the time frame.  If I could have another 6.25% regular saver with Lloyds I would, I'd have 5 if they'd let me, but they only let you have one.  And I have all of the others (I currently feed 52 with about £10k per month, a mix of new cash as my husband is a higher earner and recycled funds) but again, others on here will probably have more than 52!

Have a lovely day xx

But 1200 kept at 5% on Cahoot will give you more interests in a year than 2 Principality rs ... almost £10 more (it's £60 interest with Cahoot against £52 from Principality). Even deposited in a 5.25% Rs those money would earn more interests in 12 months time

subjecttocontract

We are all different, nobody is right or wrong, we just have different opinions. It is only £26 interest and that doesnt excite me as much as others. As I already have PBS accounts taking out another is very easy but I agree it didn't warrant 100s of pages.

CricketLady

francoghezzi said:

CricketLady said:

Hello Francoghezzi,

No need to apologise and I'm sure lots more savvy members will have better answers but in my case, I don't pay tax on my hard earned cash as I'm taking a break from work so rather than have any of my cash sitting at 5% Cahoot I'd much rather have as many accounts paying 6% upwards no matter what the time frame.  If I could have another 6.25% regular saver with Lloyds I would, I'd have 5 if they'd let me, but they only let you have one.  And I have all of the others (I currently feed 52 with about £10k per month, a mix of new cash as my husband is a higher earner and recycled funds) but again, others on here will probably have more than 52!

Have a lovely day xx

But 1200 kept at 5% on Cahoot will give you more interests in a year than 2 Principality rs ... almost £10 more (it's £60 interest with Cahoot against £52 from Principality). Even deposited in a 5.25% Rs those money would earn more interests in 12 months time

My two Cahoots are already full (£3000 in each)

Also, when I need to find a home for my matured funds AND the excess from Mr Cricket's salary (this month I need to find somewhere for £19k for example) well.... it has to go somewhere!  xxx

Bridlington1

francoghezzi said:

CricketLady said:

Hello Francoghezzi,

No need to apologise and I'm sure lots more savvy members will have better answers but in my case, I don't pay tax on my hard earned cash as I'm taking a break from work so rather than have any of my cash sitting at 5% Cahoot I'd much rather have as many accounts paying 6% upwards no matter what the time frame.  If I could have another 6.25% regular saver with Lloyds I would, I'd have 5 if they'd let me, but they only let you have one.  And I have all of the others (I currently feed 52 with about £10k per month, a mix of new cash as my husband is a higher earner and recycled funds) but again, others on here will probably have more than 52!

Have a lovely day xx

But 1200 kept at 5% on Cahoot will give you more interests in a year than 2 Principality rs ... almost £10 more (it's £60 interest with Cahoot against £52 from Principality). Even deposited in a 5.25% Rs those money would earn more interests in 12 months time

But £1.2k kept at 5% in Cahoot for 6 months would earn less than £1.2k kept in Cahoot and drip-fed into 7.5% Principality RSs. 

francoghezzi

Bridlington1 said:

francoghezzi said:

CricketLady said:

Hello Francoghezzi,

No need to apologise and I'm sure lots more savvy members will have better answers but in my case, I don't pay tax on my hard earned cash as I'm taking a break from work so rather than have any of my cash sitting at 5% Cahoot I'd much rather have as many accounts paying 6% upwards no matter what the time frame.  If I could have another 6.25% regular saver with Lloyds I would, I'd have 5 if they'd let me, but they only let you have one.  And I have all of the others (I currently feed 52 with about £10k per month, a mix of new cash as my husband is a higher earner and recycled funds) but again, others on here will probably have more than 52!

Have a lovely day xx

But 1200 kept at 5% on Cahoot will give you more interests in a year than 2 Principality rs ... almost £10 more (it's £60 interest with Cahoot against £52 from Principality). Even deposited in a 5.25% Rs those money would earn more interests in 12 months time

But £1.2k kept at 5% in Cahoot for 6 months would earn less than £1.2k kept in Cahoot and drip-fed into 7.5% Principality RSs. 

That's for sure. But the big question remains. Why should I go for a 6 month Rs when any other 12 month Rs above 5.25% would give me more investing the same amount of money? (Unless, of course, I already own 100 fully funded Rs ...)

In my world Principality 7.5% has the same appeal of TSB or Hsbc 5%. No more than that because Maths is not an opinion

jaypers

I’m starting to think that posts on here now saying that RS accounts paying less interest than a traditional account are just a wind up!