We're aware that some users are experiencing technical issues which the team are working to resolve. See the Community Noticeboard for more info. Thank you for your patience.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Some ex's are really nasty when you split up

Options
I've just spent all afternoon consoling a friend who's been well & truly stitched up by her ex. Part of the reason they split up was because of their money problems, but yesterday she found out that he'd gone BR - she only found out because a copy of his BR order was put through the door while she was at work (I bet he got someone else to do it in case he was seen).

Everything they had was in joint names - the flat, the loans & the credit cards. When he left he said rather than make her sell the flat to get his share of the proceeds, he'd be happy for her to stay there as long as she covered the mortgage & all the bills, & he offered to sign a document confirming he was no longer living there. She thought he was doing her a big favour as she loves the flat, & really didn't want to sell up. She was so pleased at him being so understanding she didn't think to get him to sign away any financial interest in the property - he's only been gone a few months, so everything's still very new & raw for her, & she was just glad the relationship was over without them having to carve the furniture in half. But the result is now that, with him going BR on Thursday, she's responsible for all the joint debts - she reckons there's at least £20k on cards alone, because she remembers when they got them & why, but now she's worried it's more than that. She hasn't even looked at the loans yet.

She works part-time & there's no way she can pay that level of debt off on top of her own debts. She's been crying & drinking all afternoon, but has just about retained her sense of humour - she said she can't even jump off a bridge because she's now too drunk to get there. I know going BR is her only option, but I want her to calm down before I say anything about it to her.

Why do people do this? If you don't want to live with someone any more, fair enough. But why do something you full well know is going to saddle them with your debts, ruin their credit rating etc, just because you can? Can people really hate each other that much? :confused::(

Comments

  • Tam_Lin
    Tam_Lin Posts: 825 Forumite
    Dreadful behaviour - deep sympathies to your friend. Can she seek legal advice?
    Nelly's other Mr. Hyde
  • She's going to look into that on Monday. Right now, she's too busy crying & panicking that she'll lose her home, lose her job, have no money etc. Most of the debts are his - she can't drive, but he was the one who got a car because it was 0% interest. She hardly used the credit cards, he used them virtually all the time - he used to come out as part of our group when they were together, & I can't remember the last time I saw him with cash, whereas she only used cards when she didn't have the cash on her (as opposed to not having the cash at all). She's tried ringing him but his mobile is off so she can't even leave a message, & she's tried ringing some of his friends & family, who've either got the answering machine on or say they haven't seen him/don't know where he is.

    I'm sure he knew what he was doing when he did this, & I hope karma grabs him by the small & danglies & squeezes very hard. :mad:
  • fermi
    fermi Posts: 40,542 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Combo Breaker Rampant Recycler
    I agree. That is outrageous.:mad: What a *********

    A good point for her to start is to confirm all her joint liabilities (when she can get her head together). It may be possible that although some debts may be 'shown' as being joint, that she did not physically sign the agreement itself. This may be the case since it seems it was her partner that took out all the debt.

    This is a good starting point:
    Joint and Several Liability

    Introduction.

    If you have taken out a credit agreement, loan or have a bank account in joint names (with another person) then you are both liable for the full amount of any debt.

    This means that if you have a joint loan with a spouse or partner and one of you fails to repay the debt (this often happens following divorce or separation) then the lender could still ask you for payment of the full amount (not just half).

    The lender cannot recover the money twice but can pursue both of you, or just one of you, for all amounts still outstanding until they have obtained full payment.

    Joint and several liability can also apply to rent arrears on joint tenancies, arrears on joint mortgages, Council Tax payments and water charges on properties that have been jointly occupied.

    I did not sign any agreement what can I do?

    For an agreement to be joint and several then it must be signed by all parties (except for Council Tax). If a lender says you are jointly liable for a debt and you believe this is not the case, it may be worth asking for a copy of the original agreement. If you have not signed it then you are not liable.

    For more information please contact us on 0800 074 6918 or email us at: info@insolvencyhelpline.co.uk

    With a bit of luck she can dump some of the debts back onto him.

    But I agree, she should take formal legal advice, either through CAB or another debt charity.

    I think everyone on this board will feel for her, and we will be here if she needs it.
    Free/impartial debt advice: National Debtline | StepChange Debt Charity | Find your local CAB

    IVA & fee charging DMP companies: Profits from misery, motivated ONLY by greed
  • Thanks for the info, fermi - unfortunately, she thinks she's signed everything apart from whatever he may have taken out after moving. :) She remembers signing on a home improvement loan, & certainly did on the cards, because she's got one for each account (each account that she knows about anyway). She also knew about the car, because they got a better deal with both signatories rather than with just one. He paid all the running expenses for it, as he can't drive (the promised driving lessons never happened). It's bad enough the stuff she knew he had, but what's worrying her most is that he might have taken on loads of other financial commitments that she doesn't know about, & that she could get lumbered with, which may put her home at risk. She couldn't afford the mortgage on her own after he left, but she got a really nice lodger a month or so later, so she's never had problems paying for that. As a part-time worker (she takes home about £700pm), she's really had to watch her money, so she's scared witless of what's going to happen next, as she can pay her bills (gets occasional overtime which helps) but can't even think about his debts, which she knows will be large. :(

    Thanks for the link, fermi - I'll pass it on. She's hoping that him signing to say he wasn't be living there any more & all the household bills being in her name, etc will support her case if he's taken on other loans etc after moving out & tries to pass on liability to her, though it won't be much use for anything prior to that date.

    I managed to speak to one of his sisters this morning, who told me to tell her not to ring the house again, & said that if she was daft enough to have joint accounts she deserved what she got. :eek: :mad: A rather unpleasant piece of work from what I've seen (wears T-shirts that have never touched her waistline at the same time as her jeans/skirt, has a 4-boob chest because her bras are the wrong size, has several rings on every finger, & apparently is more familiar with the pub walls at the back than the walls inside - you get the idea), so I hope she gets what she deserves out of life eventually.

    His parents are divorced & she told his dad this morning what he'd done. He wouldn't believe her until she showed him the copy of the BR order, at which point he apologised & went to the cashpoint & got £250 for her, saying if she needed to pay a deposit of some kind for a solicitor she could use that. She said he was so embarrassed by his son's behaviour, but he was also very upset & angry. What a nice man - I'm glad to see some people think he's out of line. It's a pity his sister doesn't feel the same way.
  • It seems he might not be getting away with it - it could be his turn to be kept awake at night.

    My friend met with a solicitor today. She was informed that technically she is responsible for any debts in joint names which she signed her agreement to. :( However, she's not responsible for anything that's just in joint names, & can also fight anything her ex may have taken out using her address after he moved out, because she has the document he signed confirming his last day in the property. Thank goodness she's got that. She can also prove that all the household bills that were in shared/his name were changed to her name only, plus she hasn't touched the joint bank account once since the week he left, which backs up her story that they haven't had shared finances since the relationship ended. She's got to see a specialist practitioner of some kind later this week, & it's going to take a good while to sort out, but it seems that the OR won't be interested in penalising her for what he's done if she can prove she wasn't party to it. They'll need to see her bank statements etc, but if they show the same level of income & expenditure since he left then things will look much better for her. She's one of those people who keeps all her statements, receipts etc, so things might not be so bad after all. :j

    Also, his dad seems to be getting madder about this by the minute. He's spoken to other family members about it, & it seems her ex owes other people money too including his dad, who will now lose out because of his BR - they didn't even know about it until the dad told them he'd been told. His dad has insisted that his son give him a copy of the SOA he submitted - he wants to see what debts, creditors & assets have been listed. If he won't give it voluntarily, he'll ask the OR for it or get a solicitor to make him because as a creditor he's an interested party. He's also said they must all meet up at some point this week to properly discuss what's happened. It seems that his dad has had enough of his son's behaviour (it goes back years apparently). He's told her that he's going to see what his son has to say for himself, & then put it to him that he tells the OR that the debts are his & his alone, leaving him open to a BRO for misinformation but hopefully clearing my friend of any liability (or at least lessening the chance) for the debts. If he won't play ball, his dad has said that she should find out how much she'll be liable for after seeing the solicitor & the specialist (they'll have to look at the SOA, get loads of statements etc), then he'll see what he can do to get it cleared. There's a trust fund from a grand-aunt that his dad has control over (I bet Sonny Jim didn't tell the OR about that), which has a final instalment (over £100k) to pay out at his 40th birthday. His dad doesn't know the ins & outs of the law on it, but he thinks that he should be allowed to pay it from that money, leaving his son to get the balance on the due date.

    His son is going to freak when he hears all this. Good. :)
  • philnicandamy
    philnicandamy Posts: 15,685 Forumite
    10,000 Posts Combo Breaker
    well..i'm glad to hear things are turning around for her...proves you can run but can't hide forever he deserves everything he has coming!
    We all die. The goal isn't to live forever, the goal is to create something that will
  • Too right he does. :) The solicitor said that the fact his father is prepared to speak up on her side & is also one of many creditors will work in her favour. If the OR wants to impose an IVA the creditors need to agree on it, & with the way things are already they're unlikely to unless other terms (longer BR are also imposed). So it would be in the son's interest to change his BR aplication if he's allowed to & take responsibility for the debts that are his instead of trying to pass them on to someone else. Either way, he's going to be in trouble if/when the OR hears about the money from the trust fund - he was obviously hoping to keep that for himself (his 40th birthday is at the end of May), but now he won't be able to. Serves him right. :)

    My friend's got to get the flat sorted out though, as the solicitor quite rightly said property should never be left to an informal arrangement. He said there's a good chance that she might have to buy out her ex's interest in the property, but she's need to sort that out once she knows how much the other debts are. If the OR accepts that she isn't responsible for the majority of the debts, he can't make her homeless by forcing her to sell a property that she half owns in order to get a share for the major debtor. If the OR says she is equally responsible for the debts, he needs to be able to prove that, which he can't. The fact that her ex wasn't forcing her to sell & she was paying the mortgage means that he can't expect to get the full value for the property divided by two, but what half the property would be worth if only half was up for sale. She's got to get someone to look into it in more detail, but the impression she got was that if she could come to an agreement with the OR on a price they'd go for that & put the money towards settling the debts with the creditors, rather than force her to sell, risk not getting a decent price for it & have to give her half the money. She'd have to get an additional loan to do it, but she says she'd rather do that & own the flat outright than have to sell it & face maybe not getting something as nice, but she'll see what amounts they present her with & work from there.

    Her ex has been really stupid. His dad says that if he'd told him about his debts sooner & had asked if there was a way to get to the trust fund money earlier, he wouldn't have given the money to him, but would have arranged for the debts to be settled with the creditors from it once the eligible date had passed. The son has played it crafty, & now stands to not only have a lengthy BRO but also end up with a much smaller trust fund payment than he expected. If he owes more than the trust fund money, he'll end up with nothing at all. :eek: That will teach him to do something so horrible to someone. :)
This discussion has been closed.
Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 351K Banking & Borrowing
  • 253.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 453.6K Spending & Discounts
  • 244K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 598.9K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 176.9K Life & Family
  • 257.3K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.6K Read-Only Boards

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.