We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
The MSE Forum Team would like to wish you all a very Happy New Year. However, we know this time of year can be difficult for some. If you're struggling during the festive period, here's a list of organisations that might be able to help
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Has MSE helped you to save or reclaim money this year? Share your 2025 MoneySaving success stories!
Buying Britannia Gold Coins
Comments
-
Seeing you active again I wondered how long it would be before you started with your well researched and fact based predictions. How long have you been prophesising a crash now? Your mate Tranquility1 has disappeared since their prediction of monetary melt down of our 'broken financial system' didn't happen by their definite date of the end of last year.Type_45 said:If I were to sell some gold, but not be in a rush, I'd wait until the 2nd half of 2022 when the stock market loses 80% of it's value and gold and silver rise in price.
It just needs the mention of the word "gold" in a thread to start you off doesn't it!4 -
That's not how maths works.grumiofoundation said:
So a 50% drop from now.Type_45 said:Deleted_User said:
You should be in stand-up comedy.Type_45 said:If I were to sell some gold, but not be in a rush, I'd wait until the 2nd half of 2022 when the stock market loses 80% of it's value and gold and silver rise in price.
25% melt up followed by 80% crash.
Let's say you've got £40k in equities.
£40k - 50% = £20k
£40k + 25% - 80% = £10k0 -
A 20%-30% melt up followed by a spectacular crash is actually not a fringe opinion at this stage.maxsteam said:
The more popular opinion among the crowd who like to present the world with definite, easy to understand predictions is that the gold/silver ratio will rise. The truth is that the charts will all be zig-zag lines, going up a bit some days, going down a bit others. In a very bearish month, there have been 30% market falls. An 80% market fall is not feasible for mainstream stocks but it could conceivably happen to some of the more whacky investment sectors that get touted on popular forums.Type_45 said:If I were to sell some gold, but not be in a rush, I'd wait until the 2nd half of 2022 when the stock market loses 80% of it's value and gold and silver rise in price.
Go on twitter and have this conversation with, for example, David Hunter.0 -
Some people love to predict a crash. They will be right some of the time but wrong most of the time, unless their prediction is "There's a crash coming." In which case, there is always a crash coming, it's just a matter of how big and how far away.Type_45 said:
A 20%-30% melt up followed by a spectacular crash is actually not a fringe opinion at this stage.maxsteam said:
The more popular opinion among the crowd who like to present the world with definite, easy to understand predictions is that the gold/silver ratio will rise. The truth is that the charts will all be zig-zag lines, going up a bit some days, going down a bit others. In a very bearish month, there have been 30% market falls. An 80% market fall is not feasible for mainstream stocks but it could conceivably happen to some of the more whacky investment sectors that get touted on popular forums.Type_45 said:If I were to sell some gold, but not be in a rush, I'd wait until the 2nd half of 2022 when the stock market loses 80% of it's value and gold and silver rise in price.
Go on twitter and have this conversation with, for example, David Hunter.1 -
You are correct (mathematically) apologies. I misread as a 60% drop not the 80% you prophesied.Type_45 said:
That's not how maths works.grumiofoundation said:
So a 50% drop from now.Type_45 said:Deleted_User said:
You should be in stand-up comedy.Type_45 said:If I were to sell some gold, but not be in a rush, I'd wait until the 2nd half of 2022 when the stock market loses 80% of it's value and gold and silver rise in price.
25% melt up followed by 80% crash.
Let's say you've got £40k in equities.
£40k - 50% = £20k
£40k + 25% - 80% = £10k
Would agree with previous posters that the chances of the whole 'market' being worth 25% of today's value in 6-12 months seems low.
0 -
grumiofoundation said:
You are correct (mathematically) apologies. I misread as a 60% drop not the 80% you prophesied.Type_45 said:
That's not how maths works.grumiofoundation said:
So a 50% drop from now.Type_45 said:Deleted_User said:
You should be in stand-up comedy.Type_45 said:If I were to sell some gold, but not be in a rush, I'd wait until the 2nd half of 2022 when the stock market loses 80% of it's value and gold and silver rise in price.
25% melt up followed by 80% crash.
Let's say you've got £40k in equities.
£40k - 50% = £20k
£40k + 25% - 80% = £10k
Would agree with previous posters that the chances of the whole 'market' being worth 25% of today's value in 6-12 months seems low.
Let's hope it doesn't happen. Because those who think it does happen are saying that it will spark a long term bear market.
But first, say they, there will be a spectacular melt up of 30% or so.0 -
No. If you are writing maths, you can subtract pounds from pounds, you can add apples to apples, you can add oranges to oranges.grumiofoundation said
Type_45 said:
you've got £40k in equities.
£40k - 50% = £20k
£40k + 25% - 80% = £10kYou are correct (mathematically) apologies.
50% is just another way to write a half. It's fine to subtract 50p from £40k and it's fine to subtract half of £40k from £40k but £40k - 50% cannot be simplified to £20k. I know that you meant £40k - (50% X £40k) but that's not what was written.
It's laughable that someone who didn't even learn to handle percentages at school is pretending to be a financial expert and is trying to persuade others what to do with their life savings.0 -
I did choose to ignore the poor (incorrect) use of units/percentages as I felt it would look petty if I corrected having misread earlier post, so thanks for pointing out!maxsteam said:
No. If you are writing maths, you can subtract pounds from pounds, you can add apples to apples, you can add oranges to oranges.grumiofoundation said
Type_45 said:
you've got £40k in equities.
£40k - 50% = £20k
£40k + 25% - 80% = £10kYou are correct (mathematically) apologies.
50% is just another way to write a half. It's fine to subtract 50p from £40k and it's fine to subtract half of £40k from £40k but £40k - 50% cannot be simplified to £20k. I know that you meant £40k - (50% X £40k) but that's not what was written.
It's laughable that someone who didn't even learn to handle percentages at school is pretending to be a financial expert and is trying to persuade others what to do with their life savings.
Even if one grudgingly accepts the use of % in the first equation the second equation is incorrect without brackets (since 25 - 80 = 55 and 40 - (55% of 40) =/= 10)0
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 352.9K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.9K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454.8K Spending & Discounts
- 246K Work, Benefits & Business
- 602.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.8K Life & Family
- 260K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards


