50% chance with 'pros' or 95% chance without?
Iggybuhd
Posts: 2 Newbie
in Credit cards
Hello people,
First-time post asking for your opinion(s) and/or advice. Apologies if this post is in the wrong place, I'm not exactly forum savvy !!!128580;
So, I have two bad-credit-esque cards both near their limits: CapitalOne - currently @ £650, and Barclays - currently @ £1900. I've not been very sensible with them in the past, but I've been gradually improving my credit file/score in general, and I'm keen to continue in the same vein. As such, I plan to apply for a 0% balance transfer card and transfer both of these balances on it to pay it off going forward.
My credit score - for what it's worth (from what I see on here, it doesn't mean much), is 'fair' on both Experian and Call Credit, and 'good' with Equifax. Using both Experian's free credit check service and CreditClub, it seems I have two possible/decent enough options:
Tesco CC - 0% fee & 0% up to 22 mths + potential £30 topcashback. 50% chance according to Experian comparison (Tesco don't currently have an eligibility function).
MBNA CC - 1.99% fee (~£50) & 0% up to 36 mths. No potential cashback. 95% chance according to CreditClub comparison & checked on MBNA eligibility checker.
So, it seems with the Tesco option I could potentially be £80 up (less ~£50 MBNA transfer fee + £30 cashback), but I have a lower chance of success, whereas MBNA I'd potentially be ~£50 down, but have a higher chance of success.
Answers [thoughts] on a postcard, please.
Thanks in advance guys.
First-time post asking for your opinion(s) and/or advice. Apologies if this post is in the wrong place, I'm not exactly forum savvy !!!128580;
So, I have two bad-credit-esque cards both near their limits: CapitalOne - currently @ £650, and Barclays - currently @ £1900. I've not been very sensible with them in the past, but I've been gradually improving my credit file/score in general, and I'm keen to continue in the same vein. As such, I plan to apply for a 0% balance transfer card and transfer both of these balances on it to pay it off going forward.
My credit score - for what it's worth (from what I see on here, it doesn't mean much), is 'fair' on both Experian and Call Credit, and 'good' with Equifax. Using both Experian's free credit check service and CreditClub, it seems I have two possible/decent enough options:
Tesco CC - 0% fee & 0% up to 22 mths + potential £30 topcashback. 50% chance according to Experian comparison (Tesco don't currently have an eligibility function).
MBNA CC - 1.99% fee (~£50) & 0% up to 36 mths. No potential cashback. 95% chance according to CreditClub comparison & checked on MBNA eligibility checker.
So, it seems with the Tesco option I could potentially be £80 up (less ~£50 MBNA transfer fee + £30 cashback), but I have a lower chance of success, whereas MBNA I'd potentially be ~£50 down, but have a higher chance of success.
Answers [thoughts] on a postcard, please.
Thanks in advance guys.
0
Comments
-
Apply for the MBNA.
You're double counting the £50 fee in your calculations and also ignoring the much longer term on the MBNA promo.
Going forward, clear your balances in full each month. Revolving a balance on an interest bearing card marks you as high risk, regardless of any pretend scores you're given.0 -
Tesco are pretty tight with the 'up to' bit. Lots of people get offered less.0
-
I would use the eligibility checker on the Capital One site and if all looks good at that point go with the Capital One card.0
-
Thanks for your advice guys.
I already have a CapitalOne card, and although it's showing on the comparisons I've used as being pre-approved, it's only 0% for 6 months.
I seems MBNA is best choice at the minute, even if I do have to pay an initial transfer fee. Tesco may be a bit risky for me at this point in time... maybe I can aim for a fee-free balance card in the future when my credit file/score looks/is a bit better.
Thanks again for your time and efforts.0 -
Deleted_User wrote: »Revolving a balance on an interest bearing card marks you as high risk, regardless of any pretend scores you're given.
What do you mean by revolving a balance? Is that just not paying the card off in full or paying off in full and then spending on the card again?0 -
Revolving means not clearing it.0
-
I found Tesco are pretty generous with limits, and a bit easier to get, if you have a poor credit history.
I'd go for that, in the first instance. The 0% fee means that, even if you don't get as long a term as you thought, it hasn't cost you anything. You can get an MBNA, or something else after, with a lower fee, as you'll have paid a fair chunk off, hopefully.0 -
Thought MBNA were quite strict on lending...Tesco seem more flexible and reasonable starting amounts for me at least £1500.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 342.5K Banking & Borrowing
- 249.9K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 449.4K Spending & Discounts
- 234.6K Work, Benefits & Business
- 607.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 172.8K Life & Family
- 247.4K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 15.8K Discuss & Feedback
- 15.1K Coronavirus Support Boards