We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Mobile for Child going to Secondary School
WorkingHardDFW
Posts: 1,324 Forumite
in Mobiles
Help:o
Oldest DD is going to secondary school in September and is after the ubiquitous mobile phone for her birthday in July. Sadly she is the one of only 2 in her small class currently without a mobile!
Being concious of the cost both initially and ongoing I am planning to do a few weeks of research into the best options however I have no idea what sort of call/texting pattern an young 11 year will have. Is it the calls they hammer or the texts or both?
Can any of you more experienced parents out there offer any advice?
Much appreciated.
Oldest DD is going to secondary school in September and is after the ubiquitous mobile phone for her birthday in July. Sadly she is the one of only 2 in her small class currently without a mobile!
Being concious of the cost both initially and ongoing I am planning to do a few weeks of research into the best options however I have no idea what sort of call/texting pattern an young 11 year will have. Is it the calls they hammer or the texts or both?
Can any of you more experienced parents out there offer any advice?
Much appreciated.
Working Hard to be Debt Free - one day :A soon
DFW Long Hauler 74; Mortgage overpayments MFiT-2 challenger 100
Total Nov07 £36000, Sep10 £1623:o:)
0
Comments
-
Mine use texting far more often than calls.
Although you often get more for your money with a monthly contract, I would advise PAYG, then at least the amount of credit you put on is limited and they can't overspend.0 -
I've just bought mine cheapish Orange PAYG phones and put them on the tariff which gives them 300 free texts (valid for 30 days) when they top up by £10.
Unfortunately I bought the phones and they were registered a couple of weeks before birthdays so they only had 2 weeks to use up all the texts - somehow they managed it!
They hardly text now as they know they have to pay for top ups but they will get another 300 free texts when they do top up.
Hope that helps.0 -
Thanks KEM & fiscalfreckles for your input.
Its seems such a difficult choice at present given I hardly use my phone (Orange PAYG with 5 free texts per day - an old deal no longer available) so I manage to only top up every other month!! Bargain and very MSE.
My OH's is a company one so there isn't any cost.
I don't want a big monthly committment (monthly budget is tight) but I do want to ensure that what I get is right for my DS. She needs to be aware that its costs money....
Some thorough research is coming my way ................Working Hard to be Debt Free - one day :A soonDFW Long Hauler 74; Mortgage overpayments MFiT-2 challenger 100Total Nov07 £36000, Sep10 £1623:o:)0 -
personally i think the O2 pay as you go sim is a good one.
If you top up £10 every month, you get 300 texts. Plus £10 to spend, on calls, or other texts, etc.
After every text/call a message appears saying how much £ you have left. And to check your current balance is usually 2 then call, again the balance appears on screen. I prefer this to Orange where you have to ring a number and a voice tells you how much you have left. Plus in my experience O2 has best coverage.
A quick look shows they dont have the cheapest phones though, maybe get a cheap unlocked one from play or somewhere, hope that helps, cheers
0 -
i totally agree withe above my 11 yr old on o2 when you top with 10 u get 300 texts free, wuth £10 credit this lasts about 2 months, this means however you will have to pay out for the phone in the begining.and if your 11yr old is like mine that could be an expense.0
-
I was also pondering the bluebook "feature" of O2 which would in theory allow a parent to monitor the SMS and MMS usage of a mobile phone. Would be wondering if this would be worthwhile given the alleged rise in cyber bullying. If you are honest about its existence and why you want to have it, plus stop it logging messages to and from their friends (so they maintain their privacy), surely it's a good thing? (If it is out of beta, it has a one-off cost of £5, otherwise it might be free).
If you start spending more than £22.50 a month (225 texts at 10p ) you could move to a SIMplicity one month contract (30 days notice required to cancel) for £22.50 which has 200 minutes, 400 texts, free O2 to O2 calls (for £15) and free SMS messages (via additional £7.50 bolt on). Only problem is reverse charged texts are outside the allowance, so if their "friends" text one of these £X chat lines I see advertised on TV after 11pm or in other magazines you could get lumped with a bill.... thinking of which, you can block access to premium rate numbers, can you block access to premium rate message services? Heck, I'd like that myself....
For buying phones, there's a pink Nokia 6111 for £50 unlocked on Amazon or a £30 O2 PAYG Nokia 2310 from CPW. There are cheap handsets, but it depends on whether it also need to be a status symbol.*I reserve the right to have an opinion, the right to change this opinion and the right to be wrong.*Hope that helps. If you find this post useful, please feel free to hit the V V V V V V 'Thanks' button below0 -
Wow thanks for the advice.
I'm lucky is the DD's interest is the phone is 'slide' or 'flip' - definately not a status symbol.
Clearly the cost of the PAYG package and the amount/value of free texts is one concern. I guess I am assuming from replies that its the texts the kids go for rather than the calls.
Additionally the cost of the handset. Question does and 'unlocked' handset mean that with the correct SIM it can go on any network?Working Hard to be Debt Free - one day :A soonDFW Long Hauler 74; Mortgage overpayments MFiT-2 challenger 100Total Nov07 £36000, Sep10 £1623:o:)0 -
I have just ordered a contract from dialaphone that works out at £30 for a year with a monthly tariff of 200 mins and 200 texts with the samsung e250
breakdown is £30 a month x 12 = 360
less cashback of £270 ( 90 ant months 6 9 and 12 )
less quidco of £60
Total cost = £30 for the year
cashback is paid within a week and they send you a text confirming receipt of claim. All you do is send the bill after x date and a cheque follows within a week / 10 days
My son had one last year and this year its daughters turn.0 -
WorkingHardDFW wrote: »Clearly the cost of the PAYG package and the amount/value of free texts is one concern. I guess I am assuming from replies that its the texts the kids go for rather than the calls.
If you look at how they are used, you can send SMS messages to other people in a class room environment like passing notes, but you cannot make phone calls.
There are people who will even change their ring tone to a buzz that is inaudible to most adults (like a cat scarer - I can probably find a link if you want to try it) in order to be able to send and receive messages behind the teachers back.WorkingHardDFW wrote: »Additionally the cost of the handset. Question does and 'unlocked' handset mean that with the correct SIM it can go on any network?
You're right, if most people write "unlocked" they mean SIM unlocked in that the phone is not locked to the SIMs from a particular network. With a lot of locked phones they can be unlocked quite cheaply (some even for free), but it depends on both the make and model (and some times the network).*I reserve the right to have an opinion, the right to change this opinion and the right to be wrong.*Hope that helps. If you find this post useful, please feel free to hit the V V V V V V 'Thanks' button below0 -
WorkingHardDFW wrote: »Help:o
Oldest DD is going to secondary school in September and is after the ubiquitous mobile phone for her birthday in July. Sadly she is the one of only 2 in her small class currently without a mobile!
Being concious of the cost both initially and ongoing I am planning to do a few weeks of research into the best options however I have no idea what sort of call/texting pattern an young 11 year will have. Is it the calls they hammer or the texts or both?
Can any of you more experienced parents out there offer any advice?
Much appreciated.
Exactly the same scenario we are facing this year. Have done some research and if we go the PAYG route I'm thinking about Tesco with the double/triple top up offer.
Phone is not a status symbol but she would like a half decent camera and video recorder.
Quite a few good 2 year contract deals about with cashback too. Vodafone £10 per month for 100 mins and 500 texts is an example.
Any ideas much appreciated.
0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 352.2K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.6K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454.3K Spending & Discounts
- 245.2K Work, Benefits & Business
- 600.9K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.5K Life & Family
- 259K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards