Ready, steady… save!
You don’t need a chart to join in. Here are 2 ways to record your savings:
1. Cross it off
Pop a chart into your first post. Saved an amount? Cross it out! Read more »
£0.01 £0.02 £0.03
2. Write it down
Skip the chart and add updates to your first post. Read more »
“Another +£3 saved today. Go me!”
Use +£ before each new saving so it counts towards your total.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
FU The poorest alway pay more
[Deleted User]
Posts: 0
Newbie
in Energy
I know of someone who is with First Utility its prices are competative its billing is accurate and she has no complaints. She gets her Warm Home Discount each year and is always in credit or tries to be.
She has two bank accounts one for bills and direct debit payments and the other for living, money for food clothing for her children. The direct debit is attached to a fixed date her income from her ex is unreliable and money comes in at varying times of the month.
As a single mum she has to juggle money sometimes robbing Peter to pay Paul and this means her bills bank account is only a couple of pounds in credit and not enough to pay her direct debit so it bounces. First Utility charge her an admin fee of £5.00 even though she is £300 pounds in credit.
So why don't First Utility first take money from the credit and if there is not enough then from the direct debit. The answer is this £300 is funding the cash flow of the business.
Does anybody think money should first come from credit and next from direct debit. This single mum would be better of by £5.00 a month.
She has two bank accounts one for bills and direct debit payments and the other for living, money for food clothing for her children. The direct debit is attached to a fixed date her income from her ex is unreliable and money comes in at varying times of the month.
As a single mum she has to juggle money sometimes robbing Peter to pay Paul and this means her bills bank account is only a couple of pounds in credit and not enough to pay her direct debit so it bounces. First Utility charge her an admin fee of £5.00 even though she is £300 pounds in credit.
So why don't First Utility first take money from the credit and if there is not enough then from the direct debit. The answer is this £300 is funding the cash flow of the business.
Does anybody think money should first come from credit and next from direct debit. This single mum would be better of by £5.00 a month.
0
Comments
-
So what happens in the winter if she runs into arrears - does she get saddled with an unexpected bill to make up the shortfall.
The whole idea of the DD arrangement is to smooth the cost of energy over the whole year so you don't end up with small bills in the summer and ginormous ones in the winter. It helps you budget because you know what it's going to cost every month - mucking about with the amounts defeats it's purpose
The clever thing is to make sure you've got a fairly accurate estimate of your annual energy consumption so you don't pay an excessive amount extra but there's sufficient for the account to balance at the end of the contract period.Never under estimate the power of stupid people in large numbers0 -
Baloney! That's how it's been sold to consumers in fact it is vastly better for the cash flow of the energy companies for their customers to always have their accounts in credit. The suggestion that consumers are so !!!!less that that they cannot manage their finances is rubbish. In the Olden Days we used to pay for gas & electric quarterly in arrears.matelodave wrote: »The whole idea of the DD arrangement is to smooth the cost of energy over the whole year so you don't end up with small bills in the summer and ginormous ones in the winter. It helps you budget because you know what it's going to cost every month - mucking about with the amounts defeats it's purpose0 -
You believe what you will.
My energy costs me around £150 a month for the four winter months and around £40 a month for the other eight making it around £920 a year = £77 a month.
It's easier for me to budget for an even amount every month rather than finding three hundred quid just before or after Xmas and the same again at the end of March when the water and Council tax bills roll in as well. Although it would be nice to pay a bit less in the summer.
Plan it right and you can be in arrears for almost the whole of the year and balance it out to zero at the end of 12 months. It just needs you to be a bit canny about when you start and to monitor your consumption profile.
I'm comfortably in arrears at the moment (but not quite as much as expected due to the mild February we've just had) and it will diminish slowly until it balances out in August when my fix ends.Never under estimate the power of stupid people in large numbers0 -
I'd make sure your friends energy supplier has an accurate estimate of expected annual energy usage by up to date and regular meter readings.
I've never been in more than one DD monthly payment in credit with Scottish Power, although they do debit my account in arrears rather than in advance.
Martin's Money Show on ITV on 18.2.19 (still on catch up) explains how to request money from energy suppliers when account too much in credit.0 -
The suggestion that consumers are so !!!!less that that they cannot manage their finances is rubbish. In the Olden Days we used to pay for gas & electric quarterly in arrears.
Sadly that is indeed the case - that consumers today cannot manage their finances and plan ahead.
You have only got to spend some time on these forums to realise this - even this board where the concept of reading the meter and checking the estimated bills are "sort of" in the right range is beyond many people. Round and round the same questions we go on here time after time - have you read the meter - no.
Yes I too like you being an oldie paid quarterly in arrears and it resulted in a huge bill immediately after winter and a microscopic one in the summer. Fine for me I just transferred the extra from a savings account: not for many.
Others I knew deliberately played the game by not paying until a red notice of imminent disconnection arrived - they did this every quarter: not surprising is it that the companies wanted monthly DD's to stop that sort of abuse of the process. After all we were all giving the energy companies in effect a quarterly loan for our as yet unpaid for energy.0 -
Baloney! That's how it's been sold to consumers in fact it is vastly better for the cash flow of the energy companies for their customers to always have their accounts in credit. The suggestion that consumers are so !!!!less that that they cannot manage their finances is rubbish. In the Olden Days we used to pay for gas & electric quarterly in arrears.
The person the OP is talking about can't even budget well enough to pay a fixed amount on a fixed day each month!, I think that's a good example of how poor people are at managing their money.
I know many people of all ages who are terrible at managing their money and so many people complain about being "skint" in the run up to payday. I think people have always been generally poor at managing money.0 -
I used to be poor at managing my money - but I soon learnt how to do it and having stuff like budget accounts with fixed direct debits made it so much easier than getting random bills every month.
In fact once upon a time Midland Bank used to run a budget account. You told them what bills you've have during the yera (gas, leccy, water, rates, phone etc.etc, even a holiday) - they'd add it all up and divide it by 12 and then you paid a standing order or DD for that amount every month. You had a special chequebook to pay these bills (and only bills that you'd specified) with and it allowed you to get onto an even keel.
Before that we used to put stuff like the rent, leccy, gas and stuff in a jam jar and it was sancrosanct - not for dipping into because you were a bit short.
It was a case of prioritising what was essential. You learned that if you didn't have the money then you went without. Rent, rates and energy costs had to be paid, food came next and anything else like clothing etc came before luxury stuff like phones, TV and going out.Never under estimate the power of stupid people in large numbers0 -
Everybody has a valid point. She is owed money by her supplier and probably has a track record of D/D's bouncing whilst being in credit. In the very least the sensible thing to do is for the supplier to waive the £5 charge. The supplier has offered to move the D/D fixed date but her income does not arrive at a fixed time of month so this is not a practical solution.
Take tax credits a lot of single mums rely on child tax credits but they are paid like old age pensions every four weeks or 28 days. The payment date shifts month by month to conflict with the D/D date.
Another thing is if she asked the supplier to refund the credit she would most likely spend it on her kids and would soon be in arrears then the admin fee would be justified. So the credit is best kept by the supplier tucked out of the way.
The Warm Home Discount arrives as a £140 credit to the account plus any credit she has already paid. When she gets out of synch she makes a card payment to compensate for the bounced D/D.
The supplier will sometimes make two or more tries at the D/D so she can be charged £15 in any month even though she is hundreds of pounds in credit. The D/D having failed once should it next be taken from her available credit and the admin fee waived?
All of these bounced D/D affect her credit rating so she can't obtain an authorised overdraft for those times when she misses payment. I think she manages her money quite well given the circumstances especially by trying to return her account back to credit when she can.0 -
[Deleted User] wrote:Everybody has a valid point. She is owed money by her supplier and probably has a track record of D/D's bouncing whilst being in credit. In the very least the sensible thing to do is for the supplier to waive the £5 charge. The supplier has offered to move the D/D fixed date but her income does not arrive at a fixed time of month so this is not a practical solution.
Take tax credits a lot of single mums rely on child tax credits but they are paid like old age pensions every four weeks or 28 days. The payment date shifts month by month to conflict with the D/D date.
Every one of her benefits will be a set amount at a set interval. The Direct Debit will be a fixed amount taken at a fixed date every month.
A simple calculation will give her an amount that she needs to put aside every time she get paid a benefit so she has enough to pay her DD every time.
If this money was put into a separate account for bills this would be easy to manage, it's not a difficult money situation she just isn't really trying.[Deleted User] wrote:Another thing is if she asked the supplier to refund the credit she would most likely spend it on her kids and would soon be in arrears then the admin fee would be justified. So the credit is best kept by the supplier tucked out of the way.
She really needs to sort out how she controls her spending if she just spends every penny when she gets it.[Deleted User] wrote:The Warm Home Discount arrives as a £140 credit to the account plus any credit she has already paid. When she gets out of synch she makes a card payment to compensate for the bounced D/D.
The supplier will sometimes make two or more tries at the D/D so she can be charged £15 in any month even though she is hundreds of pounds in credit. The D/D having failed once should it next be taken from her available credit and the admin fee waived?
All of these bounced D/D affect her credit rating so she can't obtain an authorised overdraft for those times when she misses payment. I think she manages her money quite well given the circumstances especially by trying to return her account back to credit when she can.
Simply getting paid money and then spending it all isn't managing it at all, she certainly doesn't manage it well.
The issues are all caused by her not budgeting and overspending. What i would suggest is for her to have a separate account for all her bills and then work out how much she needs to transfer into it when she gets her benefits. She needs to realise that she can never touch the money in the account. This can be setup with standing orders and if the bills are paid by Direct Debit she won't even have to do anything and all her bills will be paid on time.0 -
Simply getting paid money and then spending it all isn't managing it at all, she certainly doesn't manage it well.
The question still remains unanswered!
I'll bet you are on a fixed amount DD, your money comes in at a fixed time of month give or take a couple of days and you plan your life and finances around this event.
Dare I say if you look at the T&C of your energy provider nowhere will it say that you allowed to go into the red or debit. Quite the opposite the provider allows you to pay by variable DD and some providers contractually insist that on a fixed DD basis you keep at least one months DD credit on the account.
The way fixed DD works is that you build a credit during low energy demand and move into debit during high demand. This is contractually non-compliant and the provider turns a blind eye because over the year debit and credit in theory cancel each other out.
Mum has breached her T&C with the provider but her account is always in credit and she is otherwise contractually compliant. Her credit is £300 way above the minimum credit required contractually. The provider can contractually deduct the £5 admin fee but to avoid the contract becoming unfair should not attempt another DD withdrawal from Mum's bank instead the full DD amount should come from her credit.
Multiple DD attemps whilst a customer is in credit over and above the contractual minimum is unfair on the customer. In terms of degree fixed DD customers are far more non compliant than those who try to keep their accounts in credit.0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 355.9K Banking & Borrowing
- 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 456.2K Spending & Discounts
- 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
- 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 179.1K Life & Family
- 264K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards

