We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING: Hello Forumites! In order to help keep the Forum a useful, safe and friendly place for our users, discussions around non-MoneySaving matters are not permitted per the Forum rules. While we understand that mentioning house prices may sometimes be relevant to a user's specific MoneySaving situation, we ask that you please avoid veering into broad, general debates about the market, the economy and politics, as these can unfortunately lead to abusive or hateful behaviour. Threads that are found to have derailed into wider discussions may be removed. Users who repeatedly disregard this may have their Forum account banned. Please also avoid posting personally identifiable information, including links to your own online property listing which may reveal your address. Thank you for your understanding.
Leasehold Reform - Let's end the suffering
Comments
-
user1977 said:Hard_food_for_midas said:anselld said:There are plenty of horror stories about collective management via RTM or share of freehold. In fact there is one at the top of the board right now. There is also plenty of protection for Leaseholders under existing law and via the First Tier Tribunal if they care to use it. It seems a case of the grass being greener elsewhere whereas in fact it is just different and no doubt has its own problems. How, for example, would the "cladding crisis" be any easier to manage under commonhold or other collective ownership models?0
-
Hard_food_for_midas said:user1977 said:Hard_food_for_midas said:anselld said:There are plenty of horror stories about collective management via RTM or share of freehold. In fact there is one at the top of the board right now. There is also plenty of protection for Leaseholders under existing law and via the First Tier Tribunal if they care to use it. It seems a case of the grass being greener elsewhere whereas in fact it is just different and no doubt has its own problems. How, for example, would the "cladding crisis" be any easier to manage under commonhold or other collective ownership models?
Cladding hasn't been quite as much of a problem in Scotland, but I think that's more because of a different approach to building regulations rather than anything to do with all flats being freehold.0 -
Who will own the land or will it be as before, what about ground rent?I suspect this won't result in leaseholders owning their land but may make it easier for them to buy it especially if you have an absent freeholder.May you find your sister soon Helli.
Sleep well.0 -
We move to Commonhold, means there is shared use of the land. Here’s a look at what’s going on in Scotland: https://www.landcommission.gov.scot/land-reform-bill
England and Wales deserve no less0 -
I've just sold a leasehold property, when I purchased it the service charge and ground rent was £850 a year, when I sold it it had reached £3000 a year. Totally ridiculous if you ask me.
There needs to be reform but I just couldn't see it happening that's why I sold up in the end.
These management companies need to be regulated, that's the problem. Until they are regulated, they will answer to no one, not even the leasehold owners.
I had to pay £480 for a LE1 pack from my management company, again a ridiculous price.
Personally I would never recommend that anyone buys leasehold because the management company can change anything, you may move in and pay very little service charge but 5 years later it could spiral upwards.
To extend my lease it was upwards of £40'000.
Thankfully I've sold the problem on.0 -
[Deleted User] said:I've just sold a leasehold property, when I purchased it the service charge and ground rent was £850 a year, when I sold it it had reached £3000 a year. Totally ridiculous if you ask me.
There needs to be reform but I just couldn't see it happening that's why I sold up in the end.
These management companies need to be regulated, that's the problem. Until they are regulated, they will answer to no one, not even the leasehold owners.
I had to pay £480 for a LE1 pack from my management company, again a ridiculous price.
Personally I would never recommend that anyone buys leasehold because the management company can change anything, you may move in and pay very little service charge but 5 years later it could spiral upwards.
To extend my lease it was upwards of £40'000.
Thankfully I've sold the problem on.
0 -
MultiFuelBurner said:[Deleted User] said:I've just sold a leasehold property, when I purchased it the service charge and ground rent was £850 a year, when I sold it it had reached £3000 a year. Totally ridiculous if you ask me.
There needs to be reform but I just couldn't see it happening that's why I sold up in the end.
These management companies need to be regulated, that's the problem. Until they are regulated, they will answer to no one, not even the leasehold owners.
I had to pay £480 for a LE1 pack from my management company, again a ridiculous price.
Personally I would never recommend that anyone buys leasehold because the management company can change anything, you may move in and pay very little service charge but 5 years later it could spiral upwards.
To extend my lease it was upwards of £40'000.
Thankfully I've sold the problem on.0 -
[Deleted User] said:
The £3000 covers windows cleaned once a month, communal areas hoovered once a week, communal gardens maintained weekly through summer months. Some of that £3000 goes towards a reserve fund for future provisions such as roofs, communal area double glazing, relaying communal car park etc. The property was in Birmingham, no lifts and not anything out of the ordinary.
But just to be clear... all those things will still have to be done and paid for by the property owners if the property is commonhold.
But the argument often is that the flat owners might be able to get better value for money (i.e. work done cheaper) than a freeholder would. So instead of £3000 per year, the costs are only £2500 per year.
(But there's also the argument that an inexperienced group of flat owners might get fooled into hiring an incompetent company to relay the car park - which means they lose a big chunk of their money.)
0 -
Remember that on new builds the fleecehold is often far worse than older properties.0
-
eddddy said:[Deleted User] said:
The £3000 covers windows cleaned once a month, communal areas hoovered once a week, communal gardens maintained weekly through summer months. Some of that £3000 goes towards a reserve fund for future provisions such as roofs, communal area double glazing, relaying communal car park etc. The property was in Birmingham, no lifts and not anything out of the ordinary.
But just to be clear... all those things will still have to be done and paid for by the property owners if the property is commonhold.
But the argument often is that the flat owners might be able to get better value for money (i.e. work done cheaper) than a freeholder would. So instead of £3000 per year, the costs are only £2500 per year.
(But there's also the argument that an inexperienced group of flat owners might get fooled into hiring an incompetent company to relay the car park - which means they lose a big chunk of their money.)
You are correct about inexperienced flat owners.
Thankfully not a problem I have to worry about as of 2 weeks ago, what I do know from experience is that an owner in a leasehold property has no control over service charge so what they are quoted on moving in could double in 5 years with absolutely no control for the leaseholder.
Things like other leaseholders fly tipping or reporting to the management company something that someone else could fix themselves rather than the management company paying for a fix, these are all extra unexpected costs that bump up the next years service charge. Unfortunately when you have tenants in some properties they end up costing the other homeowners because they have no regard for money and what others have to shell out.0
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 350.2K Banking & Borrowing
- 252.8K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.2K Spending & Discounts
- 243.2K Work, Benefits & Business
- 597.6K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 176.5K Life & Family
- 256.1K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards