Offers over is over for house prices in Scotland.

chucknorris

HAMISH_MCTAVISH wrote: »

And............. Nothing.

geneer ghosts out of the thread again.

Still, self awareness of a houseplant and all that......

Hey that's out of order you have upset my houseplant with that totally unnecessary insult.

HAMISH_MCTAVISH

chucknorris wrote: »

Hey that's out of order you have upset my houseplant with that totally unnecessary insult.

He's probably frantically PM-ing all his mates on hpc to find a non-slum suburb that has had price falls since 2005.

Not being able to find one, he'll be back shortly to state he has no intention of letting us obsessives know where he's going to live.

Or just squirm around and try to move the goalposts.

Whatever.....:cool:

chucknorris

HAMISH_MCTAVISH wrote: »

He's probably frantically PM-ing all his mates on hpc to find a non-slum suburb that has had price falls since 2005.

Not being able to find one, he'll be back shortly to state he has no intention of letting us obsessives know where he's going to live.

Or just squirm around and try to move the goalposts.

Whatever.....:cool:

I admire your patience for dealing with him, personally I feel a bit sorry for him. The worst part is that he honestly doesn't seem to realise that he is complete fool.

geneer

HAMISH_MCTAVISH wrote: »

And............. Nothing.

geneer ghosts out of the thread again.

Still, self awareness of a houseplant and all that......

:rotfl:Yet here I am Hamish.
My apologies, took an early lunch before heading out for a meeting.

I've sincerely sorry I can't spend all of my day arguing with random people on an internet forum.

geneer

One minute your ignoring.
The next your not.

IveSeenTheLight wrote: »

The goalposts move so much, you can't hold a topic to debate on.

• One minute the averages are skewed and irrelevant (when rising), next their gospel (when falling)

Yes. They were skewed and essentially irrlevant. I said it at the time, even the VIs said it at the time and regularly thereafter. And the skew dropped out as expected as the spread of sales has become more normalised. Which the VIs have also confirmed.


To summarise, I thought I was right, I've been proven right, the VIs have confirmed I was right.

• One minute your discussing ROSEA average, next he switches to ESPC.

Both are of course worth of discussion. Ask Hamish. He seemed to think so last summer.

• One minute your discussing YoY and he wants monthly because of their recent trend. If that trend turns, he'll jump on YoY if monthly is up. Occasionally he'll try QoQ if both YoY and MoM are not to his sliking.

Actually, you appear to be talking about Hamish there.

You can't hold a topical debate so it's best to leave him stewing and arguing with himself.

Though the evidence suggest you can, for an extended period. Only you end up losing the debate, spit the dummy, then fumble about the board slagging him off in the most ineffective example of ignoring ever seen since the last half dozen bulls did the same. :rotfl:


I've given up pointing out his blatant error's and can see he's obviously bleating on in this thread.

In other words you failed to justify your spurious arbitrary assumptions.

Thank god I don;t get drawn into responding as I just see one liners saying I can;t see his messages.

Yet here you are. :T

Nice Ignorin' Tex!

geneer

HAMISH_MCTAVISH wrote: »

geneer, if you really think house prices in any decent part of Edinburgh have only risen by £400 a year on average since 2005, then you're a blithering idiot, and there's simply no point in responding to any more of your posts.

Didn't suggest that the averages did apply to every area in Edinburgh Spamish.
However the blunt global averages appear to be good enough for you to quote in aberdeen, and certainly have been good enough for Edinburgh, oh until January . Whats up Hamish, has something changed.
There must be a reason you're getting so gwummpy :rotfl:

HAMISH_MCTAVISH wrote: »

Tell you what, why don't you let us know which area of Edinburgh you're looking to buy in and, providing it's not a slum, we'll show you numerous examples of actual houses that sold then that have sold again recently for more.

Tell you what Hamish. Why don't you let all your bearish chums know which part of aberdeen you're living in?
No need for a house number or anything.
A post code will do. :rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:

HAMISH_MCTAVISH wrote: »

No skewed indices, no fudging of figures, no asking prices, just the same house selling for significantly more money recently than it did in 2005.

Of course being a fair, reasonable and logical chap, you really mean 2006.

HAMISH_MCTAVISH wrote: »

Let's put this tedious bickering to bed once and for all.

Yeah. 3 years listening to the same bullish nonsense is long enough, eh mate. Now its time to put it to bed. Wow. Just wow.

Pimperne1

IveSeenTheLight wrote: »

The goalposts move so much, you can't hold a topic to debate on.

• One minute the averages are skewed and irrelevant (when rising), next their gospel (when falling)
• One minute your discussing ROSEA average, next he switches to ESPC.
• One minute your discussing YoY and he wants monthly because of their recent trend. If that trend turns, he'll jump on YoY if monthly is up. Occasionally he'll try QoQ if both YoY and MoM are not to his sliking.

You can't hold a topical debate so it's best to leave him stewing and arguing with himself.
I've given up pointing out his blatant error's and can see he's obviously bleating on in this thread.
Thank god I don;t get drawn into responding as I just see one liners saying I can;t see his messages.

Insulting. I don't think you quite know the oracle that you are dealing with here:

Geneer, providing house buying advice since 2006:

http://www.housepricecrash.co.uk/forum/index.php?showtopic=21345&st=112

And the result:

http://www.ukpropertyshop.co.uk/news/531.shtml

The results mean house price inflation in the Capital has now topped 10% in six consecutive quarters dating back to early 2006.
:rotfl::rotfl::rotfl::T

HAMISH_MCTAVISH

That thread is priceless.

Another hilarious geneerism ......

The difference is that the HPC forum is a hotbed of debate , review and analysis in which a concensus is eventually reached.

Yeah.... By banning anyone that disagrees!!!! :rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:

Jimmy_31

HAMISH_MCTAVISH wrote: »

And............. Nothing.

geneer ghosts out of the thread again.

Still, self awareness of a houseplant and all that......

Just like you ghosted out of the thread about cheaper housing being better for the economy.

Feel free to respond to my post in that thread, you will know which post it is, its the silly one that didnt deserve a respone from you. (or maybe i was talking sense so you just thought ill have to ignore that post because i might lose)

Like you have said to me before hamish i am a pretty thick individual, fair enough that is your opinion and you are entitled to it, and my opinion on you is still the same, you aint half a soft ar53.

geneer

Pimperne1 wrote: »

http://www.ukpropertyshop.co.uk/news/531.shtml

The results mean house price inflation in the Capital has now topped 10% in six consecutive quarters dating back to early 2006.

:rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:Wow. Thats a fascinating article from 2007 pimp.
Got nothing more up to date.