Our new Sky Haggling guide - please share your feedback

It is very nice to see a number of customers of Sky have been rewarded for their loyalty but I have not. This is the second time as an existing customer of Sky that I have them unwilling to retain my custom and offer a better deal. Starting to get a bit self conscious lol, is my cash a different value to others? :-) First time I was with Sky for over 10 years, looked for new customer comparable deal but was advised not available to existing customers, looked at Virgin and got a fantastic deal which I was happy with. This was approximately 3 years ago. I then moved house, signed up with Sky for one of their new customer deals, this deal came to an end yesterday. I had everything through them, TV / Broadband and phone. This time (yesterday), I was on 36mb fibre broadband, anytime calls and full tv package. During my 12 months I had this all at a discounted rate of £85.00, which was about to increase in next month to £135.00. Although my DD was for £85.00, I spent nearer to £130.00 each month (calls). I consequently visited BT's website first. Priced up their Total Entertainment, BT Sports UHD package, Multi room / BT Infinity 2 (80mb as I work from home) and call anytime plus they have a tasty sim offer of £10.00, I am very interested in this as one of my mobile contracts is coming to an end next month. BT presented me with a price of £70.00 and this is with their new UHD tv boxes (Sky Q equivalent) and hub. I called Sky as I was armed with a price now and thought my loyalty and persuasion would work, I also advised them to remove the Cinema / Movies element I had, I asked for Sky Q, top broadband and Sky Sports and basic tv with multi room, they have gave me a price of £92.00. I then advised of BT price of £70.00 for the equivalent. Requested they match or improve, they advised no, the £92.00 was the best they could offer. I then said you have had almost £1600 of value out of me this year, never missed a payment, surely you can do a bit better, she said no, £92.00 is the best we can offer. Consequently I have advised to cancel my package, which she did there and then, I received an email literally 2 mins later confirming my cancellation. No retention skills whatsoever or reward for loyalty, I have now signed for BT, however, am still in my 14 day cooling period. However, I am not holding my breath for Sky to call me during this time.

Have just cancelled all of my sky services this morning after being a loyal customer of 17 years.
Have unlimited broadband, no call package as don't have a house phone. £24.90/month
2 very old white sky boxes but pre HD days
multiscreen £12/month
Sky Go extra - never used - FOC
variety pack - no sports or film channels £27.00/month
Total £63.90/month
Althought the chap on the phone made an effort he did not make any offers that would benefit me, update my old boxes or reduce my costs without losing some of my existing services.

I've check on the BT website and can get all new kit, HD, multiscreen and BT Infinity Unlimited. After taking into account cashback and up front costs it comes to an average monthly cost of £51.57.

Let's see if I get a reasonable offer.