PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING

Hello Forumites! In order to help keep the Forum a useful, safe and friendly place for our users, discussions around non-MoneySaving matters are not permitted per the Forum rules. While we understand that mentioning house prices may sometimes be relevant to a user's specific MoneySaving situation, we ask that you please avoid veering into broad, general debates about the market, the economy and politics, as these can unfortunately lead to abusive or hateful behaviour. Threads that are found to have derailed into wider discussions may be removed. Users who repeatedly disregard this may have their Forum account banned. Please also avoid posting personally identifiable information, including links to your own online property listing which may reveal your address. Thank you for your understanding.

We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum. This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are - or become - political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.

RTB-Lease Plans dispute.

Hi Guys,  

Hope to get some much needed advice with my current situation, I posted few months back regarding this issue. 
Words can't describe how much stress and anxiety this is causing me as I feel i am being cheated, 

I am in contact with the local MP as i'm failing to get real answers from the council legal team, they are ignoring my questions and ignoring me in general. 
The council recently replied to my Local MP with utter complete lies, Either someone within the legal team has been misinformed, I don't know if it's some sort of corruption( yes it does exist )  or unfair bias. 
I will post everything in detail below. 

I have applied to buy my  RTB to buy maisonette, I am the upstairs tenant. This issue is with the side gate/side pathway.  As mentioned in a previous post, Surveyor came round to visit property to draw up plans, we received plans which showed Side gate/pathway is part of my property. 
It is the only access to my garden whereas downstairs has its own back garden door.  

when presented to me ( lease plans )  when i had my solicitors appointment, i signed all relevant paperwork and confirmed all is ok to proceed with view to completion. 
I notified my downstairs neighbour of fencing i wish to erect and notified him i will be changing keys to side gate as it's part of my property. 

Neighbour complained as he thinks the side should be shared or i think it's what he had been told when moving in. 
Meanwhile solicitor constant chasing to council legal team with a view to completion as everything was ready. 
6 weeks later we receive email from council as there are changing lease plans as this side accessway is shared, and they are in process of producing new plans. 

Below is the council response to my local MP 

I am sorry for the difficulties experienced by your constituent during his Right to Buy process. It was identified by Mr *** and his Solicitors that the plans did not appear to correctly show the layout of the garden and side accessway. The matter was referred to the Surveyor who had undertaken the initial valuation visit for him to review. Unfortunately, it did require him to re-attend the property as discussions had been raised by Mr *** and his neighbour as to the rights of access over the side walkway, and some clarification was needed.


After the visit and discussion with Mr *** and his neighbour, it was agreed that the side pathway would be shown as a shared path. This then required new plans to be drawn to reflect this.

I have now sent these new plans to Mr **, Mr *** Solicitor, in readiness of setting the matter for completion

This is my response to local MP in regard to above^

I am absolutely in disbelief and saddened with **** Response as none of it is true. 



Reading her response is causing me great anger and frustration, not to mention the stress at home. 
It is making me wonder what sort of connections the downstairs council tenant has within the council. I will explain in great detail with email proof as attachments. 

***** mentioned "It was identified by **** and his Solicitors that the plans did not appear to correctly show the layout of the garden and side accessway"

At no point did we raise an issue with the original plans, As I had already signed them in witness at my solicitor's office, included email confirmation where I tell my solicitor I am satisfied with lease plans, please proceed.  which he would confirm this.  Please kindly ask ***   to provide proof of me having an issue with the original plans. 
This Issue was only raised when the downstairs council tenant made a complaint. 

**** also mentioned "After the visit and discussion with *****and his neighbour, it was agreed that the side pathway would be shown as a shared path. This then required new plans to be drawn to reflect this."    



This is false, As If I had agreed, I would not have contacted you, or made a complaint. I do NOT AGREE to New plans. 

  Not at any point I was approached by the surveyor ****** for a 2nd visit of the property Or anybody for the matter of fact. 
If he did indeed attend the property Considering I am the buyer I should have been made aware, they have my phone number. 
Similar to the first time he came over to draw up plans, we left an appointment for this. 
Why did he not call to arrange an appointment for a 2nd Visit? 
Also, NOT at any point I agreed for the side path to be shared.  As mentioned, It is my ONLY access to my garden, due to privacy reasons I do not want the Side Gate shared, It is my understanding the council Respect the privacy of its tenants. 
They came to the conclusion to change plans once the downstairs council tenant called the council to complain. 


I will explain below exactly what happened, with all email proof attached in this email. I will also attach the Original Lease plans sent to my solicitor which clearly show signed by both Me, ******j and My wife. 

Sometime towards the end of march, I believe it was the 23rd or 25th of March 2021 ( Don't quote me on this )  ***** attended My property to draw up plans on his blank piece of paper. I quote I was told "This is important as the Legal Team create the lease plans for your property based on his drawing"   He Explained to me, The side gate all the way up to your back half of the garden is part of your property. This reflected on the Original plans I received. 

Apologies if any of this is me repeating myself.  

23.06.2021 16.42pm I received an email from my Solicitors and was asked to arrange an appointment to sign all necessary paperwork. 
01.07.2021 I attended the appointment with My wife ****** to sign all paperwork and lease plans with a view for completion.  I was asked to drop an email to confirm I was happy with paperwork and please proceed I sent this at 11.42am on the same day. I have attached proof. 
Weekend 3/4 July I present Lease plans ( the originals ) showing boundaries to my downstairs neighbour explaining to him of the fencing I wish to erect as per plans and explaining to him I shall be changing keys to Side gate as its part of my property. He did not get back to me. 

Monday 05.07.2021 @ 11.39am I received through email from my solicitor the following documents, in which he also said in the email  " Please confirm that you are now satisfied with the lease plans so that I can then send all the necessary documents to the Council with a view to seeking a completion date."    
I responded " I am satisfied with Lease plans Please proceed with completion.   I have attached this as proof. 
A copy of the Lease which contains the lease plans.The Local Authority search result.The Drainage search result.The Environmental search result.​On the same day, My solicitor Mailed over by recorded Delivery all signed paperwork with a view for completion. I have also attached this. 

Monday 05.07.2021 ​I Receive a call from the Housing officer late in the evening regarding a complaint the downstairs neighbour made regarding the access to the side gate and boundaries- She told me you can't change keys to side gate as it's communal. In which i responded according to the Lease plans I have received; It is NOT the case. not to mention the fact she was rude over the phone to begin with and she should not jump to conclusions.  We left an appointment for Thursday 08.07.21 If I'm not mistaken, for her to attend property. 
Throughout the days between 05.07.2021 and 07.07.2021 I wrote numerous emails to different departments from the Council , due to the fact I wanted written evidence in making them aware of what is happening. I had received Plans in question, made the neighbour aware of fencing i wish to erect and the unprofessional way of the housing officer when she called me.  I have attached proof . 

08.07.2021 she the Housing officer attended property, Had a look at side access, took a few photos and videos, ​mentioned " in my opinion i think the side gate should be shared" I argued the neighbour has a means of access to his Garden, whereas the only access for me is the Side gate.  I noticed she came back to visit the downstairs neighbour 1 hour later, in which they had to go down the road to discuss, She spent 5-10mins with me, but at least 45minutes with the downstairs neighbour down the end of the road.  To me that doesn't sit right! 

23.07.2021 @ 15.58 pm My solicitor sends an email to ***** Which says Below  with  PROOF ATTACHED 

"I attach the letter which I sent to you on the 5th July with enclosures.

 Please confirm that you have received the letter and please let me have a completion date and a completion statement as soon as possible."


28.07.2021 @ 16.14 pm My solicitor Writes to ****** Again as no reply.  PROOF ATTACHED. 


"I note that I have not had a response from you to the e-mail that I sent to you on 23 July and which is attached.

 My clients are getting concerned and would like to know when you will arrange a completion date for the above matter"


04.08.2021 @ 16.39pm ***** Responds to my Solicitor with the following PROOF ATTACHED. 

"

Hi ***j,

 

Sorry I couldn’t get back to you earlier.

 

There have been several issues relating to the side access.  We are having to issue new plans as the original ones are incorrect as this side access is shared with the downstairs flat.  New plans have been requested and these will be forwarded to you asap, unfortunately Janet who issues the plans has been on annual leave for a couple of weeks and only works part-time."


PLEASE NOTE : this is the only correspondence we have received from council legal team. ^ 


06.08.2021 I wrote to Tina Replying To the above Email ^ with proof attached. 

Good Morning Tina,

"I had correspondence from***regarding issuing new plans as the original plans are incorrect ( the side gate is now shared )
Of corse at the end of the day I respect the council's decision as you're the landlord and you can decide the Plans as you wish however
I feel like I deserve an explanation as to why the original plans were incorrect ?
Considering number 16 & 16a Marlborough road - have the same plans as the originals which were shown to me.
Not to mention also 9/10 similar maisonettes in ****   have the same layout as per the original plans. 
As mentioned above I feel like I deserve an explanation as I have been a respectful council tenant, paying my rent on time etc
I find it confusing on my behalf as soon as he complained the plans were suddenly incorrect.
Please note- My mortgage offer expires on the 30th September so if you could please try to aim complete purchase before that."


​If Me and my solicitor identified an issue with the Original lease plans as mentioned by ****, I would not have signed the lease plans. I would have not replied to my solicitor with me confirming all is ok, please proceed with completion. I have attached all proof of this. Numerous Email by my solicitor chasing ***** with a view for completion. 


The only correspondence we got from her was that the plans were being Changed as the original are now incorrect, we never asked for this. 

 

The goal posts have been moved from the point of the downstairs neighbour complaining to the council in that he wants access to side gate. 


I have Original Lease plans of my neighbour ******** that Show the originals given to me are correct as they correspond. 


The Stress, frustration and friction this is causing me at home is unexplainable. 


I am willing to take this all the way and fight in what's mine

If needed I will be taking legal action as I 100% know I am in the right


That was my response ^

So, Basically goal posts have been moved from the point downstairs tenant  complained, no clear explanation, they went ahead issued new plans. 

To top it off, they have completely lied when asked for an explanation as to why plans were changed by my MP. 


I would  rather if they told me the truth, as in we are issuing new plans to accommodate and keep happy our 'disabled' tenant.  

Why would I be complaining if i had an issue with the original plans? 

It has gotten to the point where i will fight this to the end and potentially go to court as it is not right. 


Any advice would be appreciated, have an appointment next week with a civil litigation solicitor


I have attached original plans and New plans


Thank you 

«1345

Comments

  • Both properties belong to the council? They can adjust the land registry to mark any changes.
    Buy or don't buy. That's make take on it anway.
  • Section62
    Section62 Posts: 8,952 Forumite
    1,000 Posts Fourth Anniversary Name Dropper

    Cutting a long story short.... have you got anything that proves the downstairs neighbour doesn't have a right to use that pathway to access their rear garden without going through their flat?

    If I've got the location right, is there anything which explains why there is a privet-type hedge dividing part of the front garden off from the pathway accessed by a wooden gate on the front boundary?


    In the absence of any legal documentation to the contrary, I would have said the privet-type hedge represents the boundary between the downstairs front garden and the pathway which belongs to you, and the boundary continues along the line of that hedge back to the boundary between your rear garden and the downstairs flat's rear garden.  With you having an additional right to cross 'their' path to get to your front door.

    That way both properties have a defined 'front' access from the road, and both have a means of access to their respective rear gardens whilst remaining outdoors.
    Julz94 said:

    It has gotten to the point where i will fight this to the end and potentially go to court as it is not right. 

    Any advice would be appreciated, have an appointment next week with a civil litigation solicitor

    My honest advice would be to cancel the appointment.

    It isn't yet clear you have any case to pursue, and unless you have anything more concrete than the council officer talking to the neighbour for longer than they spoke to you, there's not really much for a solicitor to work on.  Rather than having some sinister motive, the point about them walking down the road to speak might be explained be the neighbour feeling in some way bullied or threatened by you and not wanting to talk where you might overhear what was being said.  Equally, they could have been going to look at another property to compare the access arrangements.

    Moreover, do you have the funds to actually take legal action?  A solicitor might give you some cause to be hopeful, but the amount you may spend to 'fight this to the end' could leave you without the funds needed to buy the property.

    Rather than civil litigation, your complaint (if any) is more likely to be one of maladministration.  If the council refuse to change their mind (and I can't see any reason why they should) then your likely legal remedy would be seeking permission for a judicial review of the council's decision.  That would be extremely costly though.
  • AFF8879
    AFF8879 Posts: 655 Forumite
    Ninth Anniversary 500 Posts Name Dropper
    Without meaning to sound flippant, can I ask why this is causing so much distress? Are you saying that the side access being shared means you no longer have a private garden?
  • Norman_Castle
    Norman_Castle Posts: 11,871 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Photogenic Name Dropper
    No time or interest to read the whole post or the other threads but I'd suspect the ground floor property was always intended to have access from the side. If it was your garden you'd want it. You're not being excluded from it and it would have limited use.
    How much is it costing you in rent while you dispute this?
    As above, stick to one thread.
  • anselld
    anselld Posts: 8,527 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    Given that the whole property is presumably currently owned by the Council they can determine and or change access arrangements as they wish.  The fact that you currently share access is supported by the fact that you felt the need to inform the downstairs that you wished to change the lock on the gate.  Presumably until now you can both access the gate so de-facto it is a shared access.
  • user1977
    user1977 Posts: 17,021 Forumite
    10,000 Posts Sixth Anniversary Photogenic Name Dropper
    anselld said:
    Given that the whole property is presumably currently owned by the Council they can determine and or change access arrangements as they wish.  The fact that you currently share access is supported by the fact that you felt the need to inform the downstairs that you wished to change the lock on the gate.  Presumably until now you can both access the gate so de-facto it is a shared access.
    Which I'm sure we've previously been through on one of the other threads. 
  • Julz94
    Julz94 Posts: 48 Forumite
    Fourth Anniversary 10 Posts Name Dropper
    AFF8879 said:
    Without meaning to sound flippant, can I ask why this is causing so much distress? Are you saying that the side access being shared means you no longer have a private garden?
    The fact that my privacy is effected yes , He would have to cross my front door everytime he uses the side pathway/Gate. 
    Now imagine i'm coming home with 10 bags of shopping and he is doing his clearing out his garden and we keep running into eachother, arguments sake. 

    the fact that all maisonettes in my borough have the same setup as the original plans i have received, the fact that my neighbour adjacent to me has the same layout ( picture highlighted in yellow smudge)  Landlord provided me of his lease plans.
    anselld said:
    Given that the whole property is presumably currently owned by the Council they can determine and or change access arrangements as they wish.  The fact that you currently share access is supported by the fact that you felt the need to inform the downstairs that you wished to change the lock on the gate.  Presumably until now you can both access the gate so de-facto it is a shared access.

       I at least deserve an explanation as why the originals are incorrect?  yes it was shared and still is to this date.  I had no idea of the setup of the garden when moving in as mentioned in a previous thread i think, I never questioned it and when i did once the housing officer never got back to me. 
     so i took the neighbours word that the side pathway was shared although i had my doubts.  i was not fussed on the garden till  now we have come to a decision to purchase the place and do up the garden, i was not going to do up the garden till i had boundary's plans. I informed the neighbour because that's how i am as a person- everything i have done around the house/building that might effect him i have always notified him. Slithery said:

    apologies- your absolutely right, i thought old threads get lost. Section62 said:

    Cutting a long story short.... have you got anything that proves the downstairs neighbour doesn't have a right to use that pathway to access their rear garden without going through their flat?

    If I've got the location right, is there anything which explains why there is a privet-type hedge dividing part of the front garden off from the pathway accessed by a wooden gate on the front boundary?


    In the absence of any legal documentation to the contrary, I would have said the privet-type hedge represents the boundary between the downstairs front garden and the pathway which belongs to you, and the boundary continues along the line of that hedge back to the boundary between your rear garden and the downstairs flat's rear garden.  With you having an additional right to cross 'their' path to get to your front door.

    That way both properties have a defined 'front' access from the road, and both have a means of access to their respective rear gardens whilst remaining outdoors.
    Julz94 said:

    It has gotten to the point where i will fight this to the end and potentially go to court as it is not right. 

    Any advice would be appreciated, have an appointment next week with a civil litigation solicitor

    My honest advice would be to cancel the appointment.

    It isn't yet clear you have any case to pursue, and unless you have anything more concrete than the council officer talking to the neighbour for longer than they spoke to you, there's not really much for a solicitor to work on.  Rather than having some sinister motive, the point about them walking down the road to speak might be explained be the neighbour feeling in some way bullied or threatened by you and not wanting to talk where you might overhear what was being said.  Equally, they could have been going to look at another property to compare the access arrangements.

    Moreover, do you have the funds to actually take legal action?  A solicitor might give you some cause to be hopeful, but the amount you may spend to 'fight this to the end' could leave you without the funds needed to buy the property.

    Rather than civil litigation, your complaint (if any) is more likely to be one of maladministration.  If the council refuse to change their mind (and I can't see any reason why they should) then your likely legal remedy would be seeking permission for a judicial review of the council's decision.  That would be extremely costly though.
    Isn't it proof my neighbour  adjacent to me, which is an ex council owned maisonette, he has shown me his plans which correspond with the originals given to me, produced by the same person in 2007.  I have asked two other people on my road and they told me, upstairs flat has side gate/access only.  So basically same setup as original plans.  As mentioned above its in yellow in one of the pictures. 



    The council said to my MP that me and my solicitor noticed an issue in the plans as they do not correctly identify the garden layout and we agreed to have them changed to reflect this- and the surveyor having to come back out to visit the property again. All wrong, I signed lease plans in witness at my solicitors, emailed him twice with  confirmation i am Satisfied  with plans etc please proceed,  and numerous chasing for a completion date - no response. 
    Why would we be chasing for a completion date and why would i sign and confirm twice i am satisfied to proceed ,
    if i had an issue ? 
    Surveyor never attended property again, and if he did he should of left appointment with me to let me know what is happening. like when he left an appointment with me the first time. 

    we finally receive response that plans are changing and they are waiting on the person that produces plans to come into office to create them

    So it went from
    Receive Plans
    Sign them
    Send them off Ready for completion
    Notify Neighbour of plans
    Neighbour complains 
    Plans changing

    And that doesn't sound fishy? 

    not to mention, the fact as soon as he complained and goal posts were moved.
    What if i never said anything to my neighbour? Let sale go through and carry on with my plans without letting him know. 

    I know he pulled some strings for sure cause he mentioned to me once, his sister works in the council
    Furthermore,  The housing officer should remain neutral and not tell me' i think the side gate should be shared' 
    + his Disability card
    So yes i think it's a mixture of things that have swung his way. 




    I will upload some pictures of layout of building and garden, and yes if people think i'm being greedy and unreasonable i will take that on board. 

    And yes I have the funds- it has gotten to the point where my pride and ego tells me to fight for it.  At least then i know i tried rather then letting it eat me up inside afterwards knowing I didn't try. 

    People might not believe it but it is really causing me stress and anxiety as i feel cheated- part of me tells me accept it and move on.  Don't know anymore. 

    If i had gotten a decent 
    explanation, and if they treated me with some sort of respect. Not ignore us- produce new plans and shove it into our face. 

    Yes i know i'm a council tenant exercising my right to buy , Doesn't mean we should be treated poorly. 







  • Slithery
    Slithery Posts: 6,046 Forumite
    Eighth Anniversary 1,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    edited 10 October 2021 at 12:08AM
    I've read all of your posts several times and I still have no idea what you are complaining about?
    No-one has done anything wrong. The council have offered you a property with certain terms attached, if you don't agree to them then find somewhere else to buy instead...
    Julz94 said:
    Words can't describe how much stress and anxiety this is causing me as I feel i am being cheated,
    You're not being cheated. Until contracts are exchanged neither party are under any obligation to do anything.
    Also one of the best life lessons I ever had was to not stress about anything which you have no control over - it's just a pointless waste of time and effort for no reason.
    Waffling on about 'corruption' with no evidence just makes you sound like you have no idea how things work.

Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 349K Banking & Borrowing
  • 252.4K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 452.7K Spending & Discounts
  • 241.9K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 618.5K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 176.1K Life & Family
  • 254.9K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
  • 15.1K Coronavirus Support Boards

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.