We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum. This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are - or become - political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
Automatic Insurance renewal dispute
yak111
Posts: 4 Newbie
I have had contents insurance with IBUYECO since 2010 where I have been paying £11 a month until the end of June this year. They offered me a renewal of £35 per month which obviously I did not want to take as it is a 3 times increase!! I cancelled the direct debit.
I did not renew the insurance with them and have received a snotty letter demanding payment from the time I cancelled the DD plus a cancellation fee and threatening that this can affect my credit history.
I contacted them and when I stated that I did not authorise the renewal of my insurance with them they informed me that since I didn't contact them they renewed the insurance automatically.
What they say I have to pay is £95 this I do not want to pay plus I subsequently noticed they have taken a payment of £35 before I cancelled the DD, this I would like refunded.
Can anyone help as I feel they have trapped me into a contract that I did not want and have renewed a service and taken payments I did not specifically authorise.
I did not renew the insurance with them and have received a snotty letter demanding payment from the time I cancelled the DD plus a cancellation fee and threatening that this can affect my credit history.
I contacted them and when I stated that I did not authorise the renewal of my insurance with them they informed me that since I didn't contact them they renewed the insurance automatically.
What they say I have to pay is £95 this I do not want to pay plus I subsequently noticed they have taken a payment of £35 before I cancelled the DD, this I would like refunded.
Can anyone help as I feel they have trapped me into a contract that I did not want and have renewed a service and taken payments I did not specifically authorise.
0
Comments
-
Cancelling the DD does not cance / lapsel a policy, you would need to advise them in writing or call them to instruct them you do not wish to renew.
If you arranged alternative cover to run concurrently, send them a photocopy of the schedule and ask them to lapse the policy as it obviously was required and delete any charges.
They may argue that the charges are still valid, if you wish to pursue it further, send them a letter by recorded delivery headed "Official Complaint". They will have to investigate the matter properly and report back to you.0 -
You need to check what you agreed to when you took out the policy, auto renewal is very common and just stopping the DD does not cancel the policy.0
-
By not cancelling the contract you did renew the contract with them.
I don't see how you can claim the £35 back. If you didn't tell them you wanted to cancel, and the direct debit was active at the time the money was due to be taken, that is clearly your fault.
I also suspect you owe them the money as well.0 -
When you cancel a direct debit the company that it is payable to don't know that it's been cancelled, that is between you and your bank. The first they would know about it is when they attempt to take the payment due to them and it is blocked. All insurance companies work this way and you have to inform them if you want to cancel.
By the time they would have tried to take the payment they would already have renewed your policy because you didn't tell them not to. You wouldn't like it if they cancelled your policy from their end without telling you and the first you knew about it was when you tried to make a claim and you find out you're no longer covered. It works both ways, they are not mind readers so without you telling them what you were doing they don't know.0 -
I have had contents insurance with IBUYECO since 2010 where I have been paying £11 a month until the end of June this year. They offered me a renewal of £35 per month which obviously I did not want to take as it is a 3 times increase!! I cancelled the direct debit.
I did not renew the insurance with them and have received a snotty letter demanding payment from the time I cancelled the DD plus a cancellation fee and threatening that this can affect my credit history.
I contacted them and when I stated that I did not authorise the renewal of my insurance with them they informed me that since I didn't contact them they renewed the insurance automatically.
What they say I have to pay is £95 this I do not want to pay plus I subsequently noticed they have taken a payment of £35 before I cancelled the DD, this I would like refunded.
Can anyone help as I feel they have trapped me into a contract that I did not want and have renewed a service and taken payments I did not specifically authorise.
First flaw was thinking canceling the DD would cancel the policy and the second flaw was getting in a tizz when it was your fault.
Sounds like you didnt read the terms you agreed toas auto renewal would be mentioned in there. All you do with auto renewal is once the policy is due for renewal you look round for a cheaper quote and once found 1 you either cancel your policy by calling up(ive never had a problem with calling but others suggest do it in writing) and either cancel the policy or you ask the insurer rep if they would match or better a cheaper quote.0 -
First of all thank you for your replies...
Apart from DCFC79. Another person who seems to gloat at other peoples over-sites... I came to this site for some advice not to be belittled...
I am used to services where you have to "opt in" rather than "opt out". If this is my fault for not reading the T&C or there fault for making things a little muddy/changing them from the previous renewals. I am sure they didn't auto renew in 2011... I am sure when they sent out a reminder I had to contact them to continue my cover with them.
Does anyone know if there is a chance of not paying having to pay them and if so how best to go about this...0 -
Having owned and insured a car for 20 years I have never come across a policy which did not auto renew and which didn't write after 11 months stating this?
If you continue to ignore the situation and don't pay they will cancel the policy due to non payment, this will be recorded on the insurance database. You will need to declare this every time you apply for any insurance product that they refused to continue to insure you (meaning main stream insurers will be reluctant to insure you)
As other have said your best way forward is showing you have another policy but I don't think you'll get the £35 back0 -
First of all thank you for your replies...
Apart from DCFC79. Another person who seems to gloat at other peoples over-sites... I came to this site for some advice not to be belittled...
I am used to services where you have to "opt in" rather than "opt out". If this is my fault for not reading the T&C or there fault for making things a little muddy/changing them from the previous renewals. I am sure they didn't auto renew in 2011... I am sure when they sent out a reminder I had to contact them to continue my cover with them.
Does anyone know if there is a chance of not paying having to pay them and if so how best to go about this...
You can try the suggestion posted by dacouch and see if they will waive it but dont get your hopes up.
Ive always contacted the car insurer ( whether they had auto renewal in place or not ) to tell them im not interested in the continuation of the policy beyond its current term. Im sure 10 years ago it wasn't in place or not in use by a majority or insurers.0 -
First of all thank you for your replies...
Apart from DCFC79. Another person who seems to gloat at other peoples over-sites... I came to this site for some advice not to be belittled...
I am used to services where you have to "opt in" rather than "opt out". If this is my fault for not reading the T&C or there fault for making things a little muddy/changing them from the previous renewals. I am sure they didn't auto renew in 2011... I am sure when they sent out a reminder I had to contact them to continue my cover with them.
Does anyone know if there is a chance of not paying having to pay them and if so how best to go about this...
So you've not come on here asking for advice, you've come on here to get people to agree with you that you're right and shouldn't have to pay?
You're on the wrong forum in that case. DCFC79 was spot on, and offered good advice too.
You need to read the terms next time - I've done the same and learnt from it.0 -
When you cancel a direct debit the company that it is payable to don't know that it's been cancelled, that is between you and your bank. The first they would know about it is when they attempt to take the payment due to them and it is blocked. All insurance companies work this way and you have to inform them if you want to cancel.
By the time they would have tried to take the payment they would already have renewed your policy because you didn't tell them not to. You wouldn't like it if they cancelled your policy from their end without telling you and the first you knew about it was when you tried to make a claim and you find out you're no longer covered. It works both ways, they are not mind readers so without you telling them what you were doing they don't know.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 346.5K Banking & Borrowing
- 251.3K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 451.3K Spending & Discounts
- 238.7K Work, Benefits & Business
- 614.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 174.7K Life & Family
- 251.9K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 15.1K Coronavirus Support Boards