Top Sante Magazine is it a daily click to win or not?

Marg2k8

I have just posted some competitions that can be found on the Top Sante website.

It has been suggested to me that these are daily entry click to win competitions and should not be posted separately on the main board, as they are on the click to win list.

If you look at the main Top Sante page it does say "enter every day to win the hottest fashion, accessories, technology and more at Top Sante!", but if you look at the terms and conditions of the individual competitions, it says "Only one entry permitted per person"

So my question to you more experienced compers is should these be posted on the main board and the link removed from the click to win thread, or should the link remain on the click to win thread and they should not be posted separately on the main board.

Thanks everyone.

mansey

Main board, not a click to win

They are a PITA

And have naff competitions :eek:

I think they are more of a daily than a C2W

Marg2k8

Main board, not a click to win

mansey wrote: »

They are a PITA

And have naff competitions :eek:

I think they are more of a daily than a C2W

I once won a lovely prize with Top Sante, so I don't think they're naff:rotfl:

Has anyone ever tried entering more than once since they became owned by Kelsey Media?

One-Eye

Main board, not a click to win

My view:-

Top Sante was a Bauer Media publication and like other Bauer mags - did C2Ws at winit.topsante.co.uk

In March/April 2017 it became a Kelsey Media title. Kelsey Media don't do C2W for any other title so eventually the "winit" C2Ws were dropped.

Top Sante comps are now normal comps - one entry per person - and should be posted on the main forum.

mjm3346

Kelsey might have started off with a clicktowin style when they took over but they just look like single entry competitions now.

There are also about a dozen what appear to be single entry comps for Match magazine as well

http://shop.kelsey.co.uk/promotion/win

bees**knees

I am happy to remove Top Sante from the Click to Win list if we are certain they are one time entry only.

As Top Sante are posting competitions regularly it would be useful to have a volunteer to check and post them to the main board. The same with Match.

If not we may lose the link.

I have thought about asking for someone to manage the Click to Win list and make it separate from the Mag dailies (it would reduce the work load of the thread a little) but there are very few postings associated with it ( unlike Mag Dailies which have postings most days onto the end of the thread which bump the thread to the top).

Separation would result in the Click to Win thread disappearing down the Regular comps list and making it hard to find.
I dont think we could get it to be a pinned post.

Does anyone have any suggestions?

mjm3346

bees**knees wrote: »

As Top Sante are posting competitions regularly it would be useful to have a volunteer to check and post them to the main board. The same with Match.

Separation would result in the Click to Win thread disappearing down the Regular comps list and making it hard to find.

As single entry competitions there is no reason for them to be treated any differently to the vast majority of competitions which are simply posted "as found" by anybody.

As to click to wins I suspect that most people who do them already have the sites or the thread bookmarked so it wouldn't matter what happened to the post - if it was hived off your index page could sill have a link to the new thread as it does to the post at the moment.

Marg2k8

Main board, not a click to win

I am happy to check Top Sante regularly and post any comps not already posted. I do however appreciate that the comping guide states that "no comper 'owns the right' to post a particular comp".

I am also happy to take ownership of the list of click to win comps listing. I appreciate that this would slip down the list of threads once it is no longer bumped very regularly, however, as MJM3346 says, I too believe that people would bookmark it.

On the first page of your mag daily thread, you have quick links to all the sections of your thread. The quick link for the click to wins could direct people to a new thread if started, if you are happy to do this.

bees**knees

Thanks Marg.

PM me when your new thread is up and running and i will delete the list from the Mag Dailies thread

I will leave a link on the first page to your new thread

Marg2k8

Main board, not a click to win

Thanks bees**knees. The new thread is now ready and can be found here;

https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/comment/73008761#Comment_73008761

If anyone spots any errors I have made, please PM me. Thanks.

mjm3346

Doesn't look like the "match" ones have been posted, [STRIKE]I'll post the ones currently on the site.[/STRIKE]

Now posted.