Puppy Pain

Samantha99 · 13 June 2017 at 5:06PM

I purchased a puppy from a breeder and paid for it in full. We had a verbal contract as well as text but no paper was signed.

That breeder has now let me down and has refused me a puppy. They say they intend to refund me.

Has the breeder broken their contract with me?
You can imagine the expenditure as well as puppy price: collars, leads, bowls, bed, bedding, crate, toys etc as well as a fully paid for training course for seven weeks. Also this has caused a lot of distress. Can I take them to the small claims court?

theonlywayisup · 13 June 2017 at 5:11PM

When you say 'refused' did they deem you unsuitable or give another reason?

Can you get another puppy?

When was the puppy due to be handed over? Did you seriously book a 7 week course and pay in full....

LilElvis · 13 June 2017 at 5:12PM

You are entitled to a refund for what you paid for the puppy. The other items you can use when you do get a puppy.

Samantha99 · 13 June 2017 at 5:12PM

Another reason was given. Classes don't start for a couple of months but it's important to book early

naedanger · 13 June 2017 at 5:18PM

Samantha99 wrote: »

I purchased a puppy from a breeder and paid for it in full. We had a verbal contract as well as text but no paper was signed.

That breeder has now let me down and has refused me a puppy. They say they intend to refund me.

Has the breeder broken their contract with me?
You can imagine the expenditure as well as puppy price: collars, leads, bowls, bed, bedding, crate, toys etc as well as a fully paid for training course for seven weeks. Also this has caused a lot of distress. Can I take them to the small claims court?

Did you purchase a specific puppy (e.g. one that you saw) or just a puppy of breed x?

And what was their reason for now refusing to supply it?

Samantha99 · 13 June 2017 at 5:19PM

They said they'd decided to keep it. But I wasn't offered an alternative.

naedanger · 13 June 2017 at 5:21PM

Samantha99 wrote: »

They said they'd decided to keep it. But I wasn't offered an alternative.

And was it a specific puppy e.g. one you had seen?

bris · 13 June 2017 at 5:25PM

A puppy like any other livestock is just goods in the end like anything else for sale.

It looks to me like the contract was formed and finalised so to me they have breached the contract.

The courts can uphold the contract and make them hand over the puppy if he still has it in the timescale it would take to get to court. Or you could buy another from a different breeder and sue for loss of bargain if there is a significant price difference after you have done your due diligence and mitigated the loss.

The other item including the training course could be seen as a consequential loss but again you would need to mitigate this loss by getting a refund (if the option is available) or selling them for the best price you can get for them.

But in theory there is a very good chance you would win, the fact he accepted the asking price and it is confirmed by text make any claim pretty good.

angryparcel · 13 June 2017 at 5:25PM

Samantha99 wrote: »

They said they'd decided to keep it. But I wasn't offered an alternative.

you are only entitled to the cost of the puppy refunded.

why book course so early as you cannot take puppy out until it is about 11/12 weeks, so from time of getting puppy at 8 weeks then you should book course then.

Samantha99 · 13 June 2017 at 5:44PM

Yes it was a specific puppy.

The course doesn't start till September. I am a seasoned dog owner

angryparcel · 13 June 2017 at 5:50PM

Samantha99 wrote: »

Yes it was a specific puppy.

The course doesn't start till September. I am a seasoned dog owner

I would still not book a course until i had the puppy

Puppy Pain

Comments

Categories

Get our FREE Weekly email full of deals & guides - and it’s spam-free