Overpaid tax but HMRC says underpaid

politicdoctor

chrisbur wrote: »

Sorry but I am having trouble understanding these figures. Adding them up I get a total gross of £47751.72 and tax paid of £5806.66.
The tax figures themselves seem odd as would not expect to see odd pence at the end.
As I understand it you have been employed at two places. You worked at one call in employer A until August when you moved to employer B but still did some work for A while working at B.
Can you give from your last payslip at job A your taxable gross and tax paid along with tax code and the same details from your P45 if one was issued. Then the taxable gross tax paid and tax code for the last payslip for the work done after you left.
Then from the last payslip at job B taxable gross tax paid and tax code.
If you did get a P45 from job A did you hand it in to job B if so are there any payslip figures for this ie previous gross previous tax columns.
A tax code of 0T noncum is used if a payment is made after the issue of a P45 Do you know if this occurred and if so what were the post P45 issue figures?

Regarding NI this is worked out on a month by month basis so cannot be checked using yearly figures.

Not sure how you arrived at the figure of £3303.85 in you added post. Reducing your tax allowance from 11000 to 3841 gives a reduction of 7159 20% of this is £1432 ish

Chrisbur - apologies I made a mistake with some of those figures. I think things are quite complex given it looks like I now have two separate employments with the same employer.

I feel the easiest thing would be for me to wait until two P60s come through for employer A and B which will make things much more simple for me to figure out. Until then don't want to take up any more of your time you've kindly given, but really appreciate all your input and you've helped me see a few discrepancies from payroll which I need to get corrected on my side - thanks a lot!