The Top Regular Savers Discussion Thread

Bridlington1

gt94sss2 said:

trickydicky14 said:

Melton BS Regular saver 5.
The above account allows withdrawals via passbook or nominated bank account. Well I can see I have a nominated bank account with Melton set up but for the life of me I cannot see how to withdraw money to that account can anyone help me out please.

You need to send a secure message if requesting a withdrawal online.

Best to include the last 4 digits of your account number and the last 2 digits of the sort code for your nominated bank account in your request.

In addition you can also phone them and they'll do the payments there and then. Worth noting they'll also let you do internal transfers using both methods, I've done this a few times where I've requested funds from one Melton RS be split between my other Melton Regular Savers.

Hattie627

BestSeagull said:

Hattie627 said:

janusdesign said:

Hattie627 said:

janusdesign said:

BestSeagull said:

s71hj said:

So my Principality RS issue 3 maturity instructions now show online. The RS 4 is an option, which is wasn't on the letter I received. It feels like the jury is out on here whether timing or random chance dictates whether /how to get such a request through successfully when you already have an RS 4
 I'm wondering if today as a non working day followed by a busy Monday morning would. be worth a try. Thoughts? 

You know, I was wondering myself (after putting it down to luck originally), if timing has anything to do with it. I thought about submitting a last minute request as perhaps then it would be too late to deny? And it's probably just coincidence but I noticed that both of my rejection messages arrived on a Tuesday.

i've just gone through my last 4 maturity instructions - the one yesterday (Saturday morning) and the other 3 were all submitted Thursday lunchtimes... the last two, both rejected, were replied to by she with no name; the one before that accepted by another member of staff and the fourth was unsigned (but accepted)... 3 replies within 30 mins of submitting, the other was next day... I would suggest that if you haven't been rejected after a working day or two of submission, you'll get the maturity choice you requested.

one interesting point that I just noticed is that when you submit the maturity choice online (the yellow box within the product), it actually generates a secure message to PBS - when I looked in the "Sent" folder of the secure messages, I can see the maturity choices I made using the forms, had generated secure messages containing those instructions... I think the Maturity options link from the top menu also generates a similar secure message to them.

therefore, I think it's literally a case of who happens to checking the generated secure messages at the time - if submitted during working hours, it will usually be dealt with quickly; if submitted overnight/weekend, it will be dealt with next working day... but there would be no way to know in advance of submission who, in the digital team, would be dealing with it (much like who you get when you call them).

I think I may have solved it, maybe ?

I did maturity instructions yesterday morning for my Issue 3 maturing 13th September, asking for a rollover to Issue 4. They have been acknowledged by the appearance of the yellow box confirming receipt of instructions and promising to implement on maturity. 

did you request £200 to a new RS 4 and the rest of the balance elsewhere - or did you choose another option?

Yes, those were my instructions.

@Hattie627 Both the second -"Take some money out and move the rest into a new savings account". and the 4th -"Take out all your money and open a new Regular Saver Bond" options allow you to request £200 to a new 6 month RS 4. Do you remember which one you chose? 

ETA I looked back at my messages and it looks like I chose "Moving some of my balance to a new savings account" on both occasions as a message to that effect was sent to them.  So I am going with take out all your money and open a new RS this time!

I'd be lying if I said that I could definitely recall which option I chose but I'm about 75% sure that it was option 4 (take out all your money and open a new Regular Saver Bond)

Edited to add: you may well have hit upon how to avoid a secure message being sent, well done.

janusd

Hattie627 said:

BestSeagull said:

Hattie627 said:

janusdesign said:

Hattie627 said:

janusdesign said:

BestSeagull said:

s71hj said:

So my Principality RS issue 3 maturity instructions now show online. The RS 4 is an option, which is wasn't on the letter I received. It feels like the jury is out on here whether timing or random chance dictates whether /how to get such a request through successfully when you already have an RS 4
 I'm wondering if today as a non working day followed by a busy Monday morning would. be worth a try. Thoughts? 

You know, I was wondering myself (after putting it down to luck originally), if timing has anything to do with it. I thought about submitting a last minute request as perhaps then it would be too late to deny? And it's probably just coincidence but I noticed that both of my rejection messages arrived on a Tuesday.

i've just gone through my last 4 maturity instructions - the one yesterday (Saturday morning) and the other 3 were all submitted Thursday lunchtimes... the last two, both rejected, were replied to by she with no name; the one before that accepted by another member of staff and the fourth was unsigned (but accepted)... 3 replies within 30 mins of submitting, the other was next day... I would suggest that if you haven't been rejected after a working day or two of submission, you'll get the maturity choice you requested.

one interesting point that I just noticed is that when you submit the maturity choice online (the yellow box within the product), it actually generates a secure message to PBS - when I looked in the "Sent" folder of the secure messages, I can see the maturity choices I made using the forms, had generated secure messages containing those instructions... I think the Maturity options link from the top menu also generates a similar secure message to them.

therefore, I think it's literally a case of who happens to checking the generated secure messages at the time - if submitted during working hours, it will usually be dealt with quickly; if submitted overnight/weekend, it will be dealt with next working day... but there would be no way to know in advance of submission who, in the digital team, would be dealing with it (much like who you get when you call them).

I think I may have solved it, maybe ?

I did maturity instructions yesterday morning for my Issue 3 maturing 13th September, asking for a rollover to Issue 4. They have been acknowledged by the appearance of the yellow box confirming receipt of instructions and promising to implement on maturity. 

did you request £200 to a new RS 4 and the rest of the balance elsewhere - or did you choose another option?

Yes, those were my instructions.

@Hattie627 Both the second -"Take some money out and move the rest into a new savings account". and the 4th -"Take out all your money and open a new Regular Saver Bond" options allow you to request £200 to a new 6 month RS 4. Do you remember which one you chose? 

ETA I looked back at my messages and it looks like I chose "Moving some of my balance to a new savings account" on both occasions as a message to that effect was sent to them.  So I am going with take out all your money and open a new RS this time!

I'd be lying if I said that I could definitely recall which option I chose but I'm about 75% sure that it was option 4 (take out all your money and open a new Regular Saver Bond)

I assumed that was their 4.85% variable 1-Year RS rather than the 7.50% fixed 6-Month Issue 4 ?

Hattie627

janusdesign said:

Hattie627 said:

BestSeagull said:

Hattie627 said:

janusdesign said:

Hattie627 said:

janusdesign said:

BestSeagull said:

s71hj said:

So my Principality RS issue 3 maturity instructions now show online. The RS 4 is an option, which is wasn't on the letter I received. It feels like the jury is out on here whether timing or random chance dictates whether /how to get such a request through successfully when you already have an RS 4
 I'm wondering if today as a non working day followed by a busy Monday morning would. be worth a try. Thoughts? 

You know, I was wondering myself (after putting it down to luck originally), if timing has anything to do with it. I thought about submitting a last minute request as perhaps then it would be too late to deny? And it's probably just coincidence but I noticed that both of my rejection messages arrived on a Tuesday.

i've just gone through my last 4 maturity instructions - the one yesterday (Saturday morning) and the other 3 were all submitted Thursday lunchtimes... the last two, both rejected, were replied to by she with no name; the one before that accepted by another member of staff and the fourth was unsigned (but accepted)... 3 replies within 30 mins of submitting, the other was next day... I would suggest that if you haven't been rejected after a working day or two of submission, you'll get the maturity choice you requested.

one interesting point that I just noticed is that when you submit the maturity choice online (the yellow box within the product), it actually generates a secure message to PBS - when I looked in the "Sent" folder of the secure messages, I can see the maturity choices I made using the forms, had generated secure messages containing those instructions... I think the Maturity options link from the top menu also generates a similar secure message to them.

therefore, I think it's literally a case of who happens to checking the generated secure messages at the time - if submitted during working hours, it will usually be dealt with quickly; if submitted overnight/weekend, it will be dealt with next working day... but there would be no way to know in advance of submission who, in the digital team, would be dealing with it (much like who you get when you call them).

I think I may have solved it, maybe ?

I did maturity instructions yesterday morning for my Issue 3 maturing 13th September, asking for a rollover to Issue 4. They have been acknowledged by the appearance of the yellow box confirming receipt of instructions and promising to implement on maturity. 

did you request £200 to a new RS 4 and the rest of the balance elsewhere - or did you choose another option?

Yes, those were my instructions.

@Hattie627 Both the second -"Take some money out and move the rest into a new savings account". and the 4th -"Take out all your money and open a new Regular Saver Bond" options allow you to request £200 to a new 6 month RS 4. Do you remember which one you chose? 

ETA I looked back at my messages and it looks like I chose "Moving some of my balance to a new savings account" on both occasions as a message to that effect was sent to them.  So I am going with take out all your money and open a new RS this time!

I'd be lying if I said that I could definitely recall which option I chose but I'm about 75% sure that it was option 4 (take out all your money and open a new Regular Saver Bond)

I assumed that was their 4.85% variable 1-Year RS rather than the 7.50% fixed 6-Month Issue 4 ?

Both options seem to lead to the opportunity to open a new 6 month RS of the current issue (according to BestSeagull). 

Bridlington1

francoghezzi said:

PRINCIPALITY
Why no one is opening a thread so as to give those not interested in having 55 accounts number 4 (an absolute minority, I admit, but I have been always inside a minority in all my life) a bit of rest after hundreds of pages with the same insipid litany? The one dedicated to Virgin for example is still up and running and it was a kind gesture to those not interested in that discussion.

Personally I've absolutely no objections to people using this thread to discuss the Principality BS regular savers whatsoever, so far as I'm concerned it's related to regular savers so it may be discussed in this thread at length if people wish. 

Principality BS are one of many banks/building societies whose regular savers get discussed here, this time last week it was mainly Monmouthshire BS that was dominating discussion, today it's mainly Principality BS (with others thrown in), next week people might be talking about a different account entirely. Discussing regular savers is one of the main purposes of having this thread at all.

If people wish to start a new thread to discuss the Principality BS RS, they can do and I have no objections to them doing so, but if people wish to use this thread to discuss it then that's also fine by me too.

I am all too aware that some prefer to have less chat, which is part of the reason why the Archived thread exists in its current form.

jameseonline

francoghezzi said:

PRINCIPALITY
Why no one is opening a thread so as to give those not interested in having 55 accounts number 4 (an absolute minority, I admit, but I have been always inside a minority in all my life) a bit of rest after hundreds of pages with the same insipid litany? The one dedicated to Virgin for example is still up and running and it was a kind gesture to those not interested in that discussion.

Not sure why you in a mood tbh, you exaggerating things too.

People are welcome to start a separate thread but obviously people were going to start talking about Principality because they recently launched an issue 4 6 month regular. 

Also it's on topic.

Hattie627

Bridlington1 said:

francoghezzi said:

PRINCIPALITY
Why no one is opening a thread so as to give those not interested in having 55 accounts number 4 (an absolute minority, I admit, but I have been always inside a minority in all my life) a bit of rest after hundreds of pages with the same insipid litany? The one dedicated to Virgin for example is still up and running and it was a kind gesture to those not interested in that discussion.

Personally I've absolutely no objections to people using this thread to discuss the Principality BS regular savers whatsoever, so far as I'm concerned it's related to regular savers so it may be discussed in this thread at length if people wish. 

Principality BS are one of many banks/building societies whose regular savers get discussed here, this time last week it was mainly Monmouthshire BS that was dominating discussion, today it's mainly Principality BS (with others thrown in), next week people might be talking about a different account entirely. Discussing regular savers is one of the main purposes of having this thread at all.

If people wish to start a new thread to discuss the Principality BS RS, they can do and I have no objections to them doing so, but if people wish to use this thread to discuss it then that's also fine by me too.

I am all too aware that some prefer to have less chat, which is part of the reason why the Archived thread exists in its current form.

I prefer to have all Regular Saver discussion on the one thread. Having multiple threads discussing individual accounts means that I am more likely to miss something. If the discussion on this thread includes posts about accounts which I am not interested in, I scroll past without reading. It usually only takes a fraction of a second to determine if I need to read a post or not. 

janusd

Hattie627 said:

janusdesign said:

Hattie627 said:

BestSeagull said:

Hattie627 said:

janusdesign said:

Hattie627 said:

janusdesign said:

BestSeagull said:

s71hj said:

So my Principality RS issue 3 maturity instructions now show online. The RS 4 is an option, which is wasn't on the letter I received. It feels like the jury is out on here whether timing or random chance dictates whether /how to get such a request through successfully when you already have an RS 4
 I'm wondering if today as a non working day followed by a busy Monday morning would. be worth a try. Thoughts? 

You know, I was wondering myself (after putting it down to luck originally), if timing has anything to do with it. I thought about submitting a last minute request as perhaps then it would be too late to deny? And it's probably just coincidence but I noticed that both of my rejection messages arrived on a Tuesday.

i've just gone through my last 4 maturity instructions - the one yesterday (Saturday morning) and the other 3 were all submitted Thursday lunchtimes... the last two, both rejected, were replied to by she with no name; the one before that accepted by another member of staff and the fourth was unsigned (but accepted)... 3 replies within 30 mins of submitting, the other was next day... I would suggest that if you haven't been rejected after a working day or two of submission, you'll get the maturity choice you requested.

one interesting point that I just noticed is that when you submit the maturity choice online (the yellow box within the product), it actually generates a secure message to PBS - when I looked in the "Sent" folder of the secure messages, I can see the maturity choices I made using the forms, had generated secure messages containing those instructions... I think the Maturity options link from the top menu also generates a similar secure message to them.

therefore, I think it's literally a case of who happens to checking the generated secure messages at the time - if submitted during working hours, it will usually be dealt with quickly; if submitted overnight/weekend, it will be dealt with next working day... but there would be no way to know in advance of submission who, in the digital team, would be dealing with it (much like who you get when you call them).

I think I may have solved it, maybe ?

I did maturity instructions yesterday morning for my Issue 3 maturing 13th September, asking for a rollover to Issue 4. They have been acknowledged by the appearance of the yellow box confirming receipt of instructions and promising to implement on maturity. 

did you request £200 to a new RS 4 and the rest of the balance elsewhere - or did you choose another option?

Yes, those were my instructions.

@Hattie627 Both the second -"Take some money out and move the rest into a new savings account". and the 4th -"Take out all your money and open a new Regular Saver Bond" options allow you to request £200 to a new 6 month RS 4. Do you remember which one you chose? 

ETA I looked back at my messages and it looks like I chose "Moving some of my balance to a new savings account" on both occasions as a message to that effect was sent to them.  So I am going with take out all your money and open a new RS this time!

I'd be lying if I said that I could definitely recall which option I chose but I'm about 75% sure that it was option 4 (take out all your money and open a new Regular Saver Bond)

I assumed that was their 4.85% variable 1-Year RS rather than the 7.50% fixed 6-Month Issue 4 ?

Both options seem to lead to the opportunity to open a new 6 month RS of the current issue (according to BestSeagull). 

good to know - I will try that next time I get maturity options (7 weeks time)... maybe all that insipid litany will lead to a happy outcome for some of us. 

francoghezzi

jameseonline said:

francoghezzi said:

PRINCIPALITY
Why no one is opening a thread so as to give those not interested in having 55 accounts number 4 (an absolute minority, I admit, but I have been always inside a minority in all my life) a bit of rest after hundreds of pages with the same insipid litany? The one dedicated to Virgin for example is still up and running and it was a kind gesture to those not interested in that discussion.

Not sure why you in a mood tbh, you exaggerating things too.

People are welcome to start a separate thread but obviously people were going to start talking about Principality because they recently launched an issue 4 6 month regular. 

Also it's on topic.

I was only suggesting that there are people who don't find useful reading the same post ("I opened it, I have 2 of it now, wow let's go for 3') again and again, but if you enjoy that way you more than welcome. :-)

Bobblehat

Bridlington1 said:

francoghezzi said:

PRINCIPALITY
Why no one is opening a thread so as to give those not interested in having 55 accounts number 4 (an absolute minority, I admit, but I have been always inside a minority in all my life) a bit of rest after hundreds of pages with the same insipid litany? The one dedicated to Virgin for example is still up and running and it was a kind gesture to those not interested in that discussion.

.............

If people wish to start a new thread to discuss the Principality BS RS, they can do and I have no objections to them doing so, but if people wish to use this thread to discuss it then that's also fine by me too.

I am all too aware that some prefer to have less chat, which is part of the reason why the Archived thread exists in its current form.

You'd be a great diplomat