Employer deductions

Gavin83

However I very much doubt the company is allowed to profit from the situation which is exactly what is happening. They're replacing a used phone for a new one. This puts them in a better position than they were before. I'd also expect them to receive the old one in this situation. It must also be the only situation in existence where a new purchase is allowed when a repair is possible.

Your car comment isn't really applicable either. A write off is when a vehicle cannot be repaired, at least economically. There is no indication that the phone couldn't be economically repaired.

OP, as for the car you'll need some level of proof. Do you have any?

sangie595

Gavin83 wrote: »

However I very much doubt the company is allowed to profit from the situation which is exactly what is happening. They're replacing a used phone for a new one. This puts them in a better position than they were before. I'd also expect them to receive the old one in this situation. It must also be the only situation in existence where a new purchase is allowed when a repair is possible.

Your car comment isn't really applicable either. A write off is when a vehicle cannot be repaired, at least economically. There is no indication that the phone couldn't be economically repaired.

OP, as for the car you'll need some level of proof. Do you have any?

Think what you like. It isn't the only situation. What you expect isn't relevant.