Money Moral Dilemma: Should I insist my friend pay for the ornaments she broke? 8 December 2020 at 3:18PM edited 8 December 2020 at 3:20PM in Marriage, Relationships & Families 54 replies 37K views

MSE_Kelvin

This week's MoneySaver who wants advice asks...

 A friend who was reading my birthday cards on the mantelpiece accidentally knocked off and smashed two ornaments on there. I'd recently bought one of them abroad and it was quite expensive – my friend knows this as she was with me at the time, yet she hasn't offered to reimburse me for either ornament. I don't want to ruin our friendship, but should I ask her to pay?

Unfortunately the MSE team can't always answer money moral dilemma questions as contributions are often emailed in or suggested in person. They are intended to be a point of debate and discussed at face value.

😲 If you haven’t already, join the forum to reply.

🙄 Got a Money Moral Dilemma of your own? Suggest an MMD.

74jax

There's a difference between 'asking' and 'insisting' as per the title..
I don't want to ruin our friendship - we don't know your relationship, would asking her ruin it?  Would insisting ruin it? This is an MMD so we'll never know...........
Should I ask her to pay?  Yes if you want to, and no if you don't.

Marvel1

Some friend! I would be offering as it broke.

TBagpuss

You can ask her to replace the ornaments but you can't force her. 
Did she apologise at the time? Did you say anything at the time? 

I wouldn't assume that she would remember  how expensive an item was just because she happened to be with you when you bought it, lots of people wouldn't remember the specifics of their own spending, let alone something that someone else bought. She may, quite legitimately, think they were relatively low (money) value and that an apology was the most appropriate way forward. 
You won't know unless you ask. Why not say to her that you were very fond of the ornament, you've found somewhere they can be replaced, and ask she broke them could she replace them. That said, it's also worth considering it in the context of your friendship as a whole. Does she always expect you to go halves or to pay for what you get when you are together, or does she often treat you>?Does she do you non-financial favours? Is it something which is going to bother you long term if you do't say anything or of she doesn't contribute? 

Aranyani

Could she afford to pay for it? 

Pollycat

74jax said:

There's a difference between 'asking' and 'insisting' as per the title..
I don't want to ruin our friendship - we don't know your relationship, would asking her ruin it?  Would insisting ruin it? This is an MMD so we'll never know...........
Should I ask her to pay?  Yes if you want to, and no if you don't.

+1 to this ^^^^.

JGB1955

If it's that important to you, claim on your contents insurance, suggesting to your friend that she might want to stump up the excess on the policy.

HB01

Any decent person would feel really bad, apologise and offer to pay. Even if someone said it didnt matter I’d be insisting I pay them. If she isnt is she really a good friend with values? It doesnt matter if she can afford it it not it is the offer. Even offering instalments it is the gesture that shows sincerity. I’d mention they had value both sentinental and monetary and ask she replaces them. If she won’t and depending on the friendship (is she a fab friend who is supportive and you can rely on and perhaps as the other reader said treated you to things) I’d consider whether it is worth continuing the friendship. Alternatively knock something off her mantlepiece one day 

elizabethhull

A half-decent friend would immediately offer (as I did when my child broke a plate at a friend's house) to pay for a new one.
A half-decent friend would then (even if through gritted teeth) decline the offer, as my friend did, saying,
'It's only a plate. It's more important that you can be with us.'

hello_petal

This was an accident and not something that your friend did on purpose. I would not risk ruining a good friendship over an ornament so I'd let it go.  People are more important than items.

REJP

Tell her how much they cost and see what she does.  If she laughs it off and does not offer something towards the cost, show her the door.  You don't need friends like that.