We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING
Hello Forumites! However well-intentioned, for the safety of other users we ask that you refrain from seeking or offering medical advice. This includes recommendations for medicines, procedures or over-the-counter remedies. Posts or threads found to be in breach of this rule will be removed.📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Tightwad versus De-clutter

vfairbrass
Posts: 153 Forumite
I got the Complete Tightwad Gazette for Christmas this year and am working slowly through it - a fantastic book with lots of useful ideas. BUT last Christmas's book was one on De-cluttering which I also took to like a duck to water and have decluttered the whole house as much as possible. Tightwad seems to imply a massive amount of clutter in that you save absolutely everything, just in case. How can I combine the two philosophies?
Valerie
Valerie
0
Comments
-
Yes, I know what you mean - I straddle the same two philosophies too. I keep things like margerine tubs and storage things because I don't see them as clutter as I will need them one day soon, if I amass too many then they have to go but half a dozen plastic tubs or whatever seems reasonable. If you can put them away out of sight in the garage or the back of a cupboard too that helps, so long as you remember that you have them of course!
Things like the home insurance documents from 5 years ago are clutter and of no use at all, these have all gone0 -
You can only prioritise what means "clutter" against "being prepared" based on your own storage capacities/needs.
I loved the theory of buying clothes for children in all different sizes and having labelled boxes all neatly arranged ... but, that wouldn't be practicable in my circumstances (space!). However, what I do tend to do, is to buy one year ahead - for example, this time last year, I spent money in the sales buying up clothes for the lads ready for now; I'm waiting for the prices to reach rock bottom so I can do the same again this year, although I have bought some already.
I'm slowly but surely working my way through the clutter in our home .. but a lot of what's stored is from when dh was married to his first wife :rolleyes: (loooooong time ago ... looooooots of hidden clutter!).
Once I have those spaces, maybe I'll be a bit more generous to what I will store ahead and what I won'tMy personal priorities (which might equate to someone else's clutter) are fabrics, books, notions, books, certain magazines and erm ... books. I also view TWG as a great book but not all of her ideas are suited to my way of doing things; so I take from it that which suits and disregard the rest.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
PMS Pot: £57.53 Pigsback Pot: £23.00
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0 -
I think if you haven`t used something for a year,then you are unlikely to use it.Also if you found something in the back of the cupboard and think to yourself that I forgot I had that or I didn`t even know I had one of those.These sorts of things are ideal to chuck.
When declutering sometimes you need to be ruthless with yourself and dont let the thought of "I might need this in ,2019,so I best just keep hold of it"
I tend to feel better when I have a good declutter of one room.Also I very quickly forget what I`ve already chucked out.Debt Free Date:10/09/2007 :j :money:0 -
I think a bit of a key to marrying the two styles is not to buy things you don't actually *need*. A few pieces of packaging from food like ice cream tubs, don't create clutter alone. Clutter often tends to come from things we buy thinking "we'll use them sometime" or "that's a bargain" and it doesn't turn out to be the case.Softstuff- Officially better than 0070
-
Im so pleased someone has asked this question as im struggling with what to keep and throw.Last year i had a major declutter of the whole house due to the feng shui thread and boy did i feel good.My housework was a reduced by at least half and my life seemed easier without all the extra hassles and mess.
Now im back to where i started again after being a tightwad.I keep saying to myself "now what would Amy tightwad do with this",so i keep everything and buy everything thats cheap and sometimes useless things because im so tight.A typical example is,i was trawling around the sale items in matalan and come across a pair of shoes,they were only £1,wow i thaught,its a shame they wernt very nice but for a £1 they would be ok and i might learn to like them.The worst thing is that they are a size 6 and im in a size 5.0 -
squiggles - dye them? Wear with thick socks? Charity shop???? Some things just aren't moneysaving in the longer term
:whistle:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
PMS Pot: £57.53 Pigsback Pot: £23.00
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0 -
Lol, I was thinking along these same lines this morning (ok, well more along 'how to 'flylady' and OS MS at the same time)
I've a load of jars (collected because when I wanted to make chutney/jam I didn't have any. Now I've no space - I need to build shelves for it, but that's more £'s too (if I can find the time to put them up in the understairs cupboard)
I got rid of all papers that were out of date (no, not newspapers, the letter type). I've been divorced for a few years, we moved away from the army 6 years ago - and now I need his army number..... but guess what was amongst the stuff that went? Anything that was his of course!
I always end up needing what I decluttered and falling over what I don't, lol.January '06 Grocery Challenge (4th - 31st) £320.Week 1 - £73.99 Week 2 £5.10 (so far)
Someone burst my bubble and I lost the plot so no idea what I spent now...Other Jan :- Petrol £20.41, Clothes £8.50, House £3.I will try to work it out.
0 -
I only have a small house and I'm a tidy person so I declutter once a month. I do find that there are some things that I do hang on to eg margarine pots are great for the freezer but I have allocated spaces for them. With glass jars and bottles that I know will be used [other ones go straight into recycling] I have a cardboard box in the garage. Once it's full I then put all subsequent jars into recycling or I swap one. You have to be fairly ruthless. I also have a box in our spare room next to the pc where I keep scrap paper for lists etc. It also pays to regularly check what you've got pinned up on your notice board and what's in your intray if like me you have one for post. I even have a drawer for receipts for doing accounts so I can shred them monthly. I buy clothes a year in advance for my son and then keep them in the top of his wardrobe in bags etc etc I even keep a bag going for stuff for the charity shop on the go all the time so I can keep slinging stuff in there [I've just turned out all summer clothes that small person has outgrown in preparation for the jumble sale coming up this Sat]. I've also got my own small craft basket that sits behind my arm chair [I,m one for hiding things] and an old linen basket in my bedroom where I keep all my lovely scrap fabrics and odds and ends of ribbon. I pretty much know what I've got most of the time but maybe I'm a bit anal about it all. I like to have organised and manageable treasures!!
ArilAiming for a life of elegant frugality wearing a new-to-me silk shirt rather than one of hair!0 -
Oh so I'm not the only one then :rotfl: I have a terrible hoarding habit but am trying to 'fly' at the same time whilst being a OS tightwad...As other posters have said its all about taking the bits you need from all the systems but sadly I'm too disorganised to ever have a hope of doing this
I am getting better and have actually thrown stuff out of my loft over xmas,only to quickly fill it up with my decluttered stuff from the house :rolleyes:
0 -
I'm quite good at decluttering*, and often don't need to resort to the one year rule.
To implement my one year rule, if I come across some items that I'm just not sure its right to get rid of I put them out of sight somewhere, usually in a box in the loft. I write the date on the box.
If I find I need it, then it comes back. But usually, once its in the loft it's forgotten.
Every so often when I am in the loft I pull out the boxes that are oder than a year and if I - or my DH - haven't missed the item then I dispose of it (sell/freecycle/charity shop).
I do the same sort of things with my husbands clothes. He never wants to get rid of old stuff...so I just secrete it away into a drawer in the spare room. If he hasn't missed it one year later, I get rid of it.
*I once had to empty my grandfathers house. He literally never threw ANYTHING away because it "might come in handy". "e found boxes and boxes of empty sugar packets, egg boxes, and Pedigree Chum tins, and newspapers going back about thirty years. You couldn't move in his house for crap. This cured me of any hoarding habit I might have been harbouring! Now if we find ourselves saying that something might "come in handy" it goes straight in the "one year box".0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 350.4K Banking & Borrowing
- 252.9K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.3K Spending & Discounts
- 243.4K Work, Benefits & Business
- 598K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 176.6K Life & Family
- 256.5K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards