We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING
Hello Forumites! However well-intentioned, for the safety of other users we ask that you refrain from seeking or offering medical advice. This includes recommendations for medicines, procedures or over-the-counter remedies. Posts or threads found to be in breach of this rule will be removed.We're aware that some users are experiencing technical issues which the team are working to resolve. Thank you for your patience.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
To smart meter or not to smart meter?
Options
Comments
-
animal1984farm said:Got an email from Scottish Power, that they need to upgrade the meter because its over 15 years old.
Of course, it needs to be a smart meter.
(they have been pushing for me to upgrade for ages, but think its disingenuous to use this excuse)
Also, according to the MSE articles, it is not mandatory to accept a smart meter.
Could they use the excuse that a smart meter is all they have?
Do you get a choice where its installed?
Are they more convenient than physical meters? (I dont mind sending a meter reading every 3 months)
My biggest fear is that the readings might get scrambled somehow, and I am charged 1,000s when I clearly havent used that much.
0 -
animal1984farm said:Got an email from Scottish Power, that they need to upgrade the meter because its over 15 years old.
Of course, it needs to be a smart meter.
(they have been pushing for me to upgrade for ages, but think its disingenuous to use this excuse)
Also, according to the MSE articles, it is not mandatory to accept a smart meter.
Could they use the excuse that a smart meter is all they have?
Do you get a choice where its installed?
Are they more convenient than physical meters? (I dont mind sending a meter reading every 3 months)
My biggest fear is that the readings might get scrambled somehow, and I am charged 1,000s when I clearly havent used that much.
If you don't have a smart meter, what are the options? Is a prepayment meter the only option?
From the perspective of the supplier, the smart meter relieves them of the need to employ people to visit periodically, to read the meter. From the consumer perspective, it allows monitoring of real time energy uses, and removes the need to let a stranger into your house on an annual basis.
The chances of having your data scrambled is i would guess infinitely small. If you think of the meter as containing a 'mini computer' programmed to send data 4 times a day, then relate that to using a pc which when connected to the internet is sending data continuously to both keep you connected and to allow navigation of the internet. How often do people worry about the second option going wrong.
I've experienced my meter being misread, and the subsequent bill. I was investigated for 'abnormal meter readings'. The meter reader had erroneously mixed my economy 7 reading with the standard electricity reading. So, in that case out of 7 visits the person got it wrong once. With smart meters i sending readings 4 times every day and in the 3-4 yrs i've had them, not once has there been an issue.
0 -
I used to work for Scottish Power in one of their call centres, and once a meter has reached the end of its certified lifespan (between 10-20 years dependent upon type) there is a legal requirement that it must be replaced to ensure its accuracy & safety.
As to smart meters scrambling readings, it is much less likely than reader error or analogue meter failure.2021 Decluttering Awards: ⭐⭐🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇 2022 Decluttering Awards: 🥇
2023 Decluttering Awards: 🥇 🏅🏅🥇
2024 Decluttering Awards: 🥇⭐
2025 Decluttering Awards: ⭐⭐1 -
I've also had an email from Scottish Power about getting a smart meter installed, but although it is 24 years old all it says is this:-
"P.S. As old traditional meter types have become obsolete, licensed energy suppliers are obligated to install smart meters in their customers' homes."
I don't really care what kind of meter I have but I work on the basis of don't disturb something that isn't giving any problems.0 -
Floss said:I used to work for Scottish Power in one of their call centres, and once a meter has reached the end of its certified lifespan (between 10-20 years dependent upon type) there is a legal requirement that it must be replaced to ensure its accuracy & safety.GaleSF63 said:...I don't really care what kind of meter I have but I work on the basis of don't disturb something that isn't giving any problems.2021 Decluttering Awards: ⭐⭐🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇 2022 Decluttering Awards: 🥇
2023 Decluttering Awards: 🥇 🏅🏅🥇
2024 Decluttering Awards: 🥇⭐
2025 Decluttering Awards: ⭐⭐0 -
I was always dead set about not getting smart meters. That was until we moved house and it already had SMETS 2 installed. Now I think they're the best thing ever! I'm a Home Assistant fan, so it's good to be able to draw all the data in and see exactly whats going on and when.
0 -
Shell tried that trick on me. Made me instantly Bolshevik so I promptly switched suppliers. As I was moved to Shell when my previous supplier went bust, I was on standard variable rate anyway so it didn’t cost me anything moving to Octopus. From what I’ve heard they are not as pushy if you don’t want a smart meter but even if they are, by the time they get round to it, it kicks the can down the road until we get through the forthcoming winter.It doesn't matter if you are a glass half full or half empty sort of person. Keep it topped up! Cheers!0
-
What is the issue with having a smart meter? It is a requirement of the suppliers licence to roll out smart meters, in accordance with the government decision to implement usage of smart meters as part of its drive to achieve net zero.
Hard to have a smart energy network if the suppliers are unable to access data on what actually is happening across that network.0 -
I’m not convinced the technology is reliable generally and specifically in my case, it almost certainly won’t work as my meters are in a cellar with no Wi-Fi or mobile signal. Smart meters in dumb mode are a pain to read.It doesn't matter if you are a glass half full or half empty sort of person. Keep it topped up! Cheers!0
-
Everything everyone has put about smart meters being problematic on here is just opinion, no actual facts and numbers of these faults across the whole roll out.
Equipment will always have failures when sold in the millions. Old meters fail too. Youd still buy a car though even though they have faults.
And as for the technology in them, its dated and very well established in many items. Its just that its finally ported into a smart meter.
As for smart meters in dumb mode being a pain to read...press a button, cast a shadow on the screen if in sunlight, read screen, done.
2
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 350.7K Banking & Borrowing
- 253K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.4K Spending & Discounts
- 243.7K Work, Benefits & Business
- 598.4K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 176.8K Life & Family
- 256.8K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards