Your browser isn't supported
It looks like you're using an old web browser. To get the most out of the site and to ensure guides display correctly, we suggest upgrading your browser now. Download the latest:

Welcome to the MSE Forums

We're home to a fantastic community of MoneySavers but anyone can post. Please exercise caution & report spam, illegal, offensive or libellous posts/messages: click "report" or email forumteam@.

Search
Page 1
    • Aegis
    • By Aegis 7th Apr 08, 7:21 AM
    • 4,742 Posts
    • 2,806 Thanks
    Aegis
    • #2
    • 7th Apr 08, 7:21 AM
    • #2
    • 7th Apr 08, 7:21 AM
    The catch is that you have to have an HSBC current account to open one, you can't transfer in from other ISAs and it has to be opened online. However, said rate isn't to be sniffed at, especially when (unlike Barclays' deal) it doesn't appear to be a limited-period bonus.

    https://www.hsbc.co.uk/1/2/personal/savings/cash-e-isa
    Originally posted by ShelfStacker
    Just to defend my employer here, having an HSBC current account isn't really that much of a catch given that the current accounts are free unless you want the features of a Plus account. I suppose the biggest downside is that they'll have to do a credit check on you prior to opening the account, but for most people that shouldn't be much of a problem.

    It's not quite up to the dizzying heights of some of the other providers, I'll grant you that, but it gives existing HSBC account holders somewhere to go if they want to keep all their accounts in one place. I think this is something people probably value quite highly.

    OK, end of my highly biased post
    I am an Independent Financial Adviser
    Anything I say on the forum is for discussion purposes only and should not be construed as personal financial advice. It is vitally important to do your own research before acting on information gathered from any users on this forum.
  • PauliPauli
    • #3
    • 7th Apr 08, 9:37 AM
    • #3
    • 7th Apr 08, 9:37 AM
    I'm in process of transferring a cash ISA to them (4.75%), I've asked them to "upgrade" this to a Cash e-ISA at 6% when it trasnfers in

    If they don't agree is their any rules in stopping me opening a new Cash e-ISA account with them online now before the other ISA transfers in, then let them sort out the "mess"
  • grifty
    • #4
    • 7th Apr 08, 9:52 AM
    • #4
    • 7th Apr 08, 9:52 AM
    I've just got off the phone from HSBC and they have confused me.

    I already have a Cash ISA with HSBC that I've used over the past 6 or so tax years. For this new tax year, I want a better rate of interest, so would like to open the e-ISA. However, the person on the phone said I couldn't have more than one ISA open. I said that I thought you could open a new ISA with each new tax year. Since I've not used this year's allowance yet (it's only been a day or two after all!), I wanted to open the e-ISA for this tax year.

    However, the person was convinced I would be unable to open the e-ISA if I already had any HSBC Cash ISA open with them.

    Since HSBC do not even allow transfers in to the e-ISA, does that mean the e-ISA is not available to any current HSBC customers with an open Cash ISA from previous tax years?
  • PauliPauli
    • #5
    • 7th Apr 08, 10:05 AM
    • #5
    • 7th Apr 08, 10:05 AM
    I've just got off the phone from HSBC and they have confused me.

    I already have a Cash ISA with HSBC that I've used over the past 6 or so tax years. For this new tax year, I want a better rate of interest, so would like to open the e-ISA. However, the person on the phone said I couldn't have more than one ISA open. I said that I thought you could open a new ISA with each new tax year. Since I've not used this year's allowance yet (it's only been a day or two after all!), I wanted to open the e-ISA for this tax year.

    However, the person was convinced I would be unable to open the e-ISA if I already had any HSBC Cash ISA open with them.

    Since HSBC do not even allow transfers in to the e-ISA, does that mean the e-ISA is not available to any current HSBC customers with an open Cash ISA from previous tax years?
    Originally posted by grifty
    From my dealings with HSBC, they are such a "huge giant" sometimes it better to just go ahead and do online applications ignoring what the person on the phone says.

    Just applied for an e-ISA, the only point I had to accept is "have a subscribed to another ISA in the 2008-2009 tax year", the answer being no, so opening has not broken any goverment ISA rules.

    If it shows up on my list of accounts this week, next month I'll just send them an online message asking to "amalgamate them in to my one e-ISA account"
  • grifty
    • #6
    • 7th Apr 08, 10:24 AM
    • #6
    • 7th Apr 08, 10:24 AM
    If it shows up on my list of accounts this week, next month I'll just send them an online message asking to "amalgamate them in to my one e-ISA account"
    Originally posted by PauliPauli
    I rang again and was told I wasn't informed correctly. They didn't see a reason why I shouldn't open a new ISA for this tax year. She also asked the Team Leader to confirm this and they agreed it should be fine.

    Unfortunately, PauliPauli, transfers in are not allowed. That's stated all over the place, so they won't be able to amalgamate my previous year's ISA savings. Sniff!
  • PauliPauli
    • #7
    • 7th Apr 08, 10:34 AM
    • #7
    • 7th Apr 08, 10:34 AM
    oh well...

    Although I might be lucky, as my previous years ISA hasn't transferred in yet, probably wont till next week, so who knows what the computer will decide to do next week, when it see's my existing e-ISA their
    • simpleguy_blr
    • By simpleguy_blr 7th Apr 08, 10:38 AM
    • 145 Posts
    • 71 Thanks
    simpleguy_blr
    • #8
    • 7th Apr 08, 10:38 AM
    Reply from HSBC
    • #8
    • 7th Apr 08, 10:38 AM
    Hi,

    I had emailed them and this is the reply I got from them:

    =====================================
    Thank you for your e-message received 6 April 2008

    Please be advised that ISA regulations state that ISA account is limited to one per person per tax year.

    I notice that you already hold Cash ISA. Your Cash ISA cannot be converted to e- ISA.

    You may have to close your Cash ISA and open an e- ISA subject to criteria via PIB.

    We are offering an attractive interest rate, currently 6.00% AER for e- ISA. Transfers in from other Cash ISAs are not permitted.

    Please be advised that the monthly gross interest rate of Cash ISA is as follows:-

    Upto GBP9000 4.41%
    GBP9000 to GBP15000 4.65%
    Above GBP15000 4.94%

    ==============================

    This is I feel completely misleading as If I close my Cash ISA I lose the taxfree benefit, now why would I want to do that, I still should be allowed to open the new e-ISA for this year without effecting my previous years ISA...

    Is my understanding correct?

    Please suggest. :confused:
  • PauliPauli
    • #9
    • 7th Apr 08, 10:51 AM
    • #9
    • 7th Apr 08, 10:51 AM
    HSBC have always been a "business not a customer orientated bank" in this regard why would a business start paying more for "existing ISA monies" at a loss, there really only after "new monies"

    Personally I still bank with them, for security/convenience/time with them/excellent online banking system, and I do keep a eye on them... For example they have sneekily reduced their old "online saver" account form 5.75% to 5.6% (there's even two versions of this old "online saver" account as well to confuse matters even further) !!

    I used to be very cynical when it came to banks .. now i'm just practical
  • grifty
    Hi,
    This is I feel completely misleading as If I close my Cash ISA I lose the taxfree benefit, now why would I want to do that, I still should be allowed to open the new e-ISA for this year without effecting my previous years ISA...

    Is my understanding correct?

    Please suggest. :confused:
    Originally posted by simpleguy_blr
    After my initial confusing phone call, I was assured I could open an e-ISA separately in this new tax year while keeping my previous year's Cash ISAs with HSBC available (as you'd expect) and it was confirmed by the Team Leader too.

    They further added that the only reason they suggest you don't open a separate ISA each year is because the interest rate at HSBC gets better the more you put in over the years. But they agreed that this e-ISA is a better rate of interest than the other account anyway, so it would be wise to open this new account. Hope that all makes sense!

    So if, after I have now opened an e-ISA, I am told that my previous ISA savings have been removed or that they have refused to complete my e-ISA application based on ISAs from previous tax years, I will be seeking further advice.

    As far as I can see, all should be well. But you're absolutely right, it's ever so vague and potentially misleading! :confused:
  • mac12
    Has anyone had any problems with HSBC ISAs? I quite interesting in this e-ISA as I already have a current account with them which I am happy about. Their rates on other savings haven't always been the best but I was wondering if I should get this ISA or top off my NS&I ISA for 08/09.

    Thanks!
  • grifty
    Has anyone had any problems with HSBC ISAs? I quite interesting in this e-ISA as I already have a current account with them which I am happy about. Their rates on other savings haven't always been the best but I was wondering if I should get this ISA or top off my NS&I ISA for 08/09.
    Originally posted by mac12
    I think the rate of interest on the HSBC e-ISA (6.00% AER) is currently better than the NS&I rates (4.85% AER for Cash ISA or 5.55% AER for Direct ISA). I've not had a problem with my money at HSBC.

    And, despite the worries we've had on this thread about the e-ISA, it sounds like you aren't in the same boat (i.e. you don't already have an ISA with HSBC), so you should be absolutely fine to apply without concern.
    Last edited by grifty; 07-04-2008 at 11:41 AM.
  • mac12
    Thanks Grifty for that.

    I was wondering - how comes in the website is says it is 5.84% Tax Free but 6.00% interest? Isn't is all tax free?
  • grifty
    mac12, I'm not very good at this malarkey, but I think that 5.84% is the 'gross' interest. If you ask for the monthly interest to be paid into another account, you will only make 5.84% interest over the year.

    However, if you allow the monthly interest to accrue in your e-ISA account, you will earn interest on the interest (called 'compound interest'). Over a year, that would amount to 6% interest (tax-free) in total.
  • mac12
    Ahhh Ha!

    I got it, that makes perfect sense. Thanks again!
    • Rich1976
    • By Rich1976 7th Apr 08, 2:14 PM
    • 167 Posts
    • 59 Thanks
    Rich1976
    What happens to ISA's opened in previoius tax years? I understand that no further money can be added to it if I was to open the HSBC ISA but would I still be able to withdraw money from last year's one ( which is with Nationwide) or does need to be left completely untouched?

    Thanks
  • ShelfStacker
    What happens to ISA's opened in previoius tax years? I understand that no further money can be added to it if I was to open the HSBC ISA but would I still be able to withdraw money from last year's one ( which is with Nationwide) or does need to be left completely untouched?

    Thanks
    Originally posted by Rich1976
    There's no limits on withdrawals other than the ones set by the banks (e.g. notice). However, you can't replace any money you've withdrawn.
    • simpleguy_blr
    • By simpleguy_blr 8th Apr 08, 10:02 AM
    • 145 Posts
    • 71 Thanks
    simpleguy_blr
    Thanks Grifty for that.

    I was wondering - how comes in the website is says it is 5.84% Tax Free but 6.00% interest? Isn't is all tax free?
    Originally posted by mac12
    Hi this is the reply I got from them when I asked them the above question.

    ===========================================
    The AER refers to the Annual Equivalent Rate which is the overall interest rate should the Gross interest be compounded each month. The current Gross rate which is 5.84% which is tax free and this is the return you would see in your account.
    ===============================================

    Which confirms what Grifty has already explained.

    Cheers
  • brookerbabyisababy
    I've applied for this recently. Still haven't heard anything from them. Is anyone else account showing up on online or is it just me? I remember it saying 3 working days?
  • brookerbabyisababy
    looks like its only me who has applied for this then.
Welcome to our new Forum!

Our aim's to save you money quickly and easily. We hope you like it!

Forum Team Contact us

Live Stats

701Posts Today

5,757Users online

Martin's Twitter
  • RT @hugorifkind: Arguing that Hitler was a Zionist is like arguing that the slave trade was pro-immigration. Get a grip.

  • RT @MoneySavingExp: Morning! In this week's email: Loads of ways to save inc. Urgent Sky £30/mth, M&S 50%, £36off Tesco & Hotpoint wins: ht?

  • RT @GMB: Fancy coming on GMB to learn how to save loads on your car insurance with @MartinSLewis? Find out more: https://t.co/B9vQfOliPA

  • Follow Martin