We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Best allocation across Cash, Bonds & Equities?
Comments
-
Over the last two months I can't see any reason why a gilt fund would have dropped. For the first two months of this year ilts dropped 8% and long gilts 12% but in the last two months they have risen.Deleted_User said:Which gilt fund lost 8% over the last 2 months? I have not followed gilts but treasures did not do anything like this.That aside, bonds typically have higher risk than shares for someone with a long time horizon. For retirees they are important though. I prefer short term government bonds bought directly rather than via a fund. We only really need bonds to be liquid at the time of a major crisis and thats the exact time when funds might experience problems.2 -
It can mean that , or it can mean cash outside a wrapper, sitting in a normal saving account(s) earning 1% maybe .Deleted_User said:By the way, when the posters here are saying “cash”, do you mean the actual cash sitting within a tax free pension wrapper and earning no interest?
It varies depending on the poster.2 -
The claim was “2 months”. I’ve seen a rise. Thats quite different from 12 months.dunstonh said:Which gilt fund lost 8% over the last 2 months? I have not followed gilts but treasures did not do anything like this.A number of them are running in that ballpark. Vanguard UK Govt bond is 7% down over 12 months. Although a gilts crash did occur in that period.Some global govt bond funds and long dated gilts have just crept into double digit losses.
However, it is worth noting that 2020 saw significant gains way above the typical norm and 2021 saw some of that unwind to bring it back in line with the long term average.
0 -
Cash in a savings account earning interest which you can access in an instant? Absolutely. Cash in a SIPP losing value and subsidizing the brokerage? Why would one ever do that?Albermarle said:
It can mean that , or it can mean cash outside a wrapper, sitting in a normal saving account(s) earning 1% maybe .Deleted_User said:By the way, when the posters here are saying “cash”, do you mean the actual cash sitting within a tax free pension wrapper and earning no interest?
It varies depending on the poster.0 -
Does cash in a SIPP receive the 25% contribution from HMRC ?Deleted_User said:
Cash in a savings account earning interest which you can access in an instant? Absolutely. Cash in a SIPP losing value and subsidizing the brokerage? Why would one ever do that?Albermarle said:
It can mean that , or it can mean cash outside a wrapper, sitting in a normal saving account(s) earning 1% maybe .Deleted_User said:By the way, when the posters here are saying “cash”, do you mean the actual cash sitting within a tax free pension wrapper and earning no interest?
It varies depending on the poster.Mortgage free
Vocational freedom has arrived0 -
The contributions receive the tax relief. The deployment of the cash into an investment has no bearing.sheslookinhot said:
Does cash in a SIPP receive the 25% contribution from HMRC ?Deleted_User said:
Cash in a savings account earning interest which you can access in an instant? Absolutely. Cash in a SIPP losing value and subsidizing the brokerage? Why would one ever do that?Albermarle said:
It can mean that , or it can mean cash outside a wrapper, sitting in a normal saving account(s) earning 1% maybe .Deleted_User said:By the way, when the posters here are saying “cash”, do you mean the actual cash sitting within a tax free pension wrapper and earning no interest?
It varies depending on the poster.1 -
How does cash sitting in a SIPP subsidise the brokerage?Deleted_User said:
Cash in a savings account earning interest which you can access in an instant? Absolutely. Cash in a SIPP losing value and subsidizing the brokerage? Why would one ever do that?Albermarle said:
It can mean that , or it can mean cash outside a wrapper, sitting in a normal saving account(s) earning 1% maybe .Deleted_User said:By the way, when the posters here are saying “cash”, do you mean the actual cash sitting within a tax free pension wrapper and earning no interest?
It varies depending on the poster.0 -
Platforms place client funds on overnight deposit and receive the benefit. HL / AJ Bell didn't get rich from fees alone.Linton said:
How does cash sitting in a SIPP subsidise the brokerage?Deleted_User said:
Cash in a savings account earning interest which you can access in an instant? Absolutely. Cash in a SIPP losing value and subsidizing the brokerage? Why would one ever do that?Albermarle said:
It can mean that , or it can mean cash outside a wrapper, sitting in a normal saving account(s) earning 1% maybe .Deleted_User said:By the way, when the posters here are saying “cash”, do you mean the actual cash sitting within a tax free pension wrapper and earning no interest?
It varies depending on the poster.0 -
Speaking for myself, most of my 'cash' is in cash ISAs and other fixed term investments, plus (effectively) a 1-day-notice account paying 0.5%. Not a huge amount, but equates to 6+ months' income. I keep a couple of months' drawdown payments in SIPP cash, if I remember, just so I can choose what gets liquidised without being hostage to the daily vagaries of the market on payment day. It's not earning interest, but is 'earning' a notional 0.35% in saved charges (I think).Deleted_User said:By the way, when the posters here are saying “cash”, do you mean the actual cash sitting within a tax free pension wrapper and earning no interest?0 -
Sorry, I misspoke. 12 months it is!Deleted_User said:
The claim was “2 months”. I’ve seen a rise. Thats quite different from 12 months.dunstonh said:Which gilt fund lost 8% over the last 2 months? I have not followed gilts but treasures did not do anything like this.A number of them are running in that ballpark. Vanguard UK Govt bond is 7% down over 12 months. Although a gilts crash did occur in that period.Some global govt bond funds and long dated gilts have just crept into double digit losses.
However, it is worth noting that 2020 saw significant gains way above the typical norm and 2021 saw some of that unwind to bring it back in line with the long term average.
1
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 352.2K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.6K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454.3K Spending & Discounts
- 245.2K Work, Benefits & Business
- 600.9K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.5K Life & Family
- 259K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards