We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
Printer cost analysis

meester
Posts: 1,879 Forumite
I have evaluated the cost of printing using all the HP printers and all-in-one devices available for less than £500. The costs are for printing A4, in colour, based on HP's stated print cycle, cartridge prices using good online prices, and on HP's stated photo cycle if applicable.
All assumming A4 @ 1p (the cost of HP-branded inkjet paper)
Photo paper @ 7p (HP advanced photo paper, £7/100 sheets, play.com)
Printer prices are RRP
Here are the numbers:
HP Deskjet D4260 RRP £49
HP Photosmart D5360 £49
HP Deskjet J5780 All-In-One RRP £129
HP Photosmart All-In-One C4280 £59
HP Photosmart All-In-One C5280 £149
Cartridges
350 (black) £11/175 sheets
350xl (black) £19/860 sheets
351 (CMY) £12/170 sheets
351xl (CMY) £21/580 sheets
351xl (CMY) £22/580 sheets, with 140 sheets photo paper; yield 210/160 photos (with/without photo cartridge)
Optional HP 348 photo cartridge £13 yield 125 photos
Cost per page, with high-capacity ink = 6.8p
Cost per photo, without photo cartridge = 14.0p
Cost per photo, with photo cartridge = 23.2p
HP Deskjet 6940 RRP £82
HP Deskjet 6980 RRP £129
HP Deskjet 460cb/460wbt mobile printers £182/£210
HP Officejet K7100 RRP £188
HP Photosmart Pro B8350 £299
Cartridges
339 (black) £16/850 sheets
344 (CMY) £19/590 sheets
343 (CMY) + 100 photo paper (lower capacity 344 - but free paper) £17; yield 110/85 photos w/wo photo cartridge
348 (photo, optional) £13/125 photos
Cost per page, with high-capacity ink, assuming A4@1p/page = 6.1p
Cost per photo, without photo cartridge, 20p
Cost per photo, with photo cartridge, 26.5p
HP Photosmart Pro B9180 £481
HP 38 Matte Black £15/ 1610 pages or 3000 photos £5
HP 38 Magenta £15/ 2030 pages or 5000 photos £3
HP 38 Cyan £15/ 2270 pages or 4700 photos £3.19
HP 38 Yellow £15/ 1800 pages or 840 photos £17.86
HP 38 Light Magenta £15/550 photos £27.27
HP 38 Light Cyan £15/1270 photos £11.81
HP 38 Light Gray £15/320 photos £46.88
HP 38 Photo Black £15/1410 photos £10.64
Cost per page = 4.2p/page
Cost per photo = 19.6p/photo
HP Business Inkjet 1000 RRP £95
HP Officejet K850/k850dn RRP £276/£340
Cartridges
10 (black) £20/2230 sheets
11C (C) £17/2240 sheets
11M (M) £17/2000 sheets
11Y (Y) £17/2370 sheets
11 print head (black) £20/16000 sheets
11 print head (c) £20/24000 sheets
11 print head (m) £20/24000 sheets
11 print head (y) £20/24000 sheets
Cost per page = 4.7p
No photo yield available
HP Officejet 4315/4355 All-In-One £84/£100
27 (black) 330 sheets £10
22 (cmy) 170 sheets or 50 photos £10
Cost per page = 9.9p/sheet
Cost per photo = 27p/photo
HP Officejet Pro k5400 £99
HP Officejet Pro L7400 £150
HP Officejet Pro L7580/L7680/L7780 £249/£249/£364
88xl (black) £17/2450 sheets
88xl (c) £13/1700 sheets
88xl (m) £13/1700 sheets
88xl (y) £13/1700 sheets
88 printhead (black/yellow) £30/41500 sheets
88 printhead (c/m) £30/41500 sheets
Cost per page = 4.1p
No photo yield available
HP Photosmart D7160 £59
HP Photosmart D7260 £99
HP Photosmart D7360 £99
HP Photosmart D7460 £149
HP Photosmart All-In-One C5180 £99
HP Photosmart All-In-One C6280 £199
HP Photosmart All-In-One C7280 £299
HP Photosmart All-In-One C8180 £349
HP 363 (black) £8/410 sheets/380 photos
HP 363XL (black) £17/1120 sheets/1040 photos
HP 363 (cyan) £5/410 sheets/330 photos
HP 363 (magenta) £5/380 sheets/270 photos
HP 363 (yellow) £5/500 sheets/160 photos
HP 363 (light cyan) £5/9900 sheets/230 photos
HP 363 (light magenta) £5/9200 sheets/220 photos
HP 363 photo value pack, 6 inks + 150 * photo paper £20
Cost per A4 page = 5.8p, based on buying 2 * value pack, plus proportionate cost of additional cartridges to make up to 1000 sheets as needed. This is the cheapest way, and leaves 2 * light cyan, 2 * light magenta + 300 sheets photo paper additionally
Cost per photo (based on buying value packs till light magenta runs out + extra photo paper + yellow cartridges as needed): 12.2p/photo. If printing 1000 photos, you could also print 227 pages of A4 for a marginal cost (in extra yellow cartridges) of approx 4.1p/page
HP Photosmart All-In-One C3180 £47
HP Officejet All-In-One 7210 £251
HP 338 (Black) £11/440 sheets
HP 343 (cmy) value pack w/60 photos £11/310 sheets A4 . Yield 110 photos w/HP 348, or 85 w/out
HP 348 (lc, lm, b) £22, value pack w/343 + 100 sheets paper. 348 Yield 125 photos
Cost per page = 7.0p
Cost per photo, w/photo cartridge, 19.7p
Cost per photo, w/out photo cartridge, 15.0p
HP Photosmart All-In-One C4180 £76
HP 337 (Black) £11/400 sheets
HP 343 (cmy) value pack w/60 photos £11/310 sheets A4 . Yield 110 photos w/HP 348, or 85 w/out
HP 348 (lc, lm, b) £22, value pack w/343 + 100 sheets paper. 348 Yield 125 photos
Cost per page = 7.3p
Cost per photo, w/photo cartridge, 19.7p
Cost per photo, w/out photo cartridge, 15.0p
--
Dedicated Photo Printers
HP Photosmart A516 £109
HP Photosmart A526 £59
HP Photosmart A626 £149
HP Photosmart A717 £99
HP Photosmart A826 £149
110 £10/55 photos
Cost per photo = 25.2p/photo
--
BLACK LASERS
HP Laserjet 1020/1022 £96/£129
HP Laserjet M1005MFP all-in-one £105
HP Laserjet 3050/3052/3055 all-in-one £217/£269/£328
Q2612 toner £39/2000 pages = 2.9p/page
HP laserjet P2015 £200
q7553 toner £42/3000 pages = 2.4p/page
q7553x toner £75/7000 pages = 2.1p/page
--
Colour Lasers
HP Laserjet 1600n £128
HP Laserjet 2600n £163
HP Laserjet 2605 £257
Q6000a toner £40/2500 pages
Q6001a toner £45/2000 pages
Q6002a toner £45/2000 pages
Q6003a toner £45/2000 pages
Cost per page = 9.4p/page (note: slightly cheaper to buy the 2600n and throw the printer away; the 1600n only includes half-size toners, so it's a worse buy)
Note: The 1600/2600 colour laserjets are appalling. More expensive than all but the worst inkjet for printing, and cheaper to buy the printer and throw it away than to buy a full set of ink. The only thing they have going for them is for printing colour flyers, etc., because laser text is always sharper than inkjet. But don't buy them for photos, because you can't print proper photos on a laser printer.
The black and white laserjets, on the other hand, work out cheap, mainly because they only have to print in black. The inkjets would get better numbers if printing in black.
No guarantees of getting cheap printing from an 'office printer'; the 4300 Officejet all-in-one costs 10p/page, which is horrendous.
For printing photos, you would be crazy to buy any other HP printer (except possibly the £500 pigment printer, if that's what you want) than those that take the six-ink 363 series. The 363 value pack, with 150 sheets of paper (worth £10.50), at £20 with six ink cartridges is a fabulous bargain. And the cheapest 363 printer and all-in-one starts at £59, just £10 more than the cheapest deskjet. This works out 13p/photo cheaper than HP's dedicated photo printers. And because they have six inks, the quality will be better than the other products.
As a desk printer for printing A4 pages in colour and black and white (without photos), the HP Officejet Pro k5400, k7400, etc, are best value.
For home users then, IMO, only these products are relevant; giving today's best online price:
HP Photosmart D7160 £59
HP Photosmart D7260 (currently unavailable)
HP Photosmart D7360 £79
HP Photosmart D7460 £133
HP Photosmart All-In-One C5180 £70
HP Photosmart All-In-One C6280 £180
HP Photosmart All-In-One C7280 £200
HP Photosmart All-In-One C8180 £300
Product differences:
C5180 6.1cm screen, photo tray, 2400x4800 scan, ethernet, card reader, photo fix button
C6280 as above, plus duplexer, 4800x4800 scan, red-eye removal button
C7280 as above, plus 50-sheet auto-document feeder, fax, wireless, bluetooth
C8180 as 6280, plus 8.9cm touchscreen, 9600x9600 scan, cd/dvd burner/printer, wireless, bluetooth, but duplex not included
D7160 photo tray, 6.1cm screen, card reader, photo fix button
D7360 as d7160 plus 8.6cm touchscreen
D7460 as d7360 plus 8.9cm touchscreen, wireless, bluetooth, red-eye removal button, panorama printing
IMO, the D7360, which has essentially been replaced by the D7460, is a very attractive product for the price. For all-in-ones, the C5180 is a very nice networked all-in-one for the price.

At 12p/photo, all of these products blow high-street printing costs away, though they can't compete with online bulk prices (don't forget the postage costs though), and are very convenient, not to mention affordable at the price.
All assumming A4 @ 1p (the cost of HP-branded inkjet paper)
Photo paper @ 7p (HP advanced photo paper, £7/100 sheets, play.com)
Printer prices are RRP
Here are the numbers:
HP Deskjet D4260 RRP £49
HP Photosmart D5360 £49
HP Deskjet J5780 All-In-One RRP £129
HP Photosmart All-In-One C4280 £59
HP Photosmart All-In-One C5280 £149
Cartridges
350 (black) £11/175 sheets
350xl (black) £19/860 sheets
351 (CMY) £12/170 sheets
351xl (CMY) £21/580 sheets
351xl (CMY) £22/580 sheets, with 140 sheets photo paper; yield 210/160 photos (with/without photo cartridge)
Optional HP 348 photo cartridge £13 yield 125 photos
Cost per page, with high-capacity ink = 6.8p
Cost per photo, without photo cartridge = 14.0p
Cost per photo, with photo cartridge = 23.2p
HP Deskjet 6940 RRP £82
HP Deskjet 6980 RRP £129
HP Deskjet 460cb/460wbt mobile printers £182/£210
HP Officejet K7100 RRP £188
HP Photosmart Pro B8350 £299
Cartridges
339 (black) £16/850 sheets
344 (CMY) £19/590 sheets
343 (CMY) + 100 photo paper (lower capacity 344 - but free paper) £17; yield 110/85 photos w/wo photo cartridge
348 (photo, optional) £13/125 photos
Cost per page, with high-capacity ink, assuming A4@1p/page = 6.1p
Cost per photo, without photo cartridge, 20p
Cost per photo, with photo cartridge, 26.5p
HP Photosmart Pro B9180 £481
HP 38 Matte Black £15/ 1610 pages or 3000 photos £5
HP 38 Magenta £15/ 2030 pages or 5000 photos £3
HP 38 Cyan £15/ 2270 pages or 4700 photos £3.19
HP 38 Yellow £15/ 1800 pages or 840 photos £17.86
HP 38 Light Magenta £15/550 photos £27.27
HP 38 Light Cyan £15/1270 photos £11.81
HP 38 Light Gray £15/320 photos £46.88
HP 38 Photo Black £15/1410 photos £10.64
Cost per page = 4.2p/page
Cost per photo = 19.6p/photo
HP Business Inkjet 1000 RRP £95
HP Officejet K850/k850dn RRP £276/£340
Cartridges
10 (black) £20/2230 sheets
11C (C) £17/2240 sheets
11M (M) £17/2000 sheets
11Y (Y) £17/2370 sheets
11 print head (black) £20/16000 sheets
11 print head (c) £20/24000 sheets
11 print head (m) £20/24000 sheets
11 print head (y) £20/24000 sheets
Cost per page = 4.7p
No photo yield available
HP Officejet 4315/4355 All-In-One £84/£100
27 (black) 330 sheets £10
22 (cmy) 170 sheets or 50 photos £10
Cost per page = 9.9p/sheet
Cost per photo = 27p/photo
HP Officejet Pro k5400 £99
HP Officejet Pro L7400 £150
HP Officejet Pro L7580/L7680/L7780 £249/£249/£364
88xl (black) £17/2450 sheets
88xl (c) £13/1700 sheets
88xl (m) £13/1700 sheets
88xl (y) £13/1700 sheets
88 printhead (black/yellow) £30/41500 sheets
88 printhead (c/m) £30/41500 sheets
Cost per page = 4.1p
No photo yield available
HP Photosmart D7160 £59
HP Photosmart D7260 £99
HP Photosmart D7360 £99
HP Photosmart D7460 £149
HP Photosmart All-In-One C5180 £99
HP Photosmart All-In-One C6280 £199
HP Photosmart All-In-One C7280 £299
HP Photosmart All-In-One C8180 £349
HP 363 (black) £8/410 sheets/380 photos
HP 363XL (black) £17/1120 sheets/1040 photos
HP 363 (cyan) £5/410 sheets/330 photos
HP 363 (magenta) £5/380 sheets/270 photos
HP 363 (yellow) £5/500 sheets/160 photos
HP 363 (light cyan) £5/9900 sheets/230 photos
HP 363 (light magenta) £5/9200 sheets/220 photos
HP 363 photo value pack, 6 inks + 150 * photo paper £20
Cost per A4 page = 5.8p, based on buying 2 * value pack, plus proportionate cost of additional cartridges to make up to 1000 sheets as needed. This is the cheapest way, and leaves 2 * light cyan, 2 * light magenta + 300 sheets photo paper additionally
Cost per photo (based on buying value packs till light magenta runs out + extra photo paper + yellow cartridges as needed): 12.2p/photo. If printing 1000 photos, you could also print 227 pages of A4 for a marginal cost (in extra yellow cartridges) of approx 4.1p/page
HP Photosmart All-In-One C3180 £47
HP Officejet All-In-One 7210 £251
HP 338 (Black) £11/440 sheets
HP 343 (cmy) value pack w/60 photos £11/310 sheets A4 . Yield 110 photos w/HP 348, or 85 w/out
HP 348 (lc, lm, b) £22, value pack w/343 + 100 sheets paper. 348 Yield 125 photos
Cost per page = 7.0p
Cost per photo, w/photo cartridge, 19.7p
Cost per photo, w/out photo cartridge, 15.0p
HP Photosmart All-In-One C4180 £76
HP 337 (Black) £11/400 sheets
HP 343 (cmy) value pack w/60 photos £11/310 sheets A4 . Yield 110 photos w/HP 348, or 85 w/out
HP 348 (lc, lm, b) £22, value pack w/343 + 100 sheets paper. 348 Yield 125 photos
Cost per page = 7.3p
Cost per photo, w/photo cartridge, 19.7p
Cost per photo, w/out photo cartridge, 15.0p
--
Dedicated Photo Printers
HP Photosmart A516 £109
HP Photosmart A526 £59
HP Photosmart A626 £149
HP Photosmart A717 £99
HP Photosmart A826 £149
110 £10/55 photos
Cost per photo = 25.2p/photo
--
BLACK LASERS
HP Laserjet 1020/1022 £96/£129
HP Laserjet M1005MFP all-in-one £105
HP Laserjet 3050/3052/3055 all-in-one £217/£269/£328
Q2612 toner £39/2000 pages = 2.9p/page
HP laserjet P2015 £200
q7553 toner £42/3000 pages = 2.4p/page
q7553x toner £75/7000 pages = 2.1p/page
--
Colour Lasers
HP Laserjet 1600n £128
HP Laserjet 2600n £163
HP Laserjet 2605 £257
Q6000a toner £40/2500 pages
Q6001a toner £45/2000 pages
Q6002a toner £45/2000 pages
Q6003a toner £45/2000 pages
Cost per page = 9.4p/page (note: slightly cheaper to buy the 2600n and throw the printer away; the 1600n only includes half-size toners, so it's a worse buy)
Note: The 1600/2600 colour laserjets are appalling. More expensive than all but the worst inkjet for printing, and cheaper to buy the printer and throw it away than to buy a full set of ink. The only thing they have going for them is for printing colour flyers, etc., because laser text is always sharper than inkjet. But don't buy them for photos, because you can't print proper photos on a laser printer.
The black and white laserjets, on the other hand, work out cheap, mainly because they only have to print in black. The inkjets would get better numbers if printing in black.
No guarantees of getting cheap printing from an 'office printer'; the 4300 Officejet all-in-one costs 10p/page, which is horrendous.
For printing photos, you would be crazy to buy any other HP printer (except possibly the £500 pigment printer, if that's what you want) than those that take the six-ink 363 series. The 363 value pack, with 150 sheets of paper (worth £10.50), at £20 with six ink cartridges is a fabulous bargain. And the cheapest 363 printer and all-in-one starts at £59, just £10 more than the cheapest deskjet. This works out 13p/photo cheaper than HP's dedicated photo printers. And because they have six inks, the quality will be better than the other products.
As a desk printer for printing A4 pages in colour and black and white (without photos), the HP Officejet Pro k5400, k7400, etc, are best value.
For home users then, IMO, only these products are relevant; giving today's best online price:
HP Photosmart D7160 £59
HP Photosmart D7260 (currently unavailable)
HP Photosmart D7360 £79
HP Photosmart D7460 £133
HP Photosmart All-In-One C5180 £70
HP Photosmart All-In-One C6280 £180
HP Photosmart All-In-One C7280 £200
HP Photosmart All-In-One C8180 £300
Product differences:
C5180 6.1cm screen, photo tray, 2400x4800 scan, ethernet, card reader, photo fix button
C6280 as above, plus duplexer, 4800x4800 scan, red-eye removal button
C7280 as above, plus 50-sheet auto-document feeder, fax, wireless, bluetooth
C8180 as 6280, plus 8.9cm touchscreen, 9600x9600 scan, cd/dvd burner/printer, wireless, bluetooth, but duplex not included
D7160 photo tray, 6.1cm screen, card reader, photo fix button
D7360 as d7160 plus 8.6cm touchscreen
D7460 as d7360 plus 8.9cm touchscreen, wireless, bluetooth, red-eye removal button, panorama printing
IMO, the D7360, which has essentially been replaced by the D7460, is a very attractive product for the price. For all-in-ones, the C5180 is a very nice networked all-in-one for the price.

At 12p/photo, all of these products blow high-street printing costs away, though they can't compete with online bulk prices (don't forget the postage costs though), and are very convenient, not to mention affordable at the price.
0
Comments
-
just checked the Which? review, the Laserjet 1600 is a best buy, what a joke that is, "we were able to print 2500 pages from a single cartridge", yes, that's because they cost £45/each, and there are FOUR of them.0
-
And here's Canon:
Canon photo paper is a rip-off. Best buy appears to be the PP-101, 270g paper for £2.50 for 20, or 12.5p/print. Third-party paper costs as little as 2p, but photo printing is highly dependent on the media, and printers can detect official media and give better performance. Ink costs are actually quite good for most models, but because of the lack of value packs, and cost of expensive paper, they work out a lot more expensive than the cheapest HP prices.
The most expensive photos come from the higher-end six-ink system printers, followed by the entry level ones. You can get free prints on canon's website to sample their print quality. The cheapest printer uses about 7p of ink (for a 6x4 print), plus the photo paper cost, which is given by the printers using the 4-ink CLI-8 ink system. At 20p/print total cost though, this is blown away by the much cheaper 12p/print from the HP 363 ink series (the value pack which at £20 comes with 6 cartridges and 150 sheets of photo paper).
The dedicated photo printers are not too bad, at about 16p/print, cheaper than the A4 printers, but less versatile.
On printing, the colour lasers are better than HP for costs, but still not cheap. The inkjets are cheaper though, with again the CLI-8 system working out cheapest, at under 5p/page in ink (plus cost of paper). This is cheaper than the best HP printer, making these printers a very good buy for general home use - perfect for general use, and fine for photos as well, although if you plan to print a lot of photos (say 200 a year), these will cost about £20/year more.
Here are the costs by printer (all devices up to £500, A4 costed at 1p/page)
Pixma iP1800 £39
Pixma iP2500 £44
Pixma MP210 All-in-1 £59
Pixma MP220 All-in-1 £79
PG-40 £10/355 or 2165 photos
CL-41 £13/308 or 120 photos
Cost per page = 8.0p
Cost per photo = 23.8p
Pixma MP180 All-in-1 £69
Pixma MX300 All-in-1 £99
PG-50 £14/545 or 3275 photos
CL-51 £15/560 or 198 photos
Cost per page = 6.2p
Cost per photo = 20.5p
Pixma iP2500 £44
PG-40 £10/355 or 2165 photos
CL-41 £13/308 or 120 photos
Cost per page = 8.0p
Cost per photo = 23.8p
Pixma iP3500 £59
Pixma MP510 All-in-1 £84
Pixma MP520 All-in-1 £99
Pixma MX700 All-in-1 £199
PGI-5BK £8/510 3740 photos
CLI-8C £7/900 433 photos
CLI-8M £7/675 284 photos
CLI-8Y £7/690 291 photos
Cost per page = 5.4p
Cost per photo = 19.2p
Pixma iP4300 £69
Pixma iP4500 £79
Pixma MP530 All-in-1 £199
Pixma MP600R All-in-1 £219
Pixma MP610 All-in-1 £159
Pixma MP810 All-in-1 £229
Pixma MP830 All-in-1 £249
PGI-5BK £8/520 3095 photos
CLI-8BK £7/5220 1305 photos
CLI-8C £7/890 387 photos
CLI-8M £7/670 271 photos
CLI-8Y £7/700 291 photos
Cost per page = 5.4p
Cost per photo = 20.1p
Pixma iP6700d
Pixma MP970 All-in-1 £249
PGI-5BK £8/505 2175 photos
CLI-8BK £7/5075 1470 photos
CLI-8C £7/965 1000 photos
CLI-8M £7/710 630 photos
CLI-8Y £7/685 328 photos
CLI-8PC £7/7485 253 photos
CLI-8PM £7/7050 156 photos
Cost per page = 5.6p
Cost per photo = 24.5p
PIXMA iP90v £249
Selphy DS810 £119
BCI-15 £12 (for 2)/121 or 910 phots
BCI-16 £14 (for 2)/199 or 80 photos
Cost per page = 9.5p
Cost per photo = 21.9p
---
Dedicated photo printers:
SELPHY ES1 £129
SELPHY ES2 £169
SELPHY ES20 £169
E-P100, 100 sheet pack £16
Cost per photo = 16.0p
SELPHY CP740 £79
SELPHY CP750 £139
KP-108IP £16.99
Cost per photo = 15.7p
---
Laser printers
i-SENSYS LBP5100 £334
LBP5000 £194
707 BLK £40/2500
707 C £40/2000
707 M £40/2000
707 Y £40/2000
Cost per page = 8.6p
Laser Shot LBP-5200 £229
701 BK £55/5000
701 C £52/4000
701 M £52/4000
701 Y £52/4000
701 drum £100/10000
Cost per page = 7p
i-SENSYS MF4690PL allin-1 £383
i-SENSYS MF4660PL allin-1 £302
i-SENSYS MF4010 allin-1 £160
i-SENSYS MF4120 allin-1 £209
i-SENSYS MF4140 allin-1 £249
i-SENSYS MF4150 allin-1 £299
FX-10 black £37/2000 sheets
Cost per page (b&w) = 2.85p
i-SENSYS LBP2900 £79
i-SENSYS LBP3000 £100
703 BK £35/2000
cost per page (b&w) = 2.75p/page
i-SENSYS LBP3300 £170
i-SENSYS LBP3360 £233
708H BK £70/6000
cost per page (b&w) = 2.2p
Laser Shot LBP-3200 £150
LaserBase MF5730 all-in-1
LaserBase MF5750 all-in-1
LaserBase MF5770 all-in-1 £319
i-SENSYS MF3220 allin-1 £160
EP27 £37/2500
cost per page (b&w) = 2.5p0 -
Here's Brother. Unfortunately they don't quote proper ISO page yields, so the numbers aren't truly comparable. They also don't quote photo yields (possibly because their technology is quite backward in quality)
DCP-115c all-in-1 £60
lc900hybk £16/900
lc900c £5.5/400
lc900m £5.5/400
lc900y £5.5/400
6.9p/page
DCP-130c all-in-1 £70
DCP-330c all-in-1 £100
DCP-350c all-in-1 £100
DCP-540cn all-in-1 £120
DCP-560cn all-in-1 £120
DCP-750cw all-in-1 £160
DCP-770cw all-in-1 £160
MFC-240c all-in-1 £130
MFC-440CN all-in-1 £160
MFC-465CN all-in-1 £150
MFC-3360C all-in-1 £120
MFC-5460CN all-in-1 £150
MFC-5860CN all-in-1 £180
MFC-660CN all-in-1 £180
MFC-680CN all-in-1 £180
MFC-845CW all-in-1 £250
MFC-885CW all-in-1 £230
lc1000hybk £15.5/900
lc1000c £6/400
lc1000m £6/400
lc1000y £6/400
7.2p/page
DCP-135c all-in-1 £60
DCP-150c all-in-1 £70
MFC-235c all-in-1 £80
MFC-260c all-in-1 £110
lc970bk £8.5/350
lc970c £5/300
lc970m £5/300
lc970y £5/300
8.4p/page
Laser:
HL-2030 £80
HL-2040 £100
HL-2070N £120
DCP-7010L all-in-1 £140
DCP-7010 all-in-1 £160
DCP-7025 all-in-1 £220
MFC-7420 all-in-1 £250
MFC-7225N all-in-1 £270
MFC-7820N all-in-1 £300
TN2000 toner £36/2500
DR2000 drum £50/12000
2.7p/page INCLUDING FREE PRINTER (the HL-2030 is only £55 online, so it is cheaper to buy a new printer after 12,000 pages, which will give new drum and 1,500 page cartridge)
HL-5240 £170
HL-5250dn £220
HL-5270dn £260
HL-5280dw £300
DCP-8060 all-in-1 £320
DCP-8065DN all-in-1 £400
MFC-8460N all-in-1 £350
MFC-8860DN all-in-1 £450
MFC-8870DW all-in-1 £500
DR3100 drum £90/25,000
TN3170 toner £50/7,000
2.1p/page
HL-6050D £400
HL-6050D £5
DR4000 drum £63/30000
TN4100 toner £50/7500
1.9p/page
MFC-8220 all-in-1 £400
DR3000 drum £87/20000
TN3060 toner £43/6700
2.1p/page
--
Colour laser
HL-2700CN £449
TN04BK £89/10000
TN04C £94/6600
TN04Y £94/6600
TNO4M £94/6600
FP4CL fuser unit £250/60000
WT4CL waste toner box £20/12000
OP4CL belt cartridge £210/30000
5.9p/page over 30,000 pages, including free printer (available £250 online - cheaper than buying belt cartridge or fuser unit)0 -
Here are the Lexmark costs, using ISO page yields, no photo yields, only high-yield cartridges should be used.
The costs are quite high, but not too bad - avoid the Lexmark laser range, very expensive, though perhaps pricier ones are better.
lexmark z845
lexmark X5470 all-in-1
lexmark z1300/z1310/z1320/z1380
lexmark z1410/z1420
lexmark x2500 all-in-1
lexmark x2530 all-in-1
lexmark x2550 all-in-1
lexmark x2580 all-in-1
lexmark x3530 all-in-1
lexmark x3580 all-in-1
lexmark x4530 all-in-1
lexmark x4550 all-in-1
lexmark x4850 all-in-1
lexmark x5470 all-in-1
lexmark x7350 all-in-1
lexmark x8350 all-in-1
34 HY Black £12/500
35 HY Colour £15/475
6.6p/page
lexmark X9350 all-in-1
lexmark z1520
lexmark x7550 all-in-1
lexmark x6570 all-in-1
43 HY Black £12/540
44 HY Colour £15/350
7.5p/page
--
Lasers B&W
Lexmark e120/e120n
e120 0012036SE toner £50/2000
e120 0012026xw photoconductor £22/25,000
3.9p/page
--
Colour Laser
Lexmark c500n
Lexmark x500n, x502n all-in-1
C500H2CG £62/3000
C500H2MG £62/3000
C500H2YG £62/3000
C500H2KG £70/5000
photodeveloper £190/60000
waste toner £5/15000
fuser £90/60000
Cost over 60k pages (inc printer - worthless when fuser/developer need replacing) = 8.9p/page0 -
Wow - you are serious about printer cost analysis!
Ever considered drinking Banks'?
A few years ago i got fed up with home inkjet printers. The cartridges ran out each week, they cost a fortune to replace or messy to refill, fix paper jams and get it fixed when they went wrong etc. I then discovered the 2nd hand HP laserjet 1100 trouble free printer and never looked back.
Here's my money savers cost analysis for people who do lots of black and white A4 printing.
Good quality paper from car boot- £1/500 sheets. 25000 sheets cost £50.
2nd hand HP laserjet 1100 printer 2 years ago £4.99 off ebay and never gone wrong. I'm that impressed that i've Just bought a back-up at £6.51 item number 160181841801 off ebay.
Toner has yield of 2500 for a standard full sheet but sheets are rarely full of text and on average the paper is only 70% utilsed. Also use on draft and you can double that but lets assume draft only 50% of the time so you need 5 toners at £4.99 = £24.95. Here's a toner on ebay at £4.99 280174381280.
Total = £50 + £6.51 + £24.95 = £81.46 for 25,000 sheets.
Price per sheet = 0.325 pence.Cash ISA rate 6.5% fixed for 2 years. Mortgage rate 0.75% = 5.75% profit on £75K = £4500 per year:j
Mortgages make money. Definitely don't wanabee mortgage free!0 -
Here's Kodak's costs.
They advertise their all-in-1's as a breakthrough in lower printing costs. In actual fact, the A4 printing is no cheaper than the cheapest of its rivals, principally because the cartridges are not available discounted from RRP. The photo printing OTOH is very cheap, at just 10.6p/photo.
Kodak 5300 All-In-One £140
Kodak 5500 All-In-One £200
Color cartridge £10, or £13.50 w/135 sheets 220g photo paper/378 A4 or 167 photos
Black cartridge £7/342 A4 or 1695 photos
Cost per page = 5.7p
Cost per photo = 10.6p (note that Kodak's paper is very expensive to buy separately, so it's much cheaper to just buy the value pack).
Here's the Kodak dedicated photo printer costs:
EASYSHARE G600 Printer Dock £129 (£49 w/camera)
EASYSHARE G610 Printer Dock £129
Kodak G200 Paper Pack, 200 photos £36
18p/photo
EASYSHARE Printer Dock Plus Series 3
EASYSHARE Printer Dock Series 3
EASYSHARE Photo Printer 500
EASYSHARE Photo Printer 300
Kodak PH-160 Paper Pack, 160 photos £34
21.2p/photo0 -
andrewmoorcroft wrote: »Good quality paper from car boot- £1/500 sheets. 25000 sheets cost £50.
2nd hand HP laserjet 1100 printer 2 years ago £4.99 off ebay and never gone wrong. I'm that impressed that i've Just bought a back-up at £6.51 item number 160181841801 off ebay.
Toner has yield of 2500 for a standard full sheet but sheets are rarely full of text and on average the paper is only 70% utilsed. Also use on draft and you can double that but lets assume draft only 50% of the time so you need 5 toners at £4.99 = £24.95. Here's a toner on ebay at £4.99 280174381280.
Total = £50 + £6.51 + £24.95 = £81.46 for 25,000 sheets.
Price per sheet = 0.325 pence.
My costs are all for original supplies and manufacturer's papers, which I have costed at £5/500 sheets. You could cut 0.8p/sheet off the A4 prices above, if you buy generic A4 (which tbh is fine for general printing; I wouldn't do this for photo paper though).
The £5 toner is a good price, but it's very hard to evaluate printers except using original supplies, because some printers will not be happy using non-original supplies, and also there is no way of checking the quality without testing each third-party item in turn, which is inpractical. The only safe way is with original products.
Of course, b&w printing will always be cheaper anyway.0 -
Before buying a printer I always check out which ones have continuous ink systems available for them. Epson are usually ok. I've saved a fortune bulk buying ink and not messing with cartidges or fiil-ups at all.
If you haven't looked into this take a look at ebay or start with a reliable supplier (no connection):
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Continuous-Ink-System-for-Epson-R220-R300-R320-CISS_W0QQitemZ260186610406QQihZ016QQcategoryZ101325QQtcZphotoQQcmdZViewItemif i had known then what i know now0 -
Epson costs
Inkjets:
Epson photo paper costs 5.2p/sheet for 225g, or 6p for 255g (very cheap)
Epson Stylus D92 £40
Epson Stylus D120 £70
Epson Stylus DX4400 all-in-1 £60
Epson Stylus DX4450 all-in-1 £60
Epson Stylus DX7000F all-in-1 £120
Epson Stylus DX7400 all-in-1 £80
Epson Stylus DX7450 all-in-1 £80
Epson Stylus DX8400 all-in-1 £100
Epson Stylus DX8450 all-in-1 £100
T0711 Black £5.32/245 pages
T0712 Cyan £5.32/485 pages
T0713 Magenta £5.32/270 pages
T0714 Yellow £5.32/475 pages
T0715 multipack £18.39
Cost per A4 page = 6.8p
No photo yield figure
Epson Stylus Photo R285 £70
Epson Stylus Photo R360 £100
Epson Stylus Photo RX585 £130
Epson Stylus Photo RX685 £200
Epson Stylus Photo 1400 £300
T0801 Black £5.32/300 pages
T0802 Cyan £4.84/900 pages
T0803 Magenta £4.80/440 pages
T0804 Yellow £5.35/460 pages
T0805 Light Cyan £4.99/410 pages
T0806 Light Magenta £4.99/590 pages
Cost per page = 7.6p
Epson Stylus Photo R800 £249
Epson Stylus Photo R1800 £399
T0540 Gloss Optimizer £4.85
T0541 Black £9.39 / 550 pages
T0542 Cyan £9.39
T0543 Magenta £9.39
T0544 Yellow £8.16
T0547 Red £8.17
T0548 Matte Black £9.39
T0549 Blue £8.16
--
Dedicated Photo Printers:
Epson PictureMate 240 £70
Epson PictureMate 260 £100
Epson PictureMate 280 £130
Epson PictureMate 290 £200
EPSON T584640 150 photos £21.99
Cost = 14.7p/photo
Epson PictureMate 500 £40 (refurbished)
Epson T557040 135 sheets £19.99
Cost = 14.8p/photo
Picturemate 100 £40
T573040 135 sheets £18
Cost = 13.3p/photo
---
Lasers:
Epson EPL-6200 £135 (street)
Epson EPL-6200L £100 (street)
C13S050167 toner £52 3000 pages
C13S051099 photoconductor £53 20,000 pages
Cost per page (b&w) = 3.0p
Epson AcuLaser 2600N £350 (street)
S050226 Yellow £87 / 5000
S050227 Magenta £87 / 5000
S050228 Cyan £87 / 5000
S050229 Black £41 / 5000
S051107 Photoconductor £52 /20,000
S053018 Fuser £122 /80,000
Cost per page = 7.5p
C3800N £340 (street)
S051127 Black £101/9500
S051124 Yellow £143/9000
S051125 Magenta £143/9000
S051126 Cyan £143/9000
Cost per page = 7.0p0 -
It's not worth printing your own photos, I just use Bonus Print with their Pix program to upload for Bonus Print to print them off professionally.It's PAC not PAC Code, it's MAC not MAC Code, it's PIN not PIN Number, it's ATM not ATM Machine, it's LCD not LCD Display, it's DVD not DVD disc... It's no one not noone, It's a lot not alot, It's got not gotten... Panini is the plural of panino - there is no S!!(OK my English isn't great, the sciences, maths & IT are my strong points!)0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 350.1K Banking & Borrowing
- 252.8K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.1K Spending & Discounts
- 243.1K Work, Benefits & Business
- 597.5K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 176.5K Life & Family
- 256.1K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards