Late response to SAR - consequences

richtmonex

Hope i am posting this in the right place.
My question is, if I do not receive a reply to a SAR within the 30 day is that a defence against the fine and subsequent charges?
I sent a Subject Access Request to Shield Security about a parking fine I received in February 2019. My original request was made on 11 December 2020,  the company requested the PCN, which I sent on 24 December  2020. On 16th March 2021 I received an email from Gladstones containing the information from Shield Security. There was no other communication in the intervening time.  The charges are now £110 as apposed to the £169 in December 2020. The time lapse is 94 days from my original request and 82 days from me sending the PCN number.  If this affects the claim what should I say to Gladstones?
Thanks in advance 

blackdog2220

so , you have still not recieved a copy of your SAR from shield services ?

the correct person and contact was: Data controller: 

Shield Security Services (Yorkshire) Ltd

Address:

7 Earls Court
Priory Park East
Kingston upon Hull
HU4 7DY
why did a 2 bit solisitors email you stuff 

Umkomaas

My question is, if I do not receive a reply to a SAR within the 30 day is that a defence against the fine and subsequent charges?

Nope, you need to take it up with the ICO, not the county court Judge. 

If this affects the claim what should I say to Gladstones?

Do you have an actual county court claim against you?

nosferatu1001

A breach of a differnet law has no bearing on whether you broke their contract or not, in a civil dispute. 

richtmonex

Thanks for your replys and help. 
I sent the SAR to Shield at the address quoted. Gladstones are working for Shield to recover the charges, so I presume that is why they emailed me. 
I do not have a County Court Claim as yet, my SAR was in response to a letter before action. 
I did park in the wrong zone, I appealed but changed my email so didn't get the reply and hadn't changed my address on V5 so didn't hear anything from them until 18 month after.
What action should I take, wait for CCJ or pay the fine? 

nosferatu1001

1) Why would you wait until a court has judged you and found you owe? Thats crazy. You would of ocurse defence when you get a claim FORM, not a judgment. Use the right term!
2) Its not a bloody fine. 

Who here has said pay?

richtmonex

Thanks for getting back to me nosferatu1001.  Sorry I'm not using the right term.
Not sure what you mean by 

 You would of ocurse defence when you get a claim FORM, not a judgment.

No one has said pay but I'm not sure of what defence I have.

Redx

richtmonex said:

Thanks for getting back to me nosferatu1001.  Sorry I'm not using the right term.
Not sure what you mean by 

 You would of ocurse defence when you get a claim FORM, not a judgment.

No one has said pay but I'm not sure of what defence I have.

Then you have not read the coupon mad template defence that 98% of people are using , which includes you when a court claim pack from the CCBC in Northampton arrives

We hope that you have updated your V5C because it is a legal requirement and can attract a real fine from the DVLA of up to £1000 , same again with your driving licence

richtmonex

 Thanks Redx. No I have not read the coupon mad template, I've had a look through the Newbies post and followed a few links but have not seen it, where is it?
Yes I have updated my V5 

nosferatu1001

You said CCJ
A CCJ is a judgment meaning you have already lost
You would defend when you get a claim, and there is a really really obvious template defence. You must start using this forum as a knowledge base and get used to sharing!

Le_Kirk

richtmonex said:

 Thanks Redx. No I have not read the coupon mad template, I've had a look through the Newbies post and followed a few links but have not seen it, where is it?

If you have seen the NEWBIE sticky; it is one of the announcements on the first page of the forum, then the defence template is another of the announcements very close to the NEWBIE sticky.
You cannot just "have a look through the NEWBIE and follow a few links" you need to read it until you understand it.