We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
The Forum now has a brand new text editor, adding a bunch of handy features to use when creating posts. Read more in our how-to guide
Breaking the cycle of debt
savingholmes
Posts: 29,152 Forumite
We have battled with debt throughout our married lives. We do well for a while and then a tragedy hits like someone dying (3 different people) and depression and then we spend, spend, spend.
We have got ourselves almost out of debt several times over - through selling our house and restarting, voluntary redundancy, job pay offs, gifts and then got in trouble all over again.
A few years ago we upsized our house, paid off most of our debt (other than the mortgage) and yet earlier this year we were approx £30K in debt again. I got a lucky break at work and got a payout which let us reduce our debt to about £20K. Our fixed rate came to an end (with GMAC) and Barclays have agreed to give us a new one - still an increased cost of £100 per month compared to our previous rate.
We are trying to budget. We moved all our cards to interest free credit - other than 3% balance transfer fees. This has already saved us approximately £500 per month in fees. We have also done things like moved our mortgage which will save about £1200 this year. We have done the home insurance challenge and halved our cost from £650 to £320. We've moved our gas and electricity - although with the price rises - seeing very little effect. We've reduced our phone bill by about £60 per year. Cancelled our RAC cover costing £200 per year as it was covered in our bank account charge anyway. Our biggest single area that we have not challenged is probably our life insurances, critical illness and redundancy insurance. Unfortunately however as I have had time off work with depression, we may not be able to get cheaper insurance on me. We are paying about £100 per month on this however - for about £250K insurance. We are already on an interest only mortgage. We use childcare vouchers at work.
We still have access to cheap credit as we have never ever defaulted - however we really struggle with will power to stick to budgets for the long term it would take to pay off the £20K and switch to a repayment mortgage.
Any constructive suggestions gratefully received.
Thanks
savingholmes
We have got ourselves almost out of debt several times over - through selling our house and restarting, voluntary redundancy, job pay offs, gifts and then got in trouble all over again.
A few years ago we upsized our house, paid off most of our debt (other than the mortgage) and yet earlier this year we were approx £30K in debt again. I got a lucky break at work and got a payout which let us reduce our debt to about £20K. Our fixed rate came to an end (with GMAC) and Barclays have agreed to give us a new one - still an increased cost of £100 per month compared to our previous rate.
We are trying to budget. We moved all our cards to interest free credit - other than 3% balance transfer fees. This has already saved us approximately £500 per month in fees. We have also done things like moved our mortgage which will save about £1200 this year. We have done the home insurance challenge and halved our cost from £650 to £320. We've moved our gas and electricity - although with the price rises - seeing very little effect. We've reduced our phone bill by about £60 per year. Cancelled our RAC cover costing £200 per year as it was covered in our bank account charge anyway. Our biggest single area that we have not challenged is probably our life insurances, critical illness and redundancy insurance. Unfortunately however as I have had time off work with depression, we may not be able to get cheaper insurance on me. We are paying about £100 per month on this however - for about £250K insurance. We are already on an interest only mortgage. We use childcare vouchers at work.
We still have access to cheap credit as we have never ever defaulted - however we really struggle with will power to stick to budgets for the long term it would take to pay off the £20K and switch to a repayment mortgage.
Any constructive suggestions gratefully received.
Thanks
savingholmes
Achieve FIRE/Mortgage Neutrality in 2030
1) MFW Nov 21 £202K now £167.4K Equity 38% 3/4/26
2) £3K Net savings after CCs March 26 (but owed £1.1K) so £4.1K
3) Mortgage neutral by 06/30 (AVC £36.2K + Lump Sums DB £4.6K + (25% of SIPP 1.3K) = 42.1£127.5K target 33% 27/2/26 (If took bigger lump sum = 64K or 50.1%)
4) FI Age 60 income target £17.1/30K 57% (if mortgage and debts repaid - need more otherwise) (If bigger lump sum £15.8/30K 52.67%)
5) SIPP £5.2K updated 16/1/26
1) MFW Nov 21 £202K now £167.4K Equity 38% 3/4/26
2) £3K Net savings after CCs March 26 (but owed £1.1K) so £4.1K
3) Mortgage neutral by 06/30 (AVC £36.2K + Lump Sums DB £4.6K + (25% of SIPP 1.3K) = 42.1£127.5K target 33% 27/2/26 (If took bigger lump sum = 64K or 50.1%)
4) FI Age 60 income target £17.1/30K 57% (if mortgage and debts repaid - need more otherwise) (If bigger lump sum £15.8/30K 52.67%)
5) SIPP £5.2K updated 16/1/26
0
Comments
-
Why does someone dying make you spend, spend, spend?0
-
It's all about little changes that last forever. I know all too well how when things get tough going out and spending makes you feel better, like smoking a cigarette, or drinking alcocol, or eating chocolate. But once you get used to making little changes they will stay with you forever.
You need to stop with the 'big' circles you are in
and make lifelong changes.through selling our house and restarting, voluntary redundancy, job pay offs
My biggest help was to open a 'spending account' where I have a standing order for so much per week which is my only spending money. My main account is now building up a credit amount whilst there is more than enough to pay my DDs and I have taught myself to live to this limitDebt busting! Jan 2014 £7632.50 £7445.80
Belly busting! Jan 2014 12st 2lb 11st 11lb0 -
superjaggybunnet wrote: »Why does someone dying make you spend, spend, spend?
Because you get depressed and so spending can give some people the feel good factor and cheer you up.
Naomi x0 -
We've got 2 accounts currently 1 pays the main direct debits, standing orders, and the 2nd pays any direct debits left, money towards credit card repayment and living expenses. We could look at a third account to spend from by splitting out the remaining regular payments into another account. That might be helpful. It may however just give us access to a third overdraft facility!!! In applying for our new mortgage (just to improve rates not increase debts) Barclays have opened a third account for us - so this might be a good use to put it to.
I know Martin's book recommends multiple accounts to try and regulate spending with certain pots.Achieve FIRE/Mortgage Neutrality in 2030
1) MFW Nov 21 £202K now £167.4K Equity 38% 3/4/26
2) £3K Net savings after CCs March 26 (but owed £1.1K) so £4.1K
3) Mortgage neutral by 06/30 (AVC £36.2K + Lump Sums DB £4.6K + (25% of SIPP 1.3K) = 42.1£127.5K target 33% 27/2/26 (If took bigger lump sum = 64K or 50.1%)
4) FI Age 60 income target £17.1/30K 57% (if mortgage and debts repaid - need more otherwise) (If bigger lump sum £15.8/30K 52.67%)
5) SIPP £5.2K updated 16/1/260 -
Spending gives me a buzz. I can go from having no energy whatsoever to feeling (all too briefly) high just by going to the shops. It also provides social contact and some of the very slight exercise I get - working full time, having kids and being a couch potato! I've never quite managed to sustain getting the same buzz from not spending.Because you get depressed and so spending can give some people the feel good factor and cheer you up.
Naomi xAchieve FIRE/Mortgage Neutrality in 2030
1) MFW Nov 21 £202K now £167.4K Equity 38% 3/4/26
2) £3K Net savings after CCs March 26 (but owed £1.1K) so £4.1K
3) Mortgage neutral by 06/30 (AVC £36.2K + Lump Sums DB £4.6K + (25% of SIPP 1.3K) = 42.1£127.5K target 33% 27/2/26 (If took bigger lump sum = 64K or 50.1%)
4) FI Age 60 income target £17.1/30K 57% (if mortgage and debts repaid - need more otherwise) (If bigger lump sum £15.8/30K 52.67%)
5) SIPP £5.2K updated 16/1/260 -
savingholmes wrote: »We've got 2 accounts currently 1 pays the main direct debits, standing orders, and the 2nd pays any direct debits left, money towards credit card repayment and living expenses. We could look at a third account to spend from by splitting out the remaining regular payments into another account. That might be helpful. It may however just give us access to a third overdraft facility!!! In applying for our new mortgage (just to improve rates not increase debts) Barclays have opened a third account for us - so this might be a good use to put it to.
I know Martin's book recommends multiple accounts to try and regulate spending with certain pots.
Why not look at an account with no borrowing facilities like Natwest Step account, no borrowing facilities and a solo card.You never know how strong you are until being strong is the only choice you have.
xx Mama to a gorgeous Cranio Baby xx
0 -
I have also had three very close family deaths from the age of 18. It is such a difficult time with little help avail in my experience.
Re. over spending I was unequipped for unsupported financial life, trying to live the life i knew before. Trying to keep a constant in my life, and no budgeting skills
Having no idea of how to budget realistically and to be honest not caring because i was just trying to get through each day without the people i loved. whilst having to care for my own family
Now many years later i am financially paying the price but now i am taking control of finance and working towards goals of increasing income.
I hope you are getting the help you need but also realise that you need to stop overspending now, budget, do not get any more credit.
Do you have a surplus amount of income each month if not you need to get advice from someone ie CCCS
Good luck stay strong
AC xx“most people give up just as they are about to achieve success”If you think you are going through hell keep going - Sir Winston ChurchillIf You Can't Change It, Change the Way You Think About It.SW, 13st5lb, -4 1/2, -1,(12st13.5lbs)0 -
In theory we should be able to live within our means and pay off at least £500 per month off our debts (excluding mortgage). Unfortunately, recently we have been standing still rather than improving (but that is better than nothing) - the standing still has been due to approx £500-750 in unexpected car bills, £800 on 2 holidays - and according to the demotivator - the £2850 I spend a year on things I could easily do without. Achieve FIRE/Mortgage Neutrality in 2030
1) MFW Nov 21 £202K now £167.4K Equity 38% 3/4/26
2) £3K Net savings after CCs March 26 (but owed £1.1K) so £4.1K
3) Mortgage neutral by 06/30 (AVC £36.2K + Lump Sums DB £4.6K + (25% of SIPP 1.3K) = 42.1£127.5K target 33% 27/2/26 (If took bigger lump sum = 64K or 50.1%)
4) FI Age 60 income target £17.1/30K 57% (if mortgage and debts repaid - need more otherwise) (If bigger lump sum £15.8/30K 52.67%)
5) SIPP £5.2K updated 16/1/260 -
So its not too bad ??
At least yo can see that just tightening your belt for a while will reduce your debt - not too bad then huh?? xx
You can do it see it as a challenge the people youve lost would be proud of you taking Positive action, yes??“most people give up just as they are about to achieve success”If you think you are going through hell keep going - Sir Winston ChurchillIf You Can't Change It, Change the Way You Think About It.SW, 13st5lb, -4 1/2, -1,(12st13.5lbs)0 -
If you go through Quidco, (cash back site), and use their link, they have Alliance and Leicester current account,you get £50.00 cash back. I opened minemid June, and only put £1.00 in to show willing, and the£50.00 is in Quidco andis scheduled for July payment. I've also done the same for my parents via Quidco, at mo they only have 1 joint account so they have open ed seperate accounts. Also Alliance do a savings account £20.00 cashback
Its another £70.00 to throw at debts.xx rip dad... we had our ups and downs but we’re always be family xx0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 354.2K Banking & Borrowing
- 254.3K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 455.3K Spending & Discounts
- 247.1K Work, Benefits & Business
- 603.8K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 178.4K Life & Family
- 261.3K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards
