Main site > MoneySavingExpert.com Forums > Shopping & Freebies > Shop but don't drop > Baby Formula - are Aptamil and C&G exactly th... (Page 1)

IMPORTANT! This is MoneySavingExpert's open forum - anyone can post

Please exercise caution & report any spam, illegal, offensive, racist, libellous post to forumteam@moneysavingexpert.com

  • Be nice to all MoneySavers
  • All the best tips go in the MoneySavingExpert weekly email

    Plus all the new guides, deals & loopholes

  • No spam/referral links
or Login with Facebook
Baby Formula - are Aptamil and C&G exactly the same??
Closed Thread
Views: 24,128
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
# 1
WOW Factor 0
astralbee
Old 21-07-2008, 7:43 PM
MoneySaving Convert
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Blackpool
Posts: 99
Default Baby Formula - are Aptamil and C&G exactly the same??

Just had our first baby and after a couple of weeks attempted breastfeeding have had to switch to formula. We tried SMA but didn't think so much to it - lots of reports of baby constipation and it was true in our case too.

So here's the decision we were faced with - Cow&Gate, or Aptimil?

A friend of ours who works in child health uses Aptimil for her own children, which she prefers because of its probiotic content. But she also gave us the impression it was much more expensive, so we went with Cow&Gate which is now boasting probiotics anyway.

Now, I'm all for saving money but I want the best for my child. Although baby is really happy with the C&G I kept picking up Aptimil in the supermarket and wondering if we should have gone with that. Turns out its only a quid or so more for the largest tub.

BUT!! Today I just noticed something. Both Aptimil and Cow&Gate are manufactured at exactly the same place, not only in this country but also in Ireland too. I mean, the manufacturing address is identical, even the unit number of the industrial estate. Coincidence?

Are these two products, one priced slightly more competively, exactly the same?? If so, you could save yourself a few quid by switching to the cheaper one. I'm interested in hearing from anyone that knows more.
astralbee is offline
Report Post
# 2
katiecoodle
Old 21-07-2008, 7:58 PM
MoneySaving Stalwart
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 347
Default

Not sure if they're the exact same product but when my kids were little the midwives all agreed they had less reactions like colic to Aptamil fed babies, rather than any other brand. I suppose the address in Ireland is just a milk 'factory' & they have different recipes to follow for different brands...?
katiecoodle is offline
Report Post
The Following User Says Thank You to katiecoodle For This Useful Post: Show me >>
# 3
zebulon
Old 21-07-2008, 10:16 PM
MoneySaving Stalwart
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 582
Default

did you compare full listing of ingredients maybe (incl their order in the list etc) ?

this type of situation is known for other products (food or not) so why not this one! congratulations for you baby
zebulon is offline
Report Post
The Following User Says Thank You to zebulon For This Useful Post: Show me >>
# 4
Gondo
Old 21-07-2008, 11:05 PM
MoneySaving Convert
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Plymouth
Posts: 112
Default

'Tis a little while since I was at that stage-but I was recommended Aptamil by my midwive because she felt it was the closest to breastmilk (had less long chain fats????)-but I never compared I must admit that I took advice given (have learnt since then to canvas for opinions!! :rolleyes: )

However I used to be able to buy the milk at 'cost' from the baby clinic which worked out a couple of pound cheaper than the supermarket (and they had a range of brands)-just a thought if you can access one locally to you-again I found out from the health visitor where the clinics were so that I could pick it up close to work if necessary. Not sure if this is local policy or happens nationally :confused:

Hope this helps and enjoy babe (feeding children does become a nightmare of label reading now!!) x
Gondo is offline
Report Post
The Following User Says Thank You to Gondo For This Useful Post: Show me >>
# 5
astralbee
Old 21-07-2008, 11:24 PM
MoneySaving Convert
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Blackpool
Posts: 99
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by zebulon View Post
did you compare full listing of ingredients maybe (incl their order in the list etc) ?

this type of situation is known for other products (food or not) so why not this one! congratulations for you baby
True, but normally the production lines that make multiple brands are doing them for 'off-brands' such as supermarket's own. I don't doubt that Asda cornflakes are made at the same place as Morrisons and Tescos... but Kellogs do make the claim that they don't make cornflakes for anyone else.

I'm aware of this kind of manufacturing yet the similarity between the two baby formulas still surprised me because these are both leading brands.

I saw a thread elsewhere on the forum where somebody had mentioned how Farley's brand of formula was no longer being made. This had been another brand that our health-visitor friend recommended. Today in the supermarket I saw that Heinz (who have owned Farleys for about 14 years) have their own brand of formula which I was unaware of until I saw it. Perhaps that is also a rebadged product?

I had a cursory glance at the ingredients (there are so many in formula!) and they looked identical, but not all were quite in the same order which I know can be significant but not always. The ingredients have to be in descending order of quantity, but if several ingredients are present in equal quantities then they could be ordered differently. Perhaps the few differences were deliberate so that they can market it as two seperate products?
astralbee is offline
Report Post
The Following User Says Thank You to astralbee For This Useful Post: Show me >>
# 6
zebulon
Old 22-07-2008, 12:15 AM
MoneySaving Stalwart
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 582
Default

a bit off topic but there is a code around just now in the freebie board to use when registering on the C&G website (free), and you get a nice little cuddly cow
zebulon is offline
Report Post
# 7
amandada
Old 22-07-2008, 4:44 AM
Serious MoneySaving Fan
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 1,134
Default

You might be able to buy formula at your local health centre or bac clinic. If you can, it's usually at least a couple of pounds per pack cheaper
amandada is offline
Report Post
# 8
mad&jon
Old 22-07-2008, 8:13 AM
MoneySaving Convert
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Posts: 171
Default

I'd go with Aptimil. Tried my son on both but he didn't like cow & gate. It was quite thick and savoury smelling. Apitmal was thinner and sweeter smelling. Aptimil is closet to breast milk from what my midwife told me. SMA gold was another make that went down very well with my son and its a little bit cheaper than Aptimil. Didn't find many offers when buying baby milk though - baby jars of food etc always had some kind of deal but milk very rare.
hth and enjoy your new baby!
mad&jon is offline
Report Post
# 9
Sazere
Old 22-07-2008, 9:08 AM
Serious MoneySaving Fan
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: North Warwickshire
Posts: 783
Send a message via AIM to Sazere Send a message via MSN to Sazere
Default

The baby clinics don't sell cheap baby formula anymore due to 'breast is best' WHO recommendations.

Same reason why baby formula is not included in promotions, discounts, bogofs, etc at shops/supermarkets. Once they reach progress milk stage (if you decide to use progress milk 6+ months) then this is often on offer.

http://www.who.int/nutrition/publica...de_english.pdf (Article 5)


Personally I have used SMA Gold then White for first no problems, C&G First for second (after trying every make he threw up less on this), third had aptamil/Infatrini, fourth had aptamil. I have really found it depends on what suits the child and how easily they can digest the milk.

Last edited by Sazere; 22-07-2008 at 9:13 AM.
Sazere is offline
Report Post
# 10
squiggle2902
Old 22-07-2008, 9:32 AM
MoneySaving Newbie
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 10
Default

Hi
I had my daughter on Aptamil but one day when I found it hard to get hold of I spoke to the helpline who advised me that the Cow & Gate is the same product but the ingredients in the Aptamil are of a higher quality. I didn't believe this and just took it that the products were the same - they try and push Aprtamil because it's around £1 a tub more expensive. As it happens rhe prebiotics didn't agree with my daughters tummy and she suffered terrible wind pains whilst on this milk - once I swopped over to SMA (the milk both my other children had when they were babies) she was fine!

S~
squiggle2902 is offline
Report Post
# 11
scottishgal
Old 22-07-2008, 10:57 AM
MoneySaving Stalwart
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 462
Default

I wondered this too, I did actually compare ingredients, and although their ingredients are all pretty much the same the order of them is different. So like that I couldn't choose between them. Aptamil is the most expensive baby formula though, and I have heard that baby is less likely to be constipated on it. I've personally never tried it though. I guess if baby is happy on C&G just stick with it, in the long run it doesn't make much odds.
scottishgal is offline
Report Post
# 12
zebulon
Old 22-07-2008, 12:25 PM
MoneySaving Stalwart
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 582
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by scottishgal View Post
I guess if baby is happy on C&G just stick with it,
that's my thought - and I was thinking, everytime you buy it, put the difference with the more expensive one in a money box
zebulon is offline
Report Post
# 13
claire2004pink
Old 22-07-2008, 1:34 PM
MoneySaving Newbie
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 10
Talking

Hello
Newbie here.. hope this is ok.
Both Cow and Gate and Aptamil are owned by the parent company Nutricia (I know some one who works for them).
They both contain pre biotics but a the moment Aptamil contains the pre biotic mix which is the closest to breast millk, that is really the only difference as ar as I am aware, as long as your little one is happy on the milk they are getting dont worry would be my advice.
HTH
claire2004pink is offline
Report Post
The Following User Says Thank You to claire2004pink For This Useful Post: Show me >>
# 14
Gondo
Old 22-07-2008, 2:51 PM
MoneySaving Convert
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Plymouth
Posts: 112
Default

[quote=Sazere;12693687]The baby clinics don't sell cheap baby formula anymore due to 'breast is best' WHO recommendations.

Same reason why baby formula is not included in promotions, discounts, bogofs, etc at shops/supermarkets. Once they reach progress milk stage (if you decide to use progress milk 6+ months) then this is often on offer.

http://www.who.int/nutrition/publica...de_english.pdf (Article 5)/quote]


Gone a bit OT -I hadn't realised that baby clinics had taken that to not sell baby formula-whilst I recognise that breast is best I also appreciate there are many reasons why a mother would chose not do or may not be able to breast feed. As the WHO guidance points out there are also many socioeconomic factors behind many not breastfeeding and I had thought that was why the baby clinics sold it at cost (and why you could use milk tokens to buy baby formula milk(not follow on milk) if you're on benefits but perhaps that's changed now too? Sorry gone off topic now but puzzled -this guidance http://http://www.usdaw.org.uk/equal...ft50408.pdf(Pg 20) health benefits indicates that baby formula available to all at some clinics even if not on benefits. I'll wind my neck back in now
Gondo is offline
Report Post
Closed Thread

Bookmarks
 
 




Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

 Forum Jump  

Contact Us - MoneySavingExpert.com - Archive - Privacy Statement - Top

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

All times are GMT. The time now is 2:08 PM.

 Forum Jump  

Free MoneySaving Email

Top deals: Week of 29 October 2014

Get all this & more in MoneySavingExpert's weekly email full of guides, vouchers and Deals

GET THIS FREE WEEKLY EMAIL Full of deals, guides & it's spam free

Latest News & Blogs

Martin's Twitter Feed

profile

Cheap Travel Money

Find the best online rate for holiday cash with MSE's TravelMoneyMax.

Find the best online rate for your holiday cash with MoneySavingExpert's TravelMoneyMax.

TuneChecker Top Albums

  • VARIOUS ARTISTSBBC RADIO 1'S LIVE LOUNGE 2014
  • TAYLOR SWIFT1989 (DELUXE)
  • ED SHEERANX (DELUXE EDITION)

MSE's Twitter Feed

profile
Always remember anyone can post on the MSE forums, so it can be very different from our opinion.
We use Skimlinks and other affiliated links in some of our boards, for some of our users.