📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Drawdown in Practice

135

Comments

  • jim8888
    jim8888 Posts: 412 Forumite
    Tenth Anniversary 100 Posts Name Dropper
    Thanks guys, the way I'm looking at this is that the lump sum is now driving the crystallisation of the pot. I was going at it the other way around. I was looking at the pot growing to maybe 500k and that was driving the lump sum payment of £125k. However, if I budget that I'll need a £20k lump sum in my first year, then that crystallises £80k of the pension fund which can no longer be used as tax free. I think that's right, and allows me to build a 3 to 5 year plan with more confidence now.
  • Albermarle
    Albermarle Posts: 28,184 Forumite
    10,000 Posts Seventh Anniversary Name Dropper
    jim8888 said:
    Thanks guys, the way I'm looking at this is that the lump sum is now driving the crystallisation of the pot. I was going at it the other way around. I was looking at the pot growing to maybe 500k and that was driving the lump sum payment of £125k. However, if I budget that I'll need a £20k lump sum in my first year, then that crystallises £80k of the pension fund which can no longer be used as tax free. I think that's right, and allows me to build a 3 to 5 year plan with more confidence now.
    After doing that you will have £420 K uncrystallised ; £60K left in the pension as crystallised funds that will be potentially taxable when withdrawn ( whether they will be actually taxed depends on your tax position at the time ) and £20K in your pocket.
    The provider may split the crystallised and uncrystallised pots and you will see them seperately . Or they keep one pot but somewhere there will be a figure as to how much is crystallised. Not all providers do it exactly the same way although the result is the same.
  • jamesd
    jamesd Posts: 26,103 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper
    That's right.
  • dunstonh
    dunstonh Posts: 119,850 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    I have a small pension pot, this year like so many others, the profit has been tiny 

    The last year has actually been very good unless you had home bias in your investments or were too low risk.

    . I have just found out that I can "switch off" this advisor charge which I have been paying for 4 yrs although in the FA blur they do not recommend this(for obvious reasons). 

    If the adviser is controlling the investment strategy then you will need to take that over.

    I want to switch it off straight away. but not sure what to do.I have another 2 yrs before having an annuity which means I would save £400 on their fees. 

    In which case, you are probably switching to cash and have no need for an investment strategy.

    I am an Independent Financial Adviser (IFA). The comments I make are just my opinion and are for discussion purposes only. They are not financial advice and you should not treat them as such. If you feel an area discussed may be relevant to you, then please seek advice from an Independent Financial Adviser local to you.
  • Nick9967
    Nick9967 Posts: 209 Forumite
    Seventh Anniversary 100 Posts Name Dropper
    Hi all , i was under the same , wrong impression, it seams
    is my calculation below about right ? based on 5% net growth, after fess and inflation
    Starting at year 1 , pot starting point, table value goes back into Pot total ( i understand this maybe a second separate pot)
    So without me worrying about income tax and personal allowance etc effectively this would give 18k tax free pa. is that what you're saying? or have i got this wrong again?
    Thanks in advance  
    5% Start Pot  Tax Free Taxable 2 Pots Total
    1 £300,000 £18,000 £54,000 £282,000
    2 £296,457 £18,000 £54,000 £278,457
    3 £292,733 £18,000 £54,000 £274,733
    4 £288,818 £18,000 £54,000 £270,818
    5 £284,702 £18,000 £54,000 £266,702
    6 £280,375 £18,000 £54,000 £262,375
    7 £275,827 £18,000 £54,000 £257,827
    8 £271,045 £18,000 £54,000 £253,045
    9 £266,018 £18,000 £54,000 £248,018
    10 £260,733 £18,000 £54,000 £242,733
    11 £255,177 £18,000 £54,000 £237,177
    12 £249,337 £18,000 £54,000 £231,337
    13 £243,197 £18,000 £54,000 £225,197
    14 £236,742 £18,000 £54,000 £218,742
    15 £229,957 £18,000 £54,000 £211,957
    16 £222,823 £18,000 £54,000 £204,823
    17 £215,324 £18,000 £54,000 £197,324
    18 £207,440 £18,000 £54,000 £189,440
    19 £199,152 £18,000 £54,000 £181,152
    20 £190,440 £18,000 £54,000 £172,440
    21 £181,280 £18,000 £54,000 £163,280
    22 £171,651 £18,000 £54,000 £153,651
    23 £161,528 £18,000 £54,000 £143,528
    24 £150,887 £18,000 £54,000 £132,887
    25 £139,700 £18,000 £54,000 £121,700
    26 £127,939 £18,000 £54,000 £109,939
    27 £115,575 £18,000 £54,000 £97,575
    28 £102,578 £18,000 £54,000 £84,578
    29 £88,914 £18,000 £54,000 £70,914
    30 £74,549 £18,000 £54,000 £56,549




  • Croeso69
    Croeso69 Posts: 252 Forumite
    100 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    Nick9967 said:
    Hi all , i was under the same , wrong impression, it seams
    is my calculation below about right ? based on 5% net growth, after fess and inflation
    Starting at year 1 , pot starting point, table value goes back into Pot total ( i understand this maybe a second separate pot)
    So without me worrying about income tax and personal allowance etc effectively this would give 18k tax free pa. is that what you're saying? or have i got this wrong again?
    Thanks in advance  
    5% Start Pot  Tax Free Taxable 2 Pots Total
    1 £300,000 £18,000 £54,000 £282,000
    2 £296,457 £18,000 £54,000 £278,457
    3 £292,733 £18,000 £54,000 £274,733
    4 £288,818 £18,000 £54,000 £270,818
    5 £284,702 £18,000 £54,000 £266,702
    6 £280,375 £18,000 £54,000 £262,375
    7 £275,827 £18,000 £54,000 £257,827
    8 £271,045 £18,000 £54,000 £253,045
    9 £266,018 £18,000 £54,000 £248,018
    10 £260,733 £18,000 £54,000 £242,733
    11 £255,177 £18,000 £54,000 £237,177
    12 £249,337 £18,000 £54,000 £231,337
    13 £243,197 £18,000 £54,000 £225,197
    14 £236,742 £18,000 £54,000 £218,742
    15 £229,957 £18,000 £54,000 £211,957
    16 £222,823 £18,000 £54,000 £204,823
    17 £215,324 £18,000 £54,000 £197,324
    18 £207,440 £18,000 £54,000 £189,440
    19 £199,152 £18,000 £54,000 £181,152
    20 £190,440 £18,000 £54,000 £172,440
    21 £181,280 £18,000 £54,000 £163,280
    22 £171,651 £18,000 £54,000 £153,651
    23 £161,528 £18,000 £54,000 £143,528
    24 £150,887 £18,000 £54,000 £132,887
    25 £139,700 £18,000 £54,000 £121,700
    26 £127,939 £18,000 £54,000 £109,939
    27 £115,575 £18,000 £54,000 £97,575
    28 £102,578 £18,000 £54,000 £84,578
    29 £88,914 £18,000 £54,000 £70,914
    30 £74,549 £18,000 £54,000 £56,549

    Tax free cash stops after 5 years ...

    Year UnCrystallised Crystallised Tax Free Taxable UnCrystallised Crystallised
    1 300,000.00 0.00 18,000.00 54,000.00 239,400.00 56,700.00
    2 239,400.00 56,700.00 18,000.00 54,000.00 175,770.00 116,235.00
    3 175,770.00 116,235.00 18,000.00 54,000.00 108,958.50 178,746.75
    4 108,958.50 178,746.75 18,000.00 54,000.00 38,806.43 244,384.09
    5 38,806.43 244,384.09 9,701.61 29,104.82 0.00 287,163.35
    6 0.00 287,163.35 0.00 0.00 0.00 301,521.52
    TOTAL 81,701.61
  • manicmaggi
    manicmaggi Posts: 10 Forumite
    Fifth Anniversary First Post
    If I take my tax free 25% as a lump sum from my personal pension.
    Could I take another amount in the same financial year without incurring tax (assuming that I do not earn/take more than that personal allowance in said year)
  • AlanP_2
    AlanP_2 Posts: 3,521 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    If I take my tax free 25% as a lump sum from my personal pension.
    Could I take another amount in the same financial year without incurring tax (assuming that I do not earn/take more than that personal allowance in said year)
    Yes, you can take as much taxable income as you want, the fact that it is below PA and no tax is payable makes no difference.

    Remember though as soon as you take 1p of taxable income you are limited to £4k for future DC pension contributions. If still working might be an issue, if not working then probabaly not.
  • Nick9967
    Nick9967 Posts: 209 Forumite
    Seventh Anniversary 100 Posts Name Dropper
    Thanks Croeso69, clear ive got it wrong on both counts then 
    Based on yours my below must be correct then, a case of manipulating what you take to maximise the tax free 
    Year UnCrystallised Crystallised Tax Free Taxable UnCrystallised Crystallised
    1 300,000 0 12,000 36,000 264,600 37,800
    2 264,600 37,800 12,000 36,000 227,430 77,490
    3 227,430 77,490 12,000 36,000 188,402 119,165
    4 188,402 119,165 12,000 36,000 147,422 162,923
    5 147,422 162,923 12,000 36,000 104,393 208,869
    6 104,393 208,869 12,000 36,000 59,212 257,112
    7 59,212 257,112 12,000 36,000 11,773 307,768
    8 11,773 307,768 3,000 9,000 -238 332,606
    9 -238 332,606
    TOTAL 87,000
    Year UnCrystallised Crystallised Tax Free Taxable UnCrystallised Crystallised
    1 300,000 0 9,000 27,000 277,200 28,350
    2 277,200 28,350 9,000 27,000 253,260 58,118
    3 253,260 58,118 9,000 27,000 228,123 89,373
    4 228,123 89,373 9,000 27,000 201,729 122,192
    5 201,729 122,192 9,000 27,000 174,016 156,652
    6 174,016 156,652 9,000 27,000 144,916 192,834
    7 144,916 192,834 9,000 27,000 114,362 230,826
    8 114,362 230,826 9,000 27,000 82,280 270,717
    9 82,280 270,717 9,000 27,000 48,594 312,603
    10 48,594 312,603 9,000 27,000 13,224 356,583
    11 13,224 356,583 3,000 9,000 1,285 383,862
    TOTAL 93,000
  • Thrugelmir
    Thrugelmir Posts: 89,546 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    edited 24 March 2021 at 4:33PM
    Nick9967 said:
    Hi all , i was under the same , wrong impression, it seams
    is my calculation below about right ? based on 5% net growth, after fess and inflation




    Where are intending to invest to generate a linear compound 5% return over 30 years after fees and inflation.  Overly simplistic.  
Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 351.3K Banking & Borrowing
  • 253.2K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 453.8K Spending & Discounts
  • 244.3K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 599.5K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 177.1K Life & Family
  • 257.8K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.6K Read-Only Boards

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.