📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Tax Rebate Delay

2

Comments

  • Tarasam
    Tarasam Posts: 508 Forumite
    wendy1983 wrote: »
    It appears some people in this post work for the inland revenue, my partner and I are both from the business world, maybe this is why we can't understand why this level of imcompetancy can be tolerated? Civil Servants work for tax payers and we have every right to contact the tax office when they are holding on to our hard earned money!
    People come on this site for help with issues they are not experts on themselves. They do not deserve rudeness from people who have nothing better to do with their lives than search these forums for people to have a pop at! We are simply asking for money that is owed to us, this is what this site is all about, is it not?

    This attitude will get you nowhere, you are complaining about HMRC, the attitude of the people on this forum and the above is your reply.

    The people who are employed by HMRC are also taxpayers and are not paid enough to have to tolerate this kind of attitude. If you use the above tactic re civil servants you will only get the backs up of the people you want to help you.

    I agree you have every right to contact HMRC with any tax query, that is their purpose but there will be a valid reason for the delay in your repayment.

    I hope you get this solved sooner rather than later.
  • chrismac1
    chrismac1 Posts: 2,585 Forumite
    Please do not expect normal basic standards of professionalism to apply in your dealings with HMRC. Quite simply they don't. This is Jobsworth City Arizona you are dealing with here. Where I have a real issue with these "delays" - just as with delays dealing with issuing VAT numbers, replying to really simple letters, issuing UTRs, etc, etc. - is that there is no sense whatsoever that the clock is ticking with these folks.

    When the boot is on the other foot, tax agents have 30 days to appeal a decision by HMRC against a client. No excuses about system failures, tough luck if you are on holiday for 3 weeks, no fobbing off about "the system". Just 30 days plain and simple.

    Don't get me wrong, I am not complaining about this. In fact it is fair enough. All I ask is that the same 30 days applies to HMRC. So for example, Jobsworth City has 30 days to check this guy paid his CIS tax after which time the system automatically sends out the payment. Given that 30 hours is about the longest this should take, that's a generous allowance.

    I realise this is of no help to the OP. And I hold out no false dawns to her either. Once the Jobsworth Department is on the case, it is how long is a piece of string. There is no end point, they will offer you no deadlines or end point to the merry dance, accept no target dates no matter how reasonable.
    Hideous Muddles from Right Charlies
  • suso
    suso Posts: 548 Forumite
    wendy1983 wrote: »
    Just imagine how angry you'd be if you were waiting for your refund! You don't get to mess them about like this if you owe THEM money! It appears some people in this post work for the inland revenue, my partner and I are both from the business world, maybe this is why we can't understand why this level of imcompetancy can be tolerated? Civil Servants work for tax payers and we have every right to contact the tax office when they are holding on to our hard earned money! As has already been explained, it is not the people in the call centre's carrying out the reviews, it is their job to answer telephones. How could calling them cause a further delay? I say keep on at them until they give you your money, that's what they do to you if it was the other way round!!

    People come on this site for help with issues they are not experts on themselves. They do not deserve rudeness from people who have nothing better to do with their lives than search these forums for people to have a pop at! We are simply asking for money that is owed to us, this is what this site is all about, is it not?

    My MP is dealing with this now anyway, I suggest everybody who is experiencing these delays writes to their MP and claims compensation, even if it isn't much. You can definitely claim back the cost of your phonecalls, it says so on the HMRC website.

    If you knew there was going to be a refund, why didn't you submit the return earlier ? the 31st Jan is the last day not the only day you can submit.

    The volume of tax returns that are submitted on the final day are staggering, last year there was over 100000 returns an hour during business hours submitted on the last business day before the deadline

    If HMRC (not Inland Revenue) checked just 1% of returns submitted on this day, this means checking 8000 returns, of course its going to take time.

    As you are from the business world, if someone sends you an invoice, do you just pay it or do you check it ?

    Civil servants do not work for tax payers, if they did then half the enquiries they receive wouldn't be answered as these are from people with no net liability and therefore are non taxpayers, and according to your description HMRC do not work for them.
    He's not an accountant - he's a charlatan
  • wendy1983 wrote: »
    Just imagine how angry you'd be if you were waiting for your refund! You don't get to mess them about like this if you owe THEM money!
    <snip>
    As has already been explained, it is not the people in the call centre's carrying out the reviews, it is their job to answer telephones. How could calling them cause a further delay? I say keep on at them until they give you your money, that's what they do to you if it was the other way round!!
    Wow, way to miss the point on a grand scale.

    If you'd bothered to read my post before launching into your tirade, you'd have seen that it was in response to someone saying you couldn't contact the people doing the reviews.

    Let's imagine for a second that they do 40 reviews a day if they're left to get on with their job. If they have to answer calls from Joe Public and friends hassling them to get it done quicker, this will obviously drop below 40 cases a day. Thus taking everyone's refund longer to appear.

    Feel free, however, to "keep on at them until they give you your money". This will accomplish the following:
    1) It will annoy a callcentre worker who can do nothing to speed up your refund.
    2) It will increase your phone bill.
    3) It will get your refund expedited by the grand total of zero days.

    If you're particularly hard of thinking and would like all of this explained in even more simple terms, just let me know and I'll be happy to oblige.
  • chrismac1
    chrismac1 Posts: 2,585 Forumite
    edited 6 March 2011 at 10:08PM
    For the HMRC people posting into this thread, please answer this:

    What is required in order for your organisation to behave professionally? What is needed to enable you to answer simple easy peasy letters in less than 12 weeks? What is required to enable call centre workers to deal with a query first time more or less every time without passing the buck, blaming a process, or giving the caller yet another 0845 number to call? What changes are needed for the database to knock out a simple tax reference within 12 hours not 12 weeks?

    By seeking the answer to these questions, you will learn 2 things:

    1. Why members of the public find it so difficult to deal with you when their experience of HMRC falls so woefully short of basic, easy peasy expectations.
    2. How HMRC can reduce the backlog by 50% within 12 months, using 25% less people in the process.
    Hideous Muddles from Right Charlies
  • Tarasam
    Tarasam Posts: 508 Forumite
    chrismac1 wrote: »
    For the HMRC people posting into this thread, please answer this:

    What is required in order for your organisation to behave professionally? Better senior management
    What is needed to enable you to answer simple easy peasy letters in less than 12 weeks? More staff - less ridiculous processes to follow
    What is required to enable call centre workers to deal with a query first time more or less every time without passing the buck, blaming a process, or giving the caller yet another 0845 number to call? Less ridiculous processes to follow - less bullying from managers in regards to statistics - being able to do a decent job for a decent days pay instead of being treat like school children
    What changes are needed for the database to knock out a simple tax reference within 12 hours not 12 weeks? Cant answer am not in that dept - dont know their processes.

    By seeking the answer to these questions, you will learn 2 things:

    1. Why members of the public find it so difficult to deal with you when their experience of HMRC falls so woefully short of basic, easy peasy expectations. I agree - the level of customer service has dropped considerably - you will find that the majority of HMRC staff feel the same in regards to this and would change things if they could.
    2. How HMRC can reduce the backlog by 50% within 12 months, using 25% less people in the process.More staff.
    But I need to add, the media and the general public themselves do not help. We are verbally abused in 75% of calls that we receive, we want HMRC to be better, we dont want to work in this environment. We work to the best of our abilities, do you really think that the staff go to work deliberately to p*ss the public off and cause as much trouble as we can. After all we are human beings trying to do a days work.
  • dori2o
    dori2o Posts: 8,150
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts
    Forumite
    kellyshay wrote: »
    But I need to add, the media and the general public themselves do not help. We are verbally abused in 75% of calls that we receive, we want HMRC to be better, we dont want to work in this environment. We work to the best of our abilities, do you really think that the staff go to work deliberately to p*ss the public off and cause as much trouble as we can. After all we are human beings trying to do a days work.
    Kelly, it's pointless replying to this moron, he has an agenda against HMRC from the top to the bottom.

    He claims to be an accountant, yet uses this forum mainly to tout for business.

    If he was an accountant he would know the proper channels to use to address his problems. Afterall, as you seem to be someone who works frontline for HMRC, you will know that when the agents are not happy we seem to change our processes to suit them, no matter how that affects our other customers. The ADL line is a prime example.

    You are right however that the majority of our problems lie not with the frontline staff, but with those in the Directors Office of CCD (customer contact) and processing.

    Without such processes as LEAN, and the joke that is CTP's then we wouldn't be in the mess we are in. However, whilst those in Directors office feel the need to justify their positions, we will continue to be hampered by these silly processes.

    What needs to happen is that all lines of business should be open to all contact centres and proper training given to all staff, not a 5 minute slideshow.

    we should all be able to register new self employed people, and have the ability to set up a SA record there and then, reducing the rediculus wait that we currently have for UTR's

    We should all be able to deal with ESC A19 claims instead of just the select few.

    The only things we should have to forward on are those things dealt with by Band O and above.

    Until things change with the management, then when the cuts take place, things will only get worse.
    [SIZE=-1]To equate judgement and wisdom with occupation is at best . . . insulting.
    [/SIZE]
  • chrismac1
    chrismac1 Posts: 2,585 Forumite
    The only agenda I have is that there are simple, easy peasy things which if changed would dramatically improve the situation. Such things many agents have been pointing out to HMRC from Dame Leslie down to the newest call centre operator. Yet they have not been changed and it seems unlikely to us that they will be changed anytime soon. That is my agenda - this is an organistion which is badly broken yet nonetheless appears not to want to fix itself.
    Hideous Muddles from Right Charlies
  • John_Pierpoint
    John_Pierpoint Posts: 8,401
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts
    Forumite
    edited 7 March 2011 at 5:22PM
    Here we go again.
    I am trying to sort out an on-going income tax situation. I've written a dozen letters. I can reply to HMRC within 7 days. For the majority of letters HMRC cannot answer mine at all. When they do it takes weeks and I have little or no faith in the replies, as I have examples that are simply wrong or that demonstrate that the writer might have handled the letter I wrote but does not appear to have read it or decided not to answer my questions.
    My favourite is a reply to a 4 month old letter some six weeks after I had spent (on and off) 72 hours getting an answer on the phone.
    "Oh we sorted this out months ago - its gone to archive now - didn't we tell you - I suppose you will be wanting to claim back the money you paid on account now?"

    The point that the HMRC people don't seem to be able to take on board is that when the tax payer writes a letter that goes unanswered or even acknowledged for a month, the "punter" (we don't seem to be called customers any more) has to assume it has got lost in the post and send in a copy. That way some simple task that should be done and dusted in say 6 weeks can be made to drag on for 18 months, with a huge increase in costs for both sides.

    John.

    PS Is this problem spreading.
    Who designed the new census form ? It is getting to look more like a Self Assessment tax return and asks questions about your sources of income and relationships with other members of the household.
    It seems that last time 3 million people failed to complete it, and that does no include the ones who put "jokes" into the form such as Jedi as religion. I wonder how many people will refuse to return the form this time?
    Me, well I've just been sent TWO census forms, should I send the second back full of "jokes"?
  • chrismac1
    chrismac1 Posts: 2,585 Forumite
    yes but I have it on good authority from the public sector unions that there is practically no waste at all in the UK public sector......
    Hideous Muddles from Right Charlies
This discussion has been closed.
★ ★ ★ Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 356K Banking & Borrowing
  • 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 456.3K Spending & Discounts
  • 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 179.1K Life & Family
  • 264K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.7K Read-Only Boards
Quick Search

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.