Both employees and self-employed workers will pay less in National Insurance from next year, Chancellor Jeremy Hunt has announced in today's Autumn Statement.
Read the full story:
Autumn Statement: Workers to pay less in national – but rate cuts don't offset the freezing of personal tax thresholds
If you haven't already, join the forum to reply.
We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum. This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are - or become - political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
Autumn Statement: Workers to pay less in national insurance

MSE_Molly_G
Posts: 148 MSE Staff

in Cutting tax
0
Comments
-
re: your interpretation of class2 NIcs being abolished - are you sure?
1) would mean class2 hasn't been abolished at all, just made voluntary
2) would be highly regressive: earn 6725-12569 pay no NI or income tax yet get a pension credit; but earn less than 6725 have to buy a pension credit by paying voluntary NI
3) when they last floated the idea of cancelling class2 (around 2016) it was suggested only way for self-employed low earners to get pension credit after class2 was abolished would be to pay voluntary class3 (which is five times the cost of class2)0 -
The official Government press statement
Chancellor backs business and rewards workers to get Britain growing - GOV.UK (www.gov.uk)
says this;
"The weekly Class 2 NICs – the flat rate compulsory charge which is currently £3.45 paid by self-employed people earning more than £12,570 - will effectively be abolished, with no-one required to pay from April 2024. Access to contributory benefits will be maintained and those currently paying voluntarily will still be able to do so at the same rate."
Take from that what you will.
I'm not at all sure how they think it will work. For example, I pay only Class 2 voluntarily because my self employed income is very low as I wind it down. Are they going to introduce a system with a cut off, e.g. anybody already claiming prior to January 2024 will still be able to do so, those starting after this date won't be able to claim Class 2.
They've tried to abolish Class 2 before and failed, I'm not sure what whizz bang scheme they've thought up this time to abolish it.0 -
With these changes there is now no need for voluntary class 2, it should be abolished. Earn enough you get credits or pay the relevant NI rate, don't earn enough you can pay class 3, what is wrong with that ?
0 -
molerat said:With these changes there is now no need for voluntary class 2, it should be abolished. Earn enough you get credits or pay the relevant NI rate, don't earn enough you can pay class 3, what is wrong with that ?
If they're abolished I have to pay Class 3 at about £800 per year.
I can see lots wrong with that.
0 -
The increase by just over £1 per hour in the national Minimum wage is another sly tax steal ( Albeit helping the low paid )
It costs the government nothing, as the employers pay it, and £1 an hour gives a 37 hour per week person an extra £1924 per year.
BUT the chancellor gets 20% of that in tax which is £384 per year for every minimum wage employee in the country;
That's 1.6 million people according to the Governments own 2023 stats
So a total of an extra £614 extra million tax raise through an ostensibly charitable gesture, much of it coming out of the thin profits of struggling small businesses ( and this is all about growth?).
On the minimum wage you will now be liable for tax and national insurance on £10,000 of your "minimum wage".
That's around £3000.
From 1.6 million people who cant legally earn a smaller wage than they are on?
0 -
Skintgrandad said:The increase by just over £1 per hour in the national Minimum wage is another sly tax steal ( Albeit helping the low paid )0
-
uknick said:molerat said:With these changes there is now no need for voluntary class 2, it should be abolished. Earn enough you get credits or pay the relevant NI rate, don't earn enough you can pay class 3, what is wrong with that ?
If they're abolished I have to pay Class 3 at about £800 per year.
I can see lots wrong with that.I can see it from your viewpoint but why should you "earning" £1K per year be treated differently to an employed person earning the same ?
1 -
molerat said:uknick said:molerat said:With these changes there is now no need for voluntary class 2, it should be abolished. Earn enough you get credits or pay the relevant NI rate, don't earn enough you can pay class 3, what is wrong with that ?
If they're abolished I have to pay Class 3 at about £800 per year.
I can see lots wrong with that.I can see it from your viewpoint but why should you "earning" £1K per year be treated differently to an employed person earning the same ?0 -
I have always thought that it was illogical to pay voluntary class 2 NIC if you earned up to £6,725, but then pay no class 2 NIC if profits were £6,726 to £12,570, and then compulsory class 2 if profits were above £12,570. Now that latter charge has gone, but it implies that the voluntary charge remains for profits under £6,725.
But paragraph 3.11 of the Autumn statement says:
3.11 The government will set out next steps on Class 2 reform next year. As part of this reform the government will protect the interests of lower paid self-employed people who currently pay Class 2 NICs voluntarily to build entitlement to certain contributory benefits including the State Pension. This is a progressive reform, giving lower-paid self-employed individuals a significant tax cut. It simplifies the system for self-employed taxpayers, reducing needless complexity, freeing up valuable time for them to grow their businesses rather than interacting with the tax system. This builds on the Spring Statement 2022 decision to ensure that self-employed individuals with profits between the Small Profits Threshold and Lower Profits Threshold could continue to build up National Insurance credits without paying Class 2 NICs.
Yet those who are employees have to pay expensive class 3 voluntary contributions if they earn £122 a week, but nothing if they earn £124 a week. The whole thing is idiotic. Another issue is that if your turnover is under £1,000, it actually makes sense to register as self employed, even though you are under the limit, so you can pay voluntary contributions at the class 2 rate rather than the class 3 rate. This will be even more beneficial if you get the credit without the payment.
2
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 348.3K Banking & Borrowing
- 252.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 452.4K Spending & Discounts
- 240.8K Work, Benefits & Business
- 617.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 175.6K Life & Family
- 254K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 15.1K Coronavirus Support Boards