📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Urgent Advice Needed About EDF Bill!

2»

Comments

  • jalexa
    jalexa Posts: 3,448 Forumite
    So, do you think I should cancel the DD and tell them I want to pay quarterly, ..... or agree a DD amount with them and tell them I want it by the end of the week? I am seriously thinking of complaining in writing,

    I do not think it reasonable for an organisation to extract £580 from a current account at 10 days notice.

    However try to avoid turning an Edf (probably account maladministration) issue into your fault because you cancelled the direct debit.

    You need to establish your annual consumption and to do that you need to deal with the suspect opening electric read. Then you you need to calculate your actual monthly cost. I would budget £100/month. Then "demand" that the debit balance resulting from the late start of the direct debit is collected by easy payment terms over (at least) the same period as the late start, i.e. at least 6 months.

    I would expect them to agree with sensible proposals. Otherwise complain, or do that anyway.
  • MK55
    MK55 Posts: 286 Forumite
    I joined up with them in August 2011, as I wanted to save some money and I no longer wanted to pay Scottish Power £132 DD a month. Oh, the irony! I can't be certain of the 24881 reading, as I asked my husband to do it and then I just passed it on to EDF online. Scottish Power actually refunded us some money in October 2011 too. It was £352.56, so I thought that meant our £132 DD per month to them was too high.
    Anyway, I shall update you tomorrow and thanks again.

    Hi, just having a look and this post may say it all. Reading at transfer was too low(incorrect read taken)may have resulted in this large refunds.

    This bill will be catching up on the incorrect low reading and potentially rebilling you for energy you consumed with Scottish power.

    Is the reading issued lately in line with your meter?? Howmuch kwhs did you use with Scottish power in a 12 month period.
  • notbritishgas
    notbritishgas Posts: 2,321
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    Thanks very much, Jalexa. So, do you think I should cancel the DD and tell them I want to pay quarterly, or request an energy card, or agree a DD amount with them and tell them I want it by the end of the week? I am seriously thinking of complaining in writing, as it was very stressful with the gas, and now this with the electricity, when up to now, I was impressed by their handling of that side of things.

    I joined up with them in August 2011, as I wanted to save some money and I no longer wanted to pay Scottish Power £132 DD a month. Oh, the irony! I can't be certain of the 24881 reading, as I asked my husband to do it and then I just passed it on to EDF online. Scottish Power actually refunded us some money in October 2011 too. It was £352.56, so I thought that meant our £132 DD per month to them was too high.
    Anyway, I shall update you tomorrow and thanks again.
    I think that could be the answer, I presume the refund was on the final bill from from SP.
    They would produce that from the reading of 24881 (C) that you gave EDF. Now if that reading was incorrect, ie too little, it would mean that your first EDF bill would be very high and your last SP bill very low.
    I suspect the £352 you got back should really go towards the EDF bill, but you were not to know that.
  • robotrobo
    robotrobo Posts: 921
    Part of the Furniture 500 Posts
    Forumite
    hi.
    i have been with edf for 18 months & still no gas account!my electric account is ok, i have had numerous edf advisors promising to fix the problem but to no avail , i am past the panicking stage now , as its beyond my control & theres nothing else i can do, people have in the past advised me that they canot charge me after the 12 month period for gas used, but they periodically take d/d payments for gas & put the money in the electric account . i am £ 300 in credit.
    my advice for what its worth is not to keep sending your own readings as this triggers the computer to send out the absurb d/d future payments on the reading you have just given.
    all money for the gas is makeing 3.2% interst in a bank account!, but after all the stress caused & all the days , hours & weeks donated by me in trying to sort this out , i will not be eager to hand over any money after this if ever is sorted out.
    like i say i have had edf advisors phoneing me up & get the problem sorted , but they give up on me & stop ringing me.
    my mate down the road from me who went to the ombudsman & has recieved compensation for his troubles is still no nearer , we both signed up on the same time, his problem is the electric.
  • jalexa
    jalexa Posts: 3,448 Forumite
    edited 2 April 2012 at 10:59AM
    I think that could be the answer, I presume the refund was on the final bill from from SP.
    They would produce that from the reading of 24881 (C) that you gave EDF. Now if that reading was incorrect, ie too little, it would mean that your first EDF bill would be very high and your last SP bill very low.
    I suspect the £352 you got back should really go towards the EDF bill, but you were not to know that.

    to the OP:

    That is good advice from notbritishgas. Although I thought the opening reading might be "suspect" I didn't spot the £352 (perhaps because it wasn't in the OP:D)

    *If* the Scottish Power closing reading is the same as the Edf opening reading, then just on the £££s the worst case is you have paid for more of your electricity at a higher price, but still been billed for accurate metered consumption to the present time. Nor sure how/if that type of (customer?) error can be addressed.

    However there is another side issue which is to do with the current suppliers assumption of your annual electric consumption. It will initially appear higher than actual and will probably result in a higher than necessary direct debit.

    Another poster advises "my advice for what its worth is not to keep sending your own readings as this triggers the computer to send out the absurb d/d future payments on the reading you have just given"

    The effect described is absolutely true for Edf currently, but not necessarily for other suppliers. I'm less in agreement not to provide any readings. Anyway to capture your ongoing electric consumption you will probably be asked to, and will need to, provide actual readings over a period.
  • Quick update. I finally managed to get through to an EDF advisor today, who agreed £580 was a ridiculous amount. He wanted me to go up to £150 instead, but he agreed to £130 and promised to send it in writing in the next few days. So I'll let you know if I get this, and if not, I'll cancel the direct debit and just go on a normal bill. Thanks so much for the advice, everyone.
  • Terrylw1
    Terrylw1 Posts: 7,038 Forumite
    robotrobo wrote: »
    hi.
    i have been with edf for 18 months & still no gas account!my electric account is ok, i have had numerous edf advisors promising to fix the problem but to no avail , i am past the panicking stage now , as its beyond my control & theres nothing else i can do, people have in the past advised me that they canot charge me after the 12 month period for gas used, but they periodically take d/d payments for gas & put the money in the electric account . i am £ 300 in credit.
    my advice for what its worth is not to keep sending your own readings as this triggers the computer to send out the absurb d/d future payments on the reading you have just given.
    all money for the gas is makeing 3.2% interst in a bank account!, but after all the stress caused & all the days , hours & weeks donated by me in trying to sort this out , i will not be eager to hand over any money after this if ever is sorted out.
    like i say i have had edf advisors phoneing me up & get the problem sorted , but they give up on me & stop ringing me.
    my mate down the road from me who went to the ombudsman & has recieved compensation for his troubles is still no nearer , we both signed up on the same time, his problem is the electric.

    Make a complaint and go to the ombudsman if that doesn't resolve it.

    They can't bill further back than 12 months and you should expect some compensation for all the hassle. Just be aware that any credit is going to disappear when they resolve it and back bill you. Plus if you pay too little, expect a debt to pay off.

    The change of supply is easy so something else is wrong e.g. incorrect meter number, address, reading, etc but have they even told you what is wrong?
    :rotfl: It's better to live 1 year as a tiger than a lifetime as a worm...but then, whoever heard of a wormskin rug!!!:rotfl:
  • wakeupalarm
    wakeupalarm Posts: 1,109
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    Forumite
    Agreed. Make a complaint and make sure you take it to the ombudsman. EDF will just mess you about.
This discussion has been closed.
★ ★ ★ Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 355.9K Banking & Borrowing
  • 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 456.2K Spending & Discounts
  • 248.4K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 606.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 179.1K Life & Family
  • 264K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.7K Read-Only Boards
Quick Search

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.