We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
alternative to selftrade
Options

freakin
Posts: 34 Forumite


Hi, I have some shares which I bought through selftrade but due to them now charging me £40 a quarter / year (cant remember which now) for not doing any active trades I need to move to someone else.
I am currently not allowed to sell or buy any more of my shares. How to I go about transferring these to somewhere else and any recommendations on where I can move them where I dont have to pay a recurring free to "do nothing"?
I am currently not allowed to sell or buy any more of my shares. How to I go about transferring these to somewhere else and any recommendations on where I can move them where I dont have to pay a recurring free to "do nothing"?
0
Comments
-
Hi, I have some shares which I bought through selftrade but due to them now charging me £40 a quarter / year (cant remember which now) for not doing any active trades I need to move to someone else.
I am currently not allowed to sell or buy any more of my shares. How to I go about transferring these to somewhere else and any recommendations on where I can move them where I dont have to pay a recurring free to "do nothing"?
Have a look at the i-dealing website and see what you think. The platform has not changed very much in approx 10yrs and it is a no-frills but reliable service. Straight forward and transparent £5 per quarter, with no other fees. Definitely no problem with inactivity, cash holdings etc and staff have always been helpful. Dealing fees are also reasonable (£9.90 plus stamp duty per trade) and trading is straight-forward. Electonic transfer of cash to standard or ISA accounts easy for additional funding. Only one fiddly bit and that is getting cash out by sending a withdrawal form by post and the funds are then sent electonically to your nominated bank without charges. Suitable for shares and etfs, not appropriate for funds though. They have in recent years introduced a £60 account closure fee which is a surprise, but this is more than compensated for by the low annual overhead on the fund and holdings.
If this is of interest, regarding how you can transfer your shares, go to the "forms section", and read "account/holdings transfer and instructions". You can also e-mail them any queries. This is one option which may provide an easy exit strategy for you. Others on the forum may have alternative suggestions also.
I am not a financial expert, but hope this helps.0 -
I am currently not allowed to sell or buy any more of my shares. How to I go about transferring these to somewhere else and any recommendations on where I can move them where I dont have to pay a recurring free to "do nothing"?
Have a look at:
HSBC InvestDirect
First Direct
III
None of these change annual or inactivity fees - though for the first two I think you need to hold current accounts with them.
To transfer shares from Selftrade to another broker:
1. Open an account at your new broker
2.Your new broker will have a form/template for transferring accounts from other brokers to them - which you can fill in and send to Selftrade (you may need to send it via your new broker)
3. Selftrade will then electronically transfer your shares to your new broker (without selling them)
4. Selftrade will probably charge you around £10 to do this.
Regards
Sunil0 -
Excellent Sunil......3 possibly even cheaper options! In this case I guess the lot should be compared to see which provides the best compromise between trading facilities, dealing costs and any transfer costs involved, and then it should be problem sorted.
I do not know the background on this issue at Selftrade, but pressurising investors to be more active is somewhat counter-intuitive regarding a long term investment strategy and if I was forced into this situation I would be furious. Hence my immediate possible fix with i-dealing. If overhead costs can be removed completely, may be even better!
James
I am not a fianancial expert.0 -
Excellent Sunil......3 possibly even cheaper options! In this case I guess the lot should be compared to see which provides the best compromise between trading facilities, dealing costs and any transfer costs involved, and then it should be problem sorted.
I do not know the background on this issue at Selftrade, but pressurising investors to be more active is somewhat counter-intuitive regarding a long term investment strategy and if I was forced into this situation I would be furious. Hence my immediate possible fix with i-dealing. If overhead costs can be removed completely, may be even better!
James
I am not a fianancial expert.
Selftrade introduced a yearly account fee of £35 + VAT for everyone no matter how often they trade.
I use Halfax Share Dealing as an alternative to Selftrade and am in the process of moving my ISA to Alliance Trust Savings.
Both of them have no annual fee.0 -
NOH.... the fees you mention at Selftrade are not excessive, thanks for this clarification. Fine, so I guess the main issue on this thread is being chased over trading inactivity as discussed above..
I am not a financial expert.0 -
thanks for your help guys especially gt94sss2
fyi i think the deal was something like you get 3 "free" trades in return for the subscription at selftrade, so if your dealing it probably doesn't matter.0 -
Hi, I have some shares which I bought through selftrade but due to them now charging me £40 a quarter / year (cant remember which now) for not doing any active trades I need to move to someone else.
I am currently not allowed to sell or buy any more of my shares. How to I go about transferring these to somewhere else and any recommendations on where I can move them where I dont have to pay a recurring free to "do nothing"?
Have a look at the i-dealing website and see what you think. The platform has not changed very much in approx 10yrs and it is a no-frills but reliable service. Straight forward and transparent £5 per quarter, with no other fees. Definitely no problem with inactivity, cash holdings etc and staff have always been helpful. Dealing fees are also reasonable (£9.90 plus stamp duty per trade) and trading is straight-forward. Electonic transfer of cash to standard or ISA accounts easy for additional funding. Only one fiddly bit and that is getting cash out by sending a withdrawal form by post and the funds are then sent electonically to your nominated bank without charges. Suitable for shares and etfs, not appropriate for funds though. They have in recent years introduced a £60 account closure fee which is a surprise, but this is more than compensated for by the low annual overhead on the fund and holdings.
If this is of interest, regarding how you can transfer your shares, go to the "forms section", and read "account/holdings transfer and instructions". You can also e-mail them any queries. This is one option which may provide an easy exit strategy for you. Others on the forum may have alternative suggestions also.
I am not a financial expert, but hope this helps.
I have some online accounts but when Selftrade changed hands their service became deplorable, their website was poor & despite me notifying them about lack of facilities & research &c they did not even reply to my messages. They then asked me to re-register which I took exception to & refused to do; they then froze my account so I transferred all my holdings to iDealing & have been happy with them since. They still send me emails despite the fact that my account is closed. :eek:
Regards,
N.;)Never be afraid to take a profit.
Keep breathing. :eek:
Just because I am surrounded by FOOLS does not make me wise. :j0 -
Have never used Selftrade myself. But yes, no problems whatsoever with i-dealing over the years and they suit me perfectly for certain holdings. Do not see them advertising much, so I guess they just get on with providing a good service to a loyal customer base. Regards.
JamesU0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 351.1K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.2K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.6K Spending & Discounts
- 244.1K Work, Benefits & Business
- 599.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177K Life & Family
- 257.5K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards