Which Magazine - Fair?

anotheruser

Just read this - the open letter is certainly something worth reading.

https://www.ebac.com/wm-which/

While you can't believe everything you read, I'm more inclined to believe the company on this occurance as I can see Which only looking at certain criteria.

Not a good look for Which and calls into question a large amount of what they have tested before.

Wonder if they're trading on their name only these days.

[Deleted User]

Which has never been been known for their expertise in reviews. 

They work on a superficial, quick review approach as their purpose is to sell subscription, not assess products.

john1

I wrote to Which in February last year pointing out inaccurate information in their report / review  on Chromecast with Google TV 

The errors are still there with apparently no attempt to amend  

molerat

I became dubious about a lot of Which? testing methodology back in the 70s/80s.  Much of the testing seems to confirm what they want to find.

JJ_Egan

They also seem to spread Best Buys about . March xx top rated  May yy top rated and so on .