📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Car options - thoughts needed!

DD265
DD265 Posts: 2,258
Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Photogenic Homepage Hero
Forumite
My car insurance is up for renewal (1st November) and the cheapest I've managed thus far is £1072.05 3rd Party, Fire & Theft with Tesco. I knew it would go up but that's a bit more than I expected. At this second I do not have the money for it. I'm selling frantically to try and raise some funds.

22 year old female
License with pass plus - over 3 years (license 08/07, PP 09/07)
Driving a Ford Fiesta Ghia 1.4l petrol 5 door - value of £500 (R reg) - fully owned. Great condition although it needs to go in for suspension when I have some money.

November '09 somebody drove into me and has put in a bogus claim, so I've lost all my no claims discount until it is resolved. Apparently if they just drop it, which it's looking like they might, I still lose my no claims discount.

In addition I am currently unemployed (put my premiums up) although I'm just waiting for confirmation of my acceptance of a job offer. I hope to start this job on the 25th which would give me 1 week's pay for October of roughly £250.

So thus far we can see four options.

1. Insure my car as cheaply as possible - looking at £90pm premiums plus £200 initial cost right now
2. (Dad's idea) Change to a car that's worth insuring with a value of £1500-2000 (I don't have the money, and I don't think he does either tbh)
3. Put me on Mum's car - a Freelander - and take mine off road. This will cost £125 until January when her insurance comes up for renewal. I'd have to contribute diesel but nothing else.
4. Public transport - awkward as sin but doable - £72 a month.

Any thoughts?

Obviously my preference is to keep my car on the road but the only one I can rule out for definite is option 2. I also think that option 4 is going to be a very costly one and extremely time consuming. I think running would be quicker, but not very safe in winter when it's dark on a canal tow path.

Really I think it's Fiesta vs. Freelander. I rarely do more than a 30mile round trip. My concerns with the Freelander are that it's a big car and sluggish - I do a lot of country lane driving and I'm nervous about that. If I did scrape it or slip on ice the repairs would cost a lot more to the Freelander.

The only other concern is that the Fiesta's MOT & Tax are both due 1st Jan so if I wanted to take it back on the road I'd have to find the funds for everything in one go...

Comments

  • anewman
    anewman Posts: 9,200
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    edited 15 October 2010 at 10:52PM
    DD265 wrote: »
    22 year old female
    License with pass plus - over 3 years (license 08/07, PP 09/07)
    Driving a Ford Fiesta Ghia 1.4l petrol 5 door - value of £500 (R reg) - fully owned. Great condition although it needs to go in for suspension when I have some money.

    1. Insure my car as cheaply as possible - looking at £90pm premiums plus £200 initial cost right now
    2. (Dad's idea) Change to a car that's worth insuring with a value of £1500-2000 (I don't have the money, and I don't think he does either tbh)
    3. Put me on Mum's car - a Freelander - and take mine off road. This will cost £125 until January when her insurance comes up for renewal. I'd have to contribute diesel but nothing else.
    4. Public transport - awkward as sin but doable - £72 a month.

    Wouldn't drive the freelander, increase in fuel cost will cost more than insurance.

    Option 2, sorry but to buy a more expensive car just to make the car worth more than cost of the insurance, when you are already not financially great is a rather stupid idea. You do not get any benefit whatsoever, and in fact you just spent a whole load of more money. Insurance can cost more than a car is worth, you either pay it or catch the bus instead.

    Regards insurance, try describing yourself as a housewife (should bring the cost down a bit instead of putting unemployed - as it means pretty much the same thing I can't see anything wrong with it). Then add parents as named drivers to your policy, even if they would be insured to drive your car under their own policy, as this can bring the cost down quite a bit. Also consider adding a boyfriend. Basically experiment with adding and removing people to see what makes it cost cheaper and what makes it cost more.

    Another option is to lay the car up, would need to be on a driveway (off the public roads etc), get a refund on the remaining road tax and declare it sorn, then when you get a job you can inure it and tax it and you're good to go.
  • _ollie_
    _ollie_ Posts: 49 Forumite
    Have you checked about putting one of your parents on your insurance as a driver of the car?
    Recently did insurance for my new car, and putting my Mum on it took off about £200. (Admiral)
  • Kilty_2
    Kilty_2 Posts: 5,818 Forumite
    Have you tried the providers that aren't on comparison sites? (Aviva are/were cheap for me and I'm a young driver with a reasonably powerful car)
  • forgotmyname
    forgotmyname Posts: 33,249
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper
    Forumite
    Try a quote for fulyl comp, It maybe cheaper.

    Adding an older driver who has not made a claim sometimes reduces the figure but do not
    put them as the main driver if they are not.
    Censorship Reigns Supreme in Troll City...

  • Fully comp worked out cheaper than TPFT with Tescos on one of mine this year.... Also if you have a clubacrd add it into the quote as you'll save a few quid.
  • DD265
    DD265 Posts: 2,258
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Photogenic Homepage Hero
    Forumite
    Kilty wrote: »
    Have you tried the providers that aren't on comparison sites? (Aviva are/were cheap for me and I'm a young driver with a reasonably powerful car)

    I have tried Direct Line and Admiral (Mum is insured with them but the Multicar policy actually works out really expensive) thus far. Not really sure how many others are out there but not on comparison sites.
    Try a quote for fulyl comp, It maybe cheaper.

    Adding an older driver who has not made a claim sometimes reduces the figure

    Fully comp came in at £1129.80, which is £60 more than TPFT. Whether it's worth paying the extra I don't know - if the car is worth £500, and the excess is £750, I'm never going to claim on it! I still get legal protection with the TPFT.

    It was also more expensive to have one (or both) of my parents as named drivers. Strange, because last year it brought the price down a bit.
    Also if you have a clubacrd add it into the quote as you'll save a few quid.

    I registered for a clubcard, but it never came through the post. I'll see about getting one re-ordered or something. I never bothered (only needed to register to buy a camera online) because we all put points onto Mum's clubcard account as she does the household shopping and benefits most from the points. I doubt that I could put her card on the policy though.
  • DD265 wrote: »
    I have tried Direct Line and Admiral (Mum is insured with them but the Multicar policy actually works out really expensive) thus far. Not really sure how many others are out there but not on comparison sites.



    Fully comp came in at £1129.80, which is £60 more than TPFT. Whether it's worth paying the extra I don't know - if the car is worth £500, and the excess is £750, I'm never going to claim on it! I still get legal protection with the TPFT.

    It was also more expensive to have one (or both) of my parents as named drivers. Strange, because last year it brought the price down a bit.



    I registered for a clubcard, but it never came through the post. I'll see about getting one re-ordered or something. I never bothered (only needed to register to buy a camera online) because we all put points onto Mum's clubcard account as she does the household shopping and benefits most from the points. I doubt that I could put her card on the policy though.


    Yeh you can... I used somebody elses:j
This discussion has been closed.
★ ★ ★ Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 355.9K Banking & Borrowing
  • 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 456.2K Spending & Discounts
  • 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 179.1K Life & Family
  • 264K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.7K Read-Only Boards
Quick Search

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.