We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Switching accounts..worth keeping ?

Samsung_Note2
Posts: 774 Forumite
Ok so i now find myself in the position of having several accounts and only use 2 of them regular.
Main account is B which i really cant fault...nice and easy to use and is salary account and direct debits.
Second is Halifax..transfer each month my day to day spending money.
Natwest (just waiting on bonus)..HSBC Advance (just received bonus),First Direct which i dont pay fee"s on as have Credit card with them.
Any real reason to keep the three accounts above..i hear people state 1st direct and HSBC can be picky on who they accept,just wondering what benefit in keeping them,only save a small amount each month so can do that with either B or Halifax.
Looking at Remortgage in september if that makes any difference.
Main account is B which i really cant fault...nice and easy to use and is salary account and direct debits.
Second is Halifax..transfer each month my day to day spending money.
Natwest (just waiting on bonus)..HSBC Advance (just received bonus),First Direct which i dont pay fee"s on as have Credit card with them.
Any real reason to keep the three accounts above..i hear people state 1st direct and HSBC can be picky on who they accept,just wondering what benefit in keeping them,only save a small amount each month so can do that with either B or Halifax.
Looking at Remortgage in september if that makes any difference.
0
Comments
-
How long is a piece of string? Whether or not you should keep an account depends on how it benefits YOU, not us.
I keep my accounts as they give rewards, interest, or rewards to access to high interest regular savers. That's what benefits me. I only use two for day to day spending.0 -
binaryuniverse wrote: »How long is a piece of string? Whether or not you should keep an account depends on how it benefits YOU, not us.
I keep my accounts as they give rewards, interest, or rewards to access to high interest regular savers. That's what benefits me. I only use two for day to day spending.
Sorry but thought that's what i just asked..savings aside (dont use any of the three for savings) is there any benefit in keeping them,for instance would a decent APR credit card be offered or preferential rates on mortgages,if that's the case id look at moving money through an account rather than leaving it dormant.
If that's not likely to happen then will simply close them down and continue to wonder why people insist 1st Direct and HSBC are choosy in who they offer accounts to,dont seem anything special to me..:j:j0 -
Potential mule accounts for future switch bonuses?0
-
beefturnmail wrote: »Potential mule accounts for future switch bonuses?
That was initial thoughts..but think i've hit every single switch.
Assuming an account that's not used will be of benefit when looking at remortgaging,was told 1st direct have some good deals,could move money through that if needed.0 -
First Direct and HSBC Advance are worth keeping for the 5% Regular Savings accounts that they allow you to hold. HSBC will take £250 per month and First Direct £300.
There is also additional money to be made by keeping the accounts at this stage - HSBC will give an extra £50 after a year if you meet the criteria, see here: https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/banking/compare-best-bank-accounts#hsbc
First Direct also have a leaving bonus after 6 months, but it would mean closing your credit card and any other accounts with them, see http://www1.firstdirect.com/1/2/banking/switching-bank-accounts0 -
Samsung_Note2 wrote: »That was initial thoughts..but think i've hit every single switch.
Every switch which is available today...0 -
Samsung_Note2 wrote: »Ok so i now find myself in the position of having several accounts and only use 2 of them regular.
Main account is B which i really cant fault...nice and easy to use and is salary account and direct debits.
Second is Halifax..transfer each month my day to day spending money.
Natwest (just waiting on bonus)..HSBC Advance (just received bonus),First Direct which i dont pay fee"s on as have Credit card with them.
Any real reason to keep the three accounts above..i hear people state 1st direct and HSBC can be picky on who they accept,just wondering what benefit in keeping them,only save a small amount each month so can do that with either B or Halifax.
Looking at Remortgage in september if that makes any difference.
As there is the potential for future switching bonuses, then having accounts already set up and ready to go puts you in an advantageous position. I see no reason to close these accounts, as long as you can continue to meet the terms and conditions.Samsung_Note2 wrote: »That was initial thoughts..but think i've hit every single switch.
You don't know what might be offered in the future. Not many people were expecting the Yorkshire Bank/B offer, nor the NatWest one.
First Direct and HSBC also have linked regular savers allowing you to save £550 p/m between them (£300 First Direct and £250 HSBC) at 5%. This is a pretty good reason to keep them both open. Even if you don't have the spare money to make use of these now (although any that you do would be well placed in these) you might in the future, so keeping your options open makes sense.0 -
Well think im going to give HSBC the elbow as just had the switch bonus and still cant fully use the Online banking.
Opened a 12 month saver with them and after the 15 or might have been 16th call over the last several weeks to resolve the activation key (was told go into branch as they couldn't help over the phone...went into branch and the woman said how could she issue a digital activation key).
So any and all transfers out of the account had to be verbal over the phone,now they have transferred Money twice by mistake,both amounts have hit my Halifax.
Wasn't aware until chap who done the last transfer called me and made me aware...when asked if i was liable to repay it,he said No....hmmm really but went onto say expect a letter to clarify what happened.
Complete shambles and all down to requesting numerous times a damn activation key.0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 351.7K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.4K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454K Spending & Discounts
- 244.7K Work, Benefits & Business
- 600.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.3K Life & Family
- 258.4K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards