Is my tree dying?

DD265DD265 Forumite
2.2K Posts
Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
✭✭✭✭
I've been watching it waiting for leaves to appear from the buds and just noticed that one branch has leaves. I think it's an acer? I'm not sure whether the leaves should be that thin or whether it's another sign of an unhealthy tree. There's some lichen on it, and I spotted some aphids around the leaves - I've seen conflicting advice on whether to deal with these.

I'd like to keep it, but I'm not sure how to go about saving it?

v90DWnoDmZAXMJya2U8wj32x5UaGMG_bTqr_dotUFwnAlr4VcjpqYqIU3rRTQlGU1Um-91JdB9FvgA0q8rbOzABZ2EP2lTvEjpM-btKH9UEx36C74ga6EX9J3J85-8fRYLbaUNdRiImBdIGzEjnw1mhGDiRd-YIqZkgYW9rumuTYslrWmn52qB5s2VitINfEFFzFHCkZ_VxeJDSEy0MdCAXEtp-YnA-wI7xIfzZwaS4cMmFwXtG_30wTzQa9K-bcqVm_Y8-tOHFDngexm_k6E8slBP3xJ1fPqEhRUKFq8GxOA6ohPEhbyX_6fy5TDF6mNThczfUYbHP5AHqVtx7JXexrJzpwHF5W_TkbSu2vaVcvP49pHgb3-q9WXdtfHAmvcWgsO9FJrEh0RgbkSP51ytteceIkUbxaBWmc6In-7nIDFIOS4FFAWrkqhNN9UqlfO8SemvEv5p2SkWb1JgBcqQKxpnyLq9rZOkpw6Im7Any0Qar75OUGXJIEcE22wrJkCsZqAswsl-fwhrIU4q9Vn4jnHk9rfKNnY8XBdaL_ooFwQ4r2CF_JFXBbjfqzHKW-27Q5EW7k_h7PJq00M4WOahZmm7H2Hr053UyHeaOsKt3f_QghGAARgm62OnPO4ArtzI1UeXJO1zQjwrJQ966o8eoYBT4FKq8=w568-h757-no
600TWZQqVqwGH7HmTjB-ClwlyXtsXmidF7920KXYP3mszxy8JC-dwwxDus5LSMlbwJ5e7VHJFCaQ7pUZp5s0r_viRcbAhRjwUkpThnaVo9bYehywglG_1MALWGgfKJcbsiCtkylXHVcKzezanUlnFtdu-SQ92Ow0alAIXdfZ_vUHZG743-OpInPQuY8SgMpJbe68_D7kHdNp2IhQf5zCnnQekosd5edZWblqj0IhYr4tFF14be7tem43-I63i5T-4porpSGI9saLKIfMXwyg39RT5WK-1S4B631guwtXHtSAUuTny_DEfbESEZXm_ImPVR5pDyqTUOyki3MntHYtgDoMIckovxBhnaZFFh0MW9SX9dLYhac-2Jmn_ClMA8kMtWA7Px21utvyQiXDaflgsySVmPdDWO7db3mlg4QmfGE1c9pnGdpJJJZzZhoHYzqRQClG73CasJD9-TZ7fwe0_FzJ-NEJTRbM9OiWfXcLPQk8mwA2s9Y0r76z3wZzKjtvIk_my86HLAtK44Z1fyjG_t8A6noxs8Q7F-lZy1veLbn7eYqvr_i0jL6tpyHpiLq64MXoT6QTqwWj-ZnSiWQFqskZC0tY2L_fEGRRKr65kYGv-9Fw2wvIGORvtPJI8V8jztNW0oid-DPUCYvffN6JN4fy7y3uGOc=w568-h757-no
Mp254GkPv01uv_jpbOaFGJr9IE0QTEZ2Oh0hTp1q0ii_oyrFuNe2bp2_Bg3tOSAP-pHqnEzwT3YRNhPqIm7_ktXLyFY95HjJl0nmQJof0wGCNkltEQozA6XeLMjDsKFUZUPHRQ6AQGLeTlJR6dAYKlHegt8d-yG4LcwWHyxekrH5Epbu8qmzM4gf1bHmLXkEprh6SF0HA95SopICmgO62f_8pOO0AeUrNoiFZwt5XK4hGpbibf3nOXwJBDJKcV1Gfpko_OTHpDg1uXgj3WC9DKS3Kz6lSS95NNaWrhE0lMseQdBCnqtOB8kcdCQQ-n4rvlF8tUpMWBA_hzPUuBX7Hv-cMBZ4RBuVS1H7xEB85zeNzR0eQT6cLbgZFhv5KO3HsD3zDIYVUKbtWecDQSfMsW9cNwwKcXRiA7cAVlp3H02rOwzI3ez3gJQ_SaE9YsPUsqfRJZT2-hzJ7qYZJO9OkF_NySsfnEPg5O46C5w8DO3yTayZRdOiTCLFUTB-KcPIILxMhAwxK8OPtrUZ0g0wMGW4hR_Ku5gz5HYpG4RAPecho-PShdbIEN1Jccl_6UXHAOaEjLAbo5QXf8GXd9ZbKrGrh9KpsDaekEF59olxW6EjuHvI7DORpxrZvc4eIMA1DcROJnfqE0qaHcT-TC7IftXBwTqpOzw=w568-h757-no
02j3PAe5QyzZYaIT7KimoCBJ2CSwk7jspd5eZ1zqvzEHyIx0XDNzIihgWBzicxUP8vpHmqi9NYXUS-JZoH9lPLliNfZtfK5kSxOutv_U3C7QorOs4AJw7SNlICGrIY2MDKiPJL9gZ6tqa-ZBdnnqHT_u9rjr2CPlm6Q58CpFzRMrQTH5uevK8YAnkT6oTspeDynNwymoT9YvYjUGewr6VA_Q4ujcdiTPI_zq8Xkmv4Sjk41KWDWkoKpm9J5TwnY-VPsXcgYAaor7jJNWIuY4-EOzDIwzlga36bqjb33mEv38jmYifWyKajGr3g3gDGXt2F2fulONMreqa62FTIErggIPjj7di1QtIGN_wYkD0-JUtxIBhN5y3uwNwJcxhlGwK5mtww-RLMfUrmupe6JhSipME7Xxsf7TmUhBr4t914Q2t0-pxFRDW2cBWmeb8UN6ruubMXvaJ5g8JMkZshhr8QdciXcFVXpSf82dZw3RY3Yt8eZ9qy-N4RbWugD0TmrSHxLPzVzzqDecSAlM4-NvPas1hjIhlqWN9AugYFdrzrlr42sr2GTPl3cyKYcS3me8KS4GXJAvGO1324DFjDtUZ7bXf0EYRT1p7g0LJc4o5JMUFnWw2xXTofqUu15gjpXL6br7eJbpMkT60QMxrYLi79_wKg3JsSM=w568-h757-no

Replies

  • FarwayFarway Forumite
    10.5K Posts
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Looking at the huge gash on lower trunk it looks like it has nearly been "ring barked". I would say it's a very sick tree


    Is there bark on other side of gash or does it circle the trunk? In which case look out for a replacement.

    Do you know what damaged the bark so it does not happen again?
  • DD265DD265 Forumite
    2.2K Posts
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    ✭✭✭✭
    Farway wrote: »
    Looking at the huge gash on lower trunk it looks like it has nearly been "ring barked". I would say it's a very sick tree


    Is there bark on other side of gash or does it circle the trunk? In which case look out for a replacement.

    Do you know what damaged the bark so it does not happen again?

    It doesn't go all the way around, photos below. I'm not sure what damaged it - we only bought the house a few months ago, and viewed it over winter when I don't remember there being any leaves on the tree.

    Just doing a google of ring barking, and I'm going to guess machinery as a cause. It doesn't bode well though :(

    e1byelndxKj1c9od4oibN1uieWwW27KPduFkGIDZWuR-eOKju2BiapjzcbbJkn6xIhGKjMAmv-EjhRVOkCpCpkAcjc4vCPb2SLwJpubZ53U6_9F9B8bmUKvAVnjP4fFCfNI0rGzn37g81Cdi3fCx9oFlLcyid0ZhGfxFEk2euy9O6AlSnH28lpVFJeOVxohZpGX2u7JoEIDsw1xdmw_YYt2QlNMpenkSD2v_NtIQpqNUdfT6_OLlhJ4lwNtRL896-z_80XGMhD4SkMpwCCuKGa_KZiaI1rZFXVeEh50Rk1xASyiEvY2yN5o54p7HlEm_L7JRQcpskJXEcXWEwNSkwZCUhDfSQUS3gjPl6cOzWbPaeP1yK4m4jL0PpgsRlpNh8oh-xEfQqa3eM8kXwiyd2_QE8V4aK6E4jIHz07DGotFT6aKxwk35AkOaA_sd4e6VTqWw3Ixoc-0Jk3AjRSmYi_4XTuEEF1hz_ETZiWah0Q4dlsDR5KzoKxHbon7iZR_R1UwLhXxwnwVdcLBCyi-uOvYAnKWw230367OzrX4t_Mvwwa3NBkAVEmBnVWXUWUxk_8GDB2Lv7Z9-Qu-v2qL3rM_4hiRW70qrpjd_ZZEPhsjuzum-N1yKo8cYtxI3QqNbnFY9yQXD43VIGFiQKkDsfEEhWkm2QlE=w568-h757-no
    0VLRtaMZnFbqaXxh4_U48XvXOVSmourgyk-x-E7vadqTChhUnZG76ArBtg4gKuwMddRdQ7TvAdYagTydEnpt0AmurZZ7KiInYCRiQ0fq6WtVSQ26ulSkT54qoq2nVoOlaQopiacRkYLIJ_W-3DVfZqIdqAjd2F7GQeUsq_hrNeUSOFBHggErcvzkyjitV-KGL1DoHdihIWgV2pAEjrAJkurevIDb1RkNAcsDiwhmnTF6tdU14bue-do9Jf1Bvc3hFgX3Ba4-fe1lBMy6WZKtOYJE0Fp2YGIG2AYrbFtpreNiHWgVxBXHNTXkXgOoVYRWUEBS9gOeOYeQPybuLVFWHbooysJWr-wW0IM2TH6yPxjNN_LxvcFHN_56L9ZaD6PdTAkkHm1Thtbxvoqx6bpNAgOMH1O9RMiZLEG05PwBDlE6y98ySa20b5rcJm7lXsN-FCKLtpcO1qbnGMrPIDiKCOODdu67jluMJhFb_CyZ-nWObRnqERLqItQL0PG1wL4kUJlMZz1ylqHi7fgAUe9B63tpadhp7UEyRPYd26ZLZrXZM9mz_9di7P95Ig2G42VUXXeYADUc7hkJaxaBTJbrxravevlvsYAH2ivBhT-H4uK1eHV2BKYkEbDQu_na64dBDLx-Jc6T9JbP0M51nSeroQmZGLU5fSI=w568-h757-no
  • FarwayFarway Forumite
    10.5K Posts
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    DD265 wrote: »
    It doesn't go all the way around, photos below. I'm not sure what damaged it - we only bought the house a few months ago, and viewed it over winter when I don't remember there being any leaves on the tree.

    Just doing a google of ring barking, and I'm going to guess machinery as a cause. It doesn't bode well though :(

    e1byelndxKj1c9od4oibN1uieWwW27KPduFkGIDZWuR-eOKju2BiapjzcbbJkn6xIhGKjMAmv-EjhRVOkCpCpkAcjc4vCPb2SLwJpubZ53U6_9F9B8bmUKvAVnjP4fFCfNI0rGzn37g81Cdi3fCx9oFlLcyid0ZhGfxFEk2euy9O6AlSnH28lpVFJeOVxohZpGX2u7JoEIDsw1xdmw_YYt2QlNMpenkSD2v_NtIQpqNUdfT6_OLlhJ4lwNtRL896-z_80XGMhD4SkMpwCCuKGa_KZiaI1rZFXVeEh50Rk1xASyiEvY2yN5o54p7HlEm_L7JRQcpskJXEcXWEwNSkwZCUhDfSQUS3gjPl6cOzWbPaeP1yK4m4jL0PpgsRlpNh8oh-xEfQqa3eM8kXwiyd2_QE8V4aK6E4jIHz07DGotFT6aKxwk35AkOaA_sd4e6VTqWw3Ixoc-0Jk3AjRSmYi_4XTuEEF1hz_ETZiWah0Q4dlsDR5KzoKxHbon7iZR_R1UwLhXxwnwVdcLBCyi-uOvYAnKWw230367OzrX4t_Mvwwa3NBkAVEmBnVWXUWUxk_8GDB2Lv7Z9-Qu-v2qL3rM_4hiRW70qrpjd_ZZEPhsjuzum-N1yKo8cYtxI3QqNbnFY9yQXD43VIGFiQKkDsfEEhWkm2QlE=w568-h757-no
    0VLRtaMZnFbqaXxh4_U48XvXOVSmourgyk-x-E7vadqTChhUnZG76ArBtg4gKuwMddRdQ7TvAdYagTydEnpt0AmurZZ7KiInYCRiQ0fq6WtVSQ26ulSkT54qoq2nVoOlaQopiacRkYLIJ_W-3DVfZqIdqAjd2F7GQeUsq_hrNeUSOFBHggErcvzkyjitV-KGL1DoHdihIWgV2pAEjrAJkurevIDb1RkNAcsDiwhmnTF6tdU14bue-do9Jf1Bvc3hFgX3Ba4-fe1lBMy6WZKtOYJE0Fp2YGIG2AYrbFtpreNiHWgVxBXHNTXkXgOoVYRWUEBS9gOeOYeQPybuLVFWHbooysJWr-wW0IM2TH6yPxjNN_LxvcFHN_56L9ZaD6PdTAkkHm1Thtbxvoqx6bpNAgOMH1O9RMiZLEG05PwBDlE6y98ySa20b5rcJm7lXsN-FCKLtpcO1qbnGMrPIDiKCOODdu67jluMJhFb_CyZ-nWObRnqERLqItQL0PG1wL4kUJlMZz1ylqHi7fgAUe9B63tpadhp7UEyRPYd26ZLZrXZM9mz_9di7P95Ig2G42VUXXeYADUc7hkJaxaBTJbrxravevlvsYAH2ivBhT-H4uK1eHV2BKYkEbDQu_na64dBDLx-Jc6T9JbP0M51nSeroQmZGLU5fSI=w568-h757-no


    Photos not showing:(
  • DD265DD265 Forumite
    2.2K Posts
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    ✭✭✭✭
    Weird, I can see them so might be a permissions thing. Will pop them on a hosting site..

    edOfufd.jpg

    FPiMOAI.jpg
  • DavesnaveDavesnave Forumite
    34.7K Posts
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Looks like historic frost and physical strimmer damage to me. Ugly.


    It will never be a decent tree now. Remedy: chain saw. Sorry!
This discussion has been closed.
Latest MSE News and Guides