We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
The Forum now has a brand new text editor, adding a bunch of handy features to use when creating posts. Read more in our how-to guide
Live with Ex & child - Help!!
avfcforever
Posts: 61 Forumite
Hi all,
I'm not sure whether a similar thread exists (I searched but couldn't see one!)
I have a relatively complicated relationship break up situation (aren't they all!) that I'd really appreciate some advice with.
My ex finished our relationship in late November 2010. We have a son who turned 2 in Dec 2010, and as I'm from an 'unbroken' home I tried everything I could to make it work and asked her if we could at least try over Christmas / New Year. The answer was no. To complicate things more, I'm in full time employment, and although my ex was, she has gone back to full time education to do a masters. We live in the midlands (as do my parents), her family live in Manchester. She does not intend to move back up to Manchester until she has finished her course, so in the meantime we are living in the same house that we both pay half each for mortgage/bills/food/etc. She doesn't want to sell the house, and says I have to have her consent to start to do so. I put in a significant deposit when we bought it in 2007, she didn't.
So, I don't know where to start. My priority is having access to my son and not being totally shaffted financially! I have been advised by friends not to move out (regardless of how unbearable) as this would appear as if I have walked out on the mum and child. I have also been advised not to get with anyone else as this could be seen in the same way. This is very new to me, and something I've very worried about and would appreciate and friendly or constructive advice.
Thanks in advance
Gavin
I'm not sure whether a similar thread exists (I searched but couldn't see one!)
I have a relatively complicated relationship break up situation (aren't they all!) that I'd really appreciate some advice with.
My ex finished our relationship in late November 2010. We have a son who turned 2 in Dec 2010, and as I'm from an 'unbroken' home I tried everything I could to make it work and asked her if we could at least try over Christmas / New Year. The answer was no. To complicate things more, I'm in full time employment, and although my ex was, she has gone back to full time education to do a masters. We live in the midlands (as do my parents), her family live in Manchester. She does not intend to move back up to Manchester until she has finished her course, so in the meantime we are living in the same house that we both pay half each for mortgage/bills/food/etc. She doesn't want to sell the house, and says I have to have her consent to start to do so. I put in a significant deposit when we bought it in 2007, she didn't.
So, I don't know where to start. My priority is having access to my son and not being totally shaffted financially! I have been advised by friends not to move out (regardless of how unbearable) as this would appear as if I have walked out on the mum and child. I have also been advised not to get with anyone else as this could be seen in the same way. This is very new to me, and something I've very worried about and would appreciate and friendly or constructive advice.
Thanks in advance
Gavin
0
Comments
-
sorry to make a presumption here but your not married?
marriage before kids isnt just an old fashioned antiquated social norm, it serves the purpose of minimising the risk of this exact situation.
although, the money you put down for deposit will likely be subtracted before splitting the house in the event of a sale, so you will at least get that back eventually.
why not kick her out and apply for sole custody? its your house? even if not, she cant support the child like you can.
or get back together 'for the childs sake'?Target Savings by end 2009: 20,000
current savings: 20,500 (target hit yippee!)
Debts: 8000 (student loan so doesnt count)
new target savings by Feb 2010: 30,0000 -
Are you married? Did you buy the house in joint names?MFW 2011 challenge - Aim: Overpay £414.26 a month/£5,000 a year. Overpayment Total to date: £414.26:jMortgage start 28/9/07 £46,217.00 :TMortgage balance as of 25/05/11 £24,490.58 :T
Interest saved as of 25/05/11: £2,849.84 Projected term reduction as of 25/05/11: 9 years 11 months0 -
We are not married, and the house is in joint names0
-
the money you put down for deposit will likely be subtracted before splitting the house in the event of a sale, so you will at least get that back eventually.
If the house is owned as 'joint tenants' (the usual way to buy a house) then this is not the case. When the house is sold both will be entitled to 50% of the net proceeds, regardless of how much each has paid (and equally entitled to live in it)
The only way to avoid this is to buy the house as tenants in common in unequal shares - but if that was the case, OP would be aware of it.
It is not true that you need her permission to put the house up for sale - but you do need her consent and signature to exchange contracts and complete the sale.I'm a retired employment solicitor. Hopefully some of my comments might be useful, but they are only my opinion and not intended as legal advice.0 -
We did make it clear when buying that we wanted 50/50 after the deposit was taken and the solicitor advised he had arranged it accordingly (so the unequal partnership is probably what he did).
As we are not married it is difficult to clearly define when and who ended the relationship (I.e. We can't file for divorce, therefore making it official) so does anyone know where I stand if I move out / start 'seeing' other people?
In regards to going for sole custody, although this is something that I have considered, everything I have heard suggests no matter how hard I tried the courts will always favour the mum unless there is likelyhood of harm, etc, which there isn't.
Thankyou so much for the fast and helpful responses so far0 -
I was in a similar position to you - I lived in a property myself and my ex purchased together, he paid the deposit out of sale of his former home (which was in his name only) and we had children and were not married.
When we seperated we both saw solicitors, who recommeded we both go to mediation in order to split things up and decide on childcare etc. One option that was open to us was to sell house and split profits. I decided I wanted to stay and my ex agreed to this. I had to re-mortgage so house was in my sole name as he wanted to purchase another property. I also agreed to give him a lump sum equal to the amount that he put down as a deposit. He had charge put on the house for 50% which means I cant sell it without giving him his money. Once we had sorted everything out at mediation the mediators wrote to our respective solicitors and the solicitors drew up a deed of seperation which we both signed. So a bit like a divorce but obviously no marriage to dissolve, just assets and children!
Go and see a solicitor for free 1/2 hour advice.MFW 2011 challenge - Aim: Overpay £414.26 a month/£5,000 a year. Overpayment Total to date: £414.26:jMortgage start 28/9/07 £46,217.00 :TMortgage balance as of 25/05/11 £24,490.58 :T
Interest saved as of 25/05/11: £2,849.84 Projected term reduction as of 25/05/11: 9 years 11 months0 -
And don't move out of house!!!!MFW 2011 challenge - Aim: Overpay £414.26 a month/£5,000 a year. Overpayment Total to date: £414.26:jMortgage start 28/9/07 £46,217.00 :TMortgage balance as of 25/05/11 £24,490.58 :T
Interest saved as of 25/05/11: £2,849.84 Projected term reduction as of 25/05/11: 9 years 11 months0 -
My ex and I stayed in the house til we sold it- went to mediation and agreed a split we both were happy with. We started with joint 50/50 contact with son but this as gradually changed to alternate weekend with himPeople seem not to see that their opinion of the world is also a confession of character.
Ralph Waldo Emerson0 -
hi
try the mediation route to negotiate splitting of assets,making child access arrangements etc.
first priority is,even though your son is very young,making the split as amicable as possible for both his sake and yours/ex-partner.
not sure why you "seeing" someone else would affect things-just depends what your priorities are and how quickly you want to move on?
you shouldn't need to move out.
if you can sleep in different rooms,cook seperately,"live apart" as such though in same house your ex may be able to claim child tax credit?
good luck.0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 354.3K Banking & Borrowing
- 254.4K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 455.4K Spending & Discounts
- 247.3K Work, Benefits & Business
- 604K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 178.4K Life & Family
- 261.5K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards