Which one would you choose?

tinalives

If you were me, which one of the following deals would you take?

Scottish Power fixed until Aug 09, costing 20% (£160):

Gas - 4.705 for first 1143 kwh p/qtr then 2.910 thereafter
Electric - 18.778 for first 225kwh p/qtr then 8.836 thereafter

OR

Eon Price Protection fixed until Oct 09, costing 27% (£211):

Gas - 5.081 for first 670 kwh p/qtr then 3.239 thereafter
Electric - 21.263 for first 225 kwh p/qtr then 11.739 thereafter.

tinalives

Any input would be very much appreciated.

bryanb

It depends, you have not given consumption figures.

tinalives

Aaah, I see.

Right, my gas is approx 16873kwh and electric is 3624kwh - I ve had to estimate as I don't have a full year of figures.

Thanks.

tinalives

I signed up for the Eon deal yesterday - but now I'm having cold feet.

I think I'm going to cancel with them and go for the Scottish Power one instead.

Sooo frustrating.