We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
We're aware that some users are experiencing technical issues which the team are working to resolve. See the Community Noticeboard for more info. Thank you for your patience.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
2 yr fix or 5 yr fix
Options
Comments
-
sevenhills wrote: »Surely if rates will be stable 'for 2 years or more' a two year fix is pointless.
The rates currently for discounts pretty much match 2 year fixes for 0 fee products. So yes they are unlikely to go up much, but almost certainly won't be going lower, and fairly likely to go up a bit.
So a fix has some validity.0 -
hughjonesd wrote: »That is interesting. Could you explain your reasoning?
Perhaps its classed as gambling, since no one can predict what the rates will be in 3/4 years times?0 -
sevenhills wrote: »Surely if rates will be stable 'for 2 years or more' a two year fix is pointless.
not for someone that is on 90%/95% LTV and can get down to 80%/85% then knock 1% off their rate in 2 years,
Fixing for longer at higher rate would be rather silly.
if there is a better rate than the 2y fix then that would be an option0 -
Fixed for 2 years back in Jan because of the exact same reasons listed above.0
-
I Don't Think you can class a ten year fix as gambling if anything shorter fixes are gambling. With a ten year fix you have certainty and should be able to afford it for at least that length of time. Yes you are paying a premium for certainty, but it's more of a gamble IMO to take a two year fix and risk having to renew at a higher price than current ten year fixes if interest rates go up.
The risk with a ten year fix is to the downside which is limited. If interest rates stay where they are for ten years you lose out by roughly one percentage point. With a two year fix the risk is to the upside, which theoretically is unlimited, but is IMO over the 10 year period I'd likely to be over 1%.
I could off course be wrong, but I won't lose sleep paying one percent two much as I know it's affordable. I'd worry more if I was on a two year fix and rates started to rise.
Anyway everyone has their own opinion and only time will tell.0 -
I Don't Think you can class a ten year fix as gambling if anything shorter fixes are gambling. With a ten year fix you have certainty and should be able to afford it for at least that length of time. Yes you are paying a premium for certainty, but it's more of a gamble IMO to take a two year fix and risk having to renew at a higher price than current ten year fixes if interest rates go up.
The risk with a ten year fix is to the downside which is limited. If interest rates stay where they are for ten years you lose out by roughly one percentage point. With a two year fix the risk is to the upside, which theoretically is unlimited, but is IMO over the 10 year period I'd likely to be over 1%.
I could off course be wrong, but I won't lose sleep paying one percent two much as I know it's affordable. I'd worry more if I was on a two year fix and rates started to rise.
Anyway everyone has their own opinion and only time will tell.
The 2 year fix only has to stay low for 2 year and then you take the 10 year fix.
what you are gambling with a 10 year fix is not that rates might change over 10 year but they will go up over 2 years.0 -
getmore4less wrote: »The 2 year fix only has to stay low for 2 year and then you take the 10 year fix.
what you are gambling with a 10 year fix is not that rates might change over 10 year but they will go up over 2 years.
You're gambling on what the market will think in 2019 about the interest rate for 2019-2029, compared to what the market things in 2017 about the interest rate for 2017-2027. There may not even be 10 year fixes in 2 years time, we may not even have a functioning society.
Taking any mortgage is a gamble. But we're at very low rates historically, so fixing for a long time is a gamble with reasonable odds. If you're fixing for 10 years then you should read the T&C very carefully.0 -
You're gambling on what the market will think in 2019 about the interest rate for 2019-2029, compared to what the market things in 2017 about the interest rate for 2017-2027. There may not even be 10 year fixes in 2 years time, we may not even have a functioning society.
In 2007 no one would have predicted that by 2009 interest rates would be almost zero, a change of around 4%0 -
For every borrower that selects a rate term based on what they expect will cost less overall, there is another who is making a decision based on their feelings regarding risk.
We sometimes have clients who want to know where they are for as long as possible and are focusing on long term stability. For these clients current ten year fixes are attractive. They need to remember however that a lot can happen over ten years and early redemption penalties can be painful.I am a Mortgage Broker
You should note that this site doesn't check my status as a Mortgage Broker, so you need to take my word for it. This signature is here as I follow MSE's Mortgage Adviser Code of Conduct. Any posts on here are for information and discussion purposes only and shouldn't be seen as financial advice.0 -
sevenhills wrote: »In 2007 no one would have predicted that by 2009 interest rates would be almost zero, a change of around 4%
Word on the street at the end of 2007 was that bank of england were going to make multiple cuts in 2008. Which is why I got a nationwide life time tracker rather than fixing, it saved me a fortune.
I admit a 4% drop wasn't predicted, it was looking more around the 2% mark. It can't feasibly go much lower, so it's either stay the same or go up.0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 350.9K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.5K Spending & Discounts
- 243.9K Work, Benefits & Business
- 598.8K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 176.9K Life & Family
- 257.2K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards