Is this worth appealing or just paying? Please help

Redx

Danlad99 wrote: »

Thanks RedX,
My reasoning behind that was that the pcc are given the opportunity to counter reply, and knowing I'd bring up the POFA failure in court resulting in a clear cut win would make them not waste any more time and move on to the next target.

I shall remove it though x

stop trying to be clever and just use template paragraphs that have been successful in previous cases


cross each bridge as you come to it , the time for clever terminology is in a defence and a witness statement being seen by a judge, whereas you need to point everythingout to an assessor at popla (who isnt legally trained and is definitely NOT a judge)


we want you to win now to remove the threat of court , using tried and tested paragraphs that have won previously


you said you were lazy, so find and adapt a previous winning popla appeal, it doesnt get lazier than that , and being extrtemely lazy it looks like you hadnt read the popla submissions info in the NEWBIES thread (a foolish thing to do)

Danlad99

I did read them, and the few in particular that related to points relevant to my charge I went over numerous times, hence all the points raised being bpa code of practice failures. The only difference is I didn't include long case examples of each point, as this was a 1st draft of points. Stop being mean lol

Redx

lets hope the final popla draft is better than the one on page 2 , because I give that a 3 out of 10 and expected better, as did other people reading it


I gave you the categories and order of merit, the rest I leave to your copy and paste efforts from previous winning popla appeals


frankly, I have read through the whole thread several times and dont think you are taking this seriously , or that you even look at or digest the replies

Danlad99

Wow, I've brought up every single issue where it falls foul of bpa guidelines, the same ones also all brought up in other appeals,. Unless you have a score of other, secret points, that are not mentioned in any of the appeals, then I'm not really sure.

As mentioned before, the only difference was not including or referencing winning cases on each point, which I pointed out, I wasn't at that stage, being a draft.

Coupon-mad

Danlad99 wrote: »

I think because popla pretty much ignore all copy paste stuff of various vague reasons and focus on the main one.

No they don't.

The copy & paste POPLA template points we use, have potential in themselves to win the case, and POPLA just choose one. They only ever choose one winning point, and disregard all others, no matter what style of POPLA appeal you write.

You need the usual template points, not just stuff ab out the signs, and not just things about the BPA CoP (a breach of the BPA CoP does NOT in itself, win a POPLA appeal - the Lead Assessor said so).

You've missed out 'no landowner authority' - the template which wins loads of POPLA appeals. It's in the NEWBIES thread post #3.

You also had a few typos like 'peruse' instead of pursue (and others) so it needs a check-over.

(2) Falling foul of POFA rules:

That's better headed up 'no keeper liability' and should be #1, before the signage point. Make it easy for the Assessor to choose the winning point!

Danlad99

^^ thank you ��

Coupon-mad

And here's one that was won on 'no landowner authority' by a poster who had already blabbed about who was driving:

https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/5889148/advice-and-thanks

Hence you need all the silver bullets you can add.

Pwpw

hi there I have been reading your thread about the Penalty Charge you received,I am currently going through this problem.How did you get on with appeal/outcome

regards PW

Umkomaas

Pwpw wrote: »

hi there I have been reading your thread about the Penalty Charge you received,I am currently going through this problem.How did you get on with appeal/outcome

regards PW

This thread is almost 18 months old, little chance of any response from the original poster who hasn't been seen in these parts for almost 12 months.

If you want help, please start a new thread of your own, with some background to your problem.

fisherjim

Pwpw wrote: »

hi there I have been reading your thread about the Penalty Charge you received,I am currently going through this problem.How did you get on with appeal/outcome

regards PW

I doubt that very much!