📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Taking more lump sum decision

Hi, would welcome thoughts on this. Have a good DB pension which has increased wuite a lot of last 18 months. It will form basis of pension funds. Rises with inflation. Current age is 55. Looking to retire in next 12 months. DB pension with age reduction at 56 is £40000. Have a SIPP of £200000. Lump sum of £99000 at 56, can't change this. I will have state pension at 67. Lump sum is 12.1 factoring in tax at 20% which I will be liable for it's 15.1. Thinking of reducing the DB pension to £35000 so I can take as much as possible out of SIPP before 67 and hopefully avoid higher rate tax at SP age. I know the lump sum commutation rate isn't great but just trying to juggle tax etc and thinking of options. Looking for about £4000 a month after tax. May have a few big ticket items to sort such as car and some house upgrades. Mortgage paid.

«1

Comments

  • Triumph13
    Triumph13 Posts: 2,218
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper I've been Money Tipped!
    Forumite

    It would take very little growth on your SIPP to push you into higher rate tax, even if you do take maximum commutation. Without it, it is pretty well nailed on as you wouldn't be able to empty the SIPP at 20% before your SP kicks in. That makes it more likely a 20:1 ratio post tax.

    It still comes down though to what gives you higher utility - a bigger guaranteed income or more cash in hand.

  • hugheskevi
    hugheskevi Posts: 4,964
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Photogenic Name Dropper
    Forumite
    edited 14 November at 12:37PM

    Thinking of reducing the DB pension to £35000 so I can take as much as possible out of SIPP before 67 and hopefully avoid higher rate tax at SP age.

    At age 56, your life expectancy will be late 80s, so about 30 years or so.

    For every £1 of pension converted to lump sum, it would take 15 years of pension payments to equal lump sum at basic rate, and 20 years at higher rate. That ignores investment returns on lump sum, and inflation increases on pension. Given life expectancy of around 30 years, that is a terrible commutation rate for a 56 year old.

    You don't appear to have a great need for lump sum cash given the £35,000 automatic lump sum, and any deficit could be made good from the DC lump sum if necessary via drawdown. It is hard to see any justification for ravaging the value of the DB pension via the terrible commutation rate - it would avoid higher rate tax either partially or entirely, but it is probably going to be better overall value paying the tax.

    I think fiscal drag is going to mean higher rate tax is an inevitability for you sooner or later. You could take DB pension with standard lump sum, use Marriage Allowance if relevant, and withdraw from DC up to higher rate tax each year using UFPLS (or drawdown if you want immediate capital). That has a decent chance of keeping you out of higher rate tax until State Pension age. If you die before age 75 the DC pension would be passed on free of income tax, so that would avoid higher rate tax too.

    An alternative could be to defer the DB pension until age 60 (or higher), and use DC pension to draw up to higher rate tax. As you get older, the commutation rate improves. So at 60 or whenever commuting the pension for lump sum wouldn't be such bad value. Although even 60 gives poor terms.

  • jp2026
    jp2026 Posts: 17
    Fifth Anniversary 10 Posts
    Forumite

    Thanks, yes that's what I am grappling with especially as both DB and SP will rise with inflation and it doesn't look like higher rate tax is shifting any time soon. Really appreciate the comments. All thoughts welcome!

  • kempiejon
    kempiejon Posts: 1,213
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    Forumite

    There is some advantage to leverage the tax treatments. I've read messages here from people wanting to reduce the tax bill particularly higher rate come state pension. The obvious solution to me being to delay taking it. There is also an uplift for doing that. More SIPP funds can be extracted each year, often a desire for inheritance tax planning.

  • ali_bear
    ali_bear Posts: 727
    Fourth Anniversary 500 Posts Photogenic Name Dropper
    Forumite

    The state pension starts at 67 normally, but you can defer taking it later if that suits you. Not sure about the exact terms but I believe they are equitable.

    Paying some tax in the 40% band is not the worst thing that could happen

    🐻 A little FIRE lights the cigar 
  • RogerPensionGuy
    RogerPensionGuy Posts: 1,005
    Fourth Anniversary 500 Posts Photogenic Name Dropper
    Forumite

    To OP.

    Just to be clear is the following correct.

    DB pension is 40K PA at age 56 and on activion at age 56 the scheme pays out 99K lump sum which is tax free.

    If you commute any of that 40K PA the rate is X 15 and so using 5K that will produce 75K more tax free.

    If the above is correct that would be 35K DB and call state pension 13K in todays money, that's a starting point of 48K PA in todays money, just 2K away liklihood of 40% tax in todays money.

    The SIPP is 200K, so hopefully at least 50K TFLS there or required.

    So assuming the above is correct and you don't want to possibly pay much 40% you could take 15K PA outa the SIPP pre state pension and maybe fill an ISA.

    If the numbers work out, you could maybe pay in £2,880/3K PA in to the SIPP for some years if the numbers agree it suits.

    Cheers Roger.

  • jp2026
    jp2026 Posts: 17
    Fifth Anniversary 10 Posts
    Forumite

    Yes, that's correct, thanks Roger

  • Dazed_and_C0nfused
    Dazed_and_C0nfused Posts: 19,633
    10,000 Posts Sixth Anniversary Name Dropper
    Forumite
    edited 14 November at 5:00PM

    I thought you said the commutation rate was 12:1.

    So doesn't £5k of inflation proofed pension, payable for maybe 50 years (if lucky 😉) get you £60k tax free PCLS?

  • mrklaw
    mrklaw Posts: 479
    Part of the Furniture 100 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    edited 14 November at 4:13PM

    bear in mind even if you hit 40%, its only 30% effectively if you blend in tax free cash. And only on the portion over 50k.

    so from 56 you have 11 years you could take another 10000 taxable or 13333 total gross from the SIPP under basic rate tax. Taxed at 15% effective would be £11333 net. Over 11 years that would move 13333*11=146,663 almost 150k from your SIPP and still basic rate.

    lets say your SIPP grows so you still have another 110k in there you want to move out before state pension age as you’ll be HRT by then. so you withdraw 10k gross per year over 11 years. at 30% effective tax thats 7k net per year. you’ve paid 3k in tax vs basic rate which would have been £1500 in tax. So £1500 more in tax per year. over 11 years, 11*1500=16,500 more in tax.

    but if you wait until state pension age everything you take above SP+DB will be taxable at 30% which is likely to be even more.

    so I’d consider a strategy of maxing basic rate and accepting a little bit of HRT would work ok (or leave some in the SIPP and stop at the top of basic rate if you dno’t need it)

  • Triumph13
    Triumph13 Posts: 2,218
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper I've been Money Tipped!
    Forumite

    The maths alone won't tell you which way to jump. It's all about how useful each option is to you.

    Regarding income, if you are a frugal soul and can't really see yourself ever spending more than £35k pa (pre tax), then the extra £5k doesn't move the dial. If, OTOH, even with the full £40k plus SP you are going to find it tight, then you probably wouldn't want to give up that guaranteed income.

    Similarly with the lump sum. If it's just going to sit in a cash ISA for a rainy day, never be touched and you don't care about inheritance, then the extra lump sum is pretty worthless. OTOH, if you owe Big Tony that 60 large and he's going to break your legs if you don't pay up, then it might have a rather higher utility!

★ ★ ★ Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 355.9K Banking & Borrowing
  • 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 456.2K Spending & Discounts
  • 248.4K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 606.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 179.1K Life & Family
  • 264K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.7K Read-Only Boards
Quick Search

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.