📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Which sockets on a Dell Inspiron desktop?

13»

Comments

  • bikerchris
    bikerchris Posts: 160
    Part of the Furniture 100 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    marms wrote: »
    The Dell Inspiron 560 has VGA and HDMI outputs, if you have a maplins nearby you can get http://www.maplin.co.uk/module.aspx?moduleno=97886 to convert HDMI to DVI, would be a lot cheaper than what Dell reccomend.

    That's a very fair point, although I would be concerned with a) whether on-board graphics would allow dual screens (not usually) and b) if the on-board graphics could cope with dual screens. We/I don't know the set-up fully and both outputs could require a high resolution. You'd be more than welcome to check with dell yourself, their chat system is fairly OK. I only suggested Dell as wadewade's previous PC may steer the decision makers to the same make.
    KillerWatt wrote: »
    Building a system that suits all the OP's needs from the ground upwards would be cheaper than buying a "supermarket" PC, and they would end up with better hardware than what they were expecting to start with.

    Definitely, if wadewade were local I would offer to build it, but as you know, there are both cheap systems built with cheap components as well as the professional rigs with high qualify components, that are professionally priced. I'm fairly sure wadewade doesn't wish to get involved with learning how to build a computer, so I figured the simplest route was to have one that's simply "pay, plug and play" (I just made that saying up, I like it!).
    If someone is worth thanking - click on the 'Thanks' button on their response. It's just a nice thing to do :-)

    Started debt at 17, stopped by 25 :-D ...I'm in debt again because of property :-/
  • KillerWatt
    KillerWatt Posts: 1,655 Forumite
    bikerchris wrote: »
    but as you know, there are both cheap systems built with cheap components as well as the professional rigs with high qualify components, that are professionally priced. I'm fairly sure wadewade doesn't wish to get involved with learning how to build a computer, so I figured the simplest route was to have one that's simply "pay, plug and play" (I just made that saying up, I like it!).
    Dell don't use "cheap" components, but you can most certainly get better VFM if you choose to build yourself.
    Remember kids, it's the volts that jolt and the mills that kill.
  • bikerchris
    bikerchris Posts: 160
    Part of the Furniture 100 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    KillerWatt wrote: »
    Dell don't use "cheap" components, but you can most certainly get better VFM if you choose to build yourself.

    Please be assured I wasn't referred to Dell, but custom computers such as those found advertised on online auction sites (mentioning no names). Again, you are right regarding value for money, but I don't believe a man of the cloth is interested in learning and building a computer in the slightest. Only last week I built one for a customer for less than £130, for secretarial use, so I'm well aware of the VFM potential.
    If someone is worth thanking - click on the 'Thanks' button on their response. It's just a nice thing to do :-)

    Started debt at 17, stopped by 25 :-D ...I'm in debt again because of property :-/
  • wadewade
    wadewade Posts: 735
    Part of the Furniture 100 Posts Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    edited 3 January 2011 at 9:23PM
    Hello, bikerchris, I'm afraid it's me again.


    As often happens with church things someone else has given me the benefit of his research on a suitable computer. I think he has been on the Easyworship site (whose software we use) and seems to have come up with their recommendations (although I am not sure how up to date this information is). Basicly he suggests we need to future-proof this system to be able to supply HD in future. The problem is none of his card numbers matches any of yours!!

    His note says:


    Video Cards

    Video cards should be purchased with either an AGP or PCI Express interface. Standard PCI video cards will work, but you will be unable to do quality video transitions and high definition video.

    We recommend using NVIDIA GeForce cards because of the ease of driver installation and Windows Extended desktop setup and overall performance. We do not recommend using the Nvidia Quadro chipset as they do not work well with EasyWorship.
    NVIDIA GeForce Video Cards
    • Basic: 5200, 5500, 6200, 8400, 9400, 9500
    • Standard: 7600, 7800, 8600, 9600
    • HD: 8800, 9800, GTS 250, GTS 260
    ATI Radeon HD (Desktop Computers Only)
    • Basic: 3450, 5450 Standard: 5770
    • HD: 3850, 4850, 5850
    If you have time, could you give me the benefit of your opinion again please?

    [Incidentally we have just bought a new computer for the church office - nothing to do with current discussion - which did come with an HD screen. It is Dell Inspiron 560 MT (D005620) - NVidia GeForce G310 512MB card but another card twice as big was also on offer at a supplement - yourATI Radeon™ HD 5450 1GB DDR3 graphics]



    Sorry to bother you again but this sort of thing seems to happen with us!

    Regards
  • bikerchris
    bikerchris Posts: 160
    Part of the Furniture 100 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    wadewade wrote: »
    Hello, bikerchris, I'm afraid it's me again.


    As often happens with church things someone else has given me the benefit of his research on a suitable computer. I think he has been on the Easyworship site (whose software we use) and seems to have come up with their recommendations (although I am not sure how up to date this information is). Basicly he suggests we need to future-proof this system to be able to supply HD in future. The problem is none of his card numbers matches any of yours!!

    Hello again wadewade,

    Yes, quite right, your colleague is referring to THIS PAGE

    I completely agree that future-proofing is highly recommended and I constantly push it to anyone that asked for my advice (however there is always a tipping point). I have read through this specification requirement and it slightly conflicts in my opinion. For instance the card available to a dell computer for you, is a Radeon "HD" 5450. However it then lists "HD" cards as if the others are not, when they are. A layman's check of this is that this card has an HDMI output.

    As extra future proofing, I would therefore recommend the XPS 8100 (D00X8101). This has an i3 (or an i5 if your budget can extend to it) CPU which exceeds the performance of those CPU's mentioned on the site (the easyworship web page is badly out of date for not mentioning this type of processor). If budget allows, go for the i5, but ensure that the wifi card similar in description to my previous recommendation is included.
    wadewade wrote: »
    His note says:

    Video Cards

    Video cards should be purchased with either an AGP or PCI Express interface. Standard PCI video cards will work, but you will be unable to do quality video transitions and high definition video.

    PCI Express is the most common of connection types these days, so again, an outdated statement (although of course useful for anyone that's getting an old donated machine)

    So, to conclude I would suggest as above. To compare, the following is a list of spec requirements from the website. In brackets is the spec suggested by myself:

    2.8 Ghz Intel dual core or quad core processor or better (3.2GHz and a better 'type' of CPU)
    1 GB RAM or more for XP / 2 GB RAM or more for Vista (3GB)
    SATA 7200 RPM Hard Drive with 8MB cache (This is a very typical spec' for a hard drive these days)
    500 MB of free disk space (320,000MB available)
    NVIDIA G-Force 8800 (interesting to note there are 5 different versions of the same card, i.e. different performance)

    Re; Anti-virus (note, this is a personal preference issue) I would recommend Avira and "Avira AntiVir Premium" to be specific (www.avira.com), it gets cheaper the longer you buy it for and you can get 3 years worth of protection for £35.94 and install it yourself (very easy). It could be a little cheaper as you may be a registered charity and claim the VAT back?

    It's also interesting to note that the easyworship website doesn't make it obvious that a monitor with HDCP capability is necessary should HD be used as an input method. A very important point for your future reference.

    I hope that helps and doesn't confuse things for you.
    If someone is worth thanking - click on the 'Thanks' button on their response. It's just a nice thing to do :-)

    Started debt at 17, stopped by 25 :-D ...I'm in debt again because of property :-/
  • wadewade
    wadewade Posts: 735
    Part of the Furniture 100 Posts Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    edited 3 January 2011 at 9:54PM
    Thank you for this explanation, I half suspected his information was a bit out of date.

    The XPS 8100 in fact comes with the same video card as our new office machine (512MB NVIDIA® GeForce™ G310 graphics card) but also offers an upgrade for £20 to

    ATI Radeon™ HD 5450 1GB DDR3 graphics

    I don't particularly want to go up in price but, if you thought it worth it, it would only be another £20. However the Easyworship page does suggest they favour the NVidia I think. Do you think we should stick with the Nvidia that Dell have included as standard?

    Thanks again for all your help.
  • wadewade wrote: »
    The XPS 8100 in fact comes with the same video card as our new office machine (512MB NVIDIA® GeForce™ G310 graphics card) but also offers an upgrade for £20 to

    ATI Radeon™ HD 5450 1GB DDR3 graphics

    I don't particularly want to go up in price but, if you thought it worth it, it would only be another £20. However the Easyworship page does suggest they favour the NVidia I think. Do you think we should stick with the Nvidia that Dell have included as standard?

    Thanks again for all your help.

    I wish they gave their reasons for having a preference for one company and not the other. If they provided specifics it would help, but there are incredibly few instances where one manufacturer is preferred to another (ATI vs Nvidia).

    For £20 you would do well to upgrade, it would be much more expensive to upgrade later on. As the Geforce card 'recommended' on the website is normally between 500-750MB, the 1GB (or 1000MB) upgrade would be advisable for future proofing. Although looking at the software gallery examples, I would doubt they'd ever do anything to push the performance needs any further.

    As a side note, if you heavily rely on the machine, bear in mind you should consider the possibility of a failure at around the 3 year mark with average usage. Come back then and ask what to do, hopefully I'll still be alive :A
    If someone is worth thanking - click on the 'Thanks' button on their response. It's just a nice thing to do :-)

    Started debt at 17, stopped by 25 :-D ...I'm in debt again because of property :-/
  • wadewade
    wadewade Posts: 735
    Part of the Furniture 100 Posts Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    I certainly hope you will be around for a long time. Bike carefully. If you ever feel the urge to move home to Wiltshire do let me know. There will always be a cup of coffee (and probably a few computer questions) ready for you!
  • wadewade wrote: »
    I certainly hope you will be around for a long time. Bike carefully. If you ever feel the urge to move home to Wiltshire do let me know. There will always be a cup of coffee (and probably a few computer questions) ready for you!

    Kind of you to say, I shall certainly ride carefully after my last incident (mentioned it in a bit of detail HERE). Thank you for the offer of a Wiltshire coffee (my mother originated from there) and computer questions - as my girlfriend says, I'm "poor but helpful"!

    All the best in the future,

    Chris
    If someone is worth thanking - click on the 'Thanks' button on their response. It's just a nice thing to do :-)

    Started debt at 17, stopped by 25 :-D ...I'm in debt again because of property :-/
  • prowla
    prowla Posts: 14,559
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper
    Forumite
    Dell do dual-head graphics cards, and you can get a DVI-VGA converter for a few quid (if it's not included with the card).

    It may even be that the existing PC's graphics are from an add-on, in which case it could be swapped to the new machine if funds are limited.
This discussion has been closed.
★ ★ ★ Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 355.9K Banking & Borrowing
  • 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 456.2K Spending & Discounts
  • 248.4K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 179.1K Life & Family
  • 264K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.7K Read-Only Boards
Quick Search

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.