We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Tax return - including pay from employment

GSTAR
Posts: 58 Forumite


in Cutting tax
I am filling in a tax return for the year 2017-2018.
During this period I was EMPLOYED up until 31/06/2017. Between 01/07/2017 and 05/04/2018 I was SELF-EMPLOYED.
For my employment, I was paid and taxed via PAYE. I have input these amounts in my tax return as follows:
- Pay before tax: £9224
- UK tax paid: £1212
For my self-employment, I have entered the following:
- Turnover: £33444
- Expenses: £1422
Now for some reason, it is adding up both of my employed and self-employed incomes to work out how much tax is due. But I have already paid tax and NI on my employment, so it does not make sense to include this amount.
So in other words, instead of:
Profit from self employment (£32022) - Personal allowance (£11500) = £20522
It is instead doing:
Pay from employment (£9224) + Profit from self-employment (£32022) = £41246
Total income (£41246) - Personal allowance (£11500) = £29746.
Unfortunately I don't have a P45/P60 from my employment so I have used the figures from my last payslip (Gross pay to date and Tax paid to date).
I must be doing something wrong here, can anyone advise?
During this period I was EMPLOYED up until 31/06/2017. Between 01/07/2017 and 05/04/2018 I was SELF-EMPLOYED.
For my employment, I was paid and taxed via PAYE. I have input these amounts in my tax return as follows:
- Pay before tax: £9224
- UK tax paid: £1212
For my self-employment, I have entered the following:
- Turnover: £33444
- Expenses: £1422
Now for some reason, it is adding up both of my employed and self-employed incomes to work out how much tax is due. But I have already paid tax and NI on my employment, so it does not make sense to include this amount.
So in other words, instead of:
Profit from self employment (£32022) - Personal allowance (£11500) = £20522
It is instead doing:
Pay from employment (£9224) + Profit from self-employment (£32022) = £41246
Total income (£41246) - Personal allowance (£11500) = £29746.
Unfortunately I don't have a P45/P60 from my employment so I have used the figures from my last payslip (Gross pay to date and Tax paid to date).
I must be doing something wrong here, can anyone advise?
0
Comments
-
...
Now for some reason, it is adding up both of my employed and self-employed incomes to work out how much tax is due. ...
That's the way it works....
Pay from employment (£9224) + Profit from self-employment (£32022) = £41246
Total income (£41246) - Personal allowance (£11500) = £29746.
Looks about right.
So 20% of that is due, less the tax already paid of £1212.0 -
fundamental misunderstanding.
your tax return declares your total income for the year.
You are taxed on that total (less personal allowance) so in your case taxed on 29,746
from that tax due figure you then deduct any tax already paid (1212) so leaving the actual amount of tax you must now pay on submitting your tax return0 -
I still don't get it. As I understand, I've paid £1212 tax on my employment income of £9224. So why am I now being re-taxed on this income?0
-
I still don't get it. As I understand, I've paid £1212 tax on my employment income of £9224. So why am I now being re-taxed on this income?
Because that's how it works. Your tax return and tax calculation is for the full tax year, not part of it. So ALL your taxable incomes sources are added up, tax is worked out on the total, and then tax you've already paid is deducted, leaving you with a figure of what is owed.0 -
I still don't get it. As I understand, I've paid £1212 tax on my employment income of £9224. So why am I now being re-taxed on this income?
You won't be re-taxed on this income as you will be given credit for the tax that has already been deducted through PAYE.
For example
Your total income is as follows:
Pay from PAYE employment - £9,224
Profit from Self Employment - £32,022
Total earnings = £41,246
Minus your personal allowance of £11,500 leaves total taxable earnings of £29,746
£29,746 @ 20% tax = £5,949.20
Of the £5,949.20 in tax due, you have already paid £1,212 through PAYE so the remaining £4,737.20 should be your balancing payment due 31/01/2019.
Edit Note: The balancing payment above will simply be the income tax aspect and won't include any Class 2 National Insurance or Class 4 National Insurance Contributions you will be due to pay on your Self Employed profits.0 -
For my employment, I was paid and taxed via PAYE. I have input these amounts in my tax return as follows:
- Pay before tax: £9224
- UK tax paid: £1212
So in other words, instead of:
Profit from self employment (£32022) - Personal allowance (£11500) = £20522
).I must be doing something wrong here, can anyone advise?
The tax paid on your PAYE earnings was calculated after giving you part of your personal allowance aprox £3165.
You have then put the full £11500 against your self employed earnings rather than the part left after PAYE ie 11500 - 31650 -
I still don't get it. As I understand, I've paid £1212 tax on my employment income of £9224. So why am I now being re-taxed on this income?
It sounds like you haven't actually completed the return, because if you had you'd see in the calculations that the tax you have already paid has been deducted to give a figure that you still owe.0 -
I was told that I don’t put the money I have paid tax on in the tax return form as they already have that on record. Tax return is to calculate how much tax you need to pay on your self employed earnings.0
-
jayne_richardson wrote: »I was told that I don’t put the money I have paid tax on in the tax return form as they already have that on record. Tax return is to calculate how much tax you need to pay on your self employed earnings.
You must put all taxable income on your self-assessment form.0 -
jayne_richardson wrote: »I was told that I don’t put the money I have paid tax on in the tax return form as they already have that on record. Tax return is to calculate how much tax you need to pay on your self employed earnings.
This is a worryingly common misconception.
If you don't understand why all your income needs to go on your tax return, even if it has been taxed at source, you need an accountant to help you through the process.0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 351.7K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.4K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454K Spending & Discounts
- 244.7K Work, Benefits & Business
- 600.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.3K Life & Family
- 258.4K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards