What class are you?

Options
135

Comments

  • stevemcol
    stevemcol Posts: 1,666 Forumite
    Options
    It is interesting and I think things have changed significantly. There are a few obvious questions.

    Do you stay in the class band you are borne into?

    If your parents' outlook improves / worsens as you grow up, does you class change accordingly?

    When you leave home and start work, if your job prospects improve through promotions etc do you climb a class ladder?

    If you inherit wealth or win the lottery and give up work has your class changed?

    If you lose your job late on in working life, never recover and turn to benefits, possibly lose your home, have you become a member of the underclass?

    If you do well in business what class are you? What class would Alan Sugar be for example?

    If it is important to have a class system, there should be some way of measuring where you start and where you end up. Personally, I've managed to tread water.
    Apparently I'm 10 years old on MSE. Happy birthday to me...etc
  • geri1965_2
    geri1965_2 Posts: 8,736 Forumite
    Options
    Very tricky, I am a socialist from a working class background. University educated, professional with kids in independent school, own home on a council estate but earning well above the national average running a charity. I reckon i could tick upper working, lower middle or middle but on balance think most people would consider me middle class.


    <

    Funny kind of socialist, sending your kids to an independent school.
  • Mark_Beech
    Mark_Beech Posts: 77 Forumite
    Options
    This is all a bit oxymoronic .... In that a good proportion of the "Working Class" don't have a job ..... And pretty much all of the "Middle Class" do. And what is the "Underclass" all about? Does it mean they have no class? "Upper Middle" is almost a contradiction in terms .... as is "Lower Middle".
    Having said all that it also depends on whether you classify yourself as to where you came from, the heights you rose to, or where you are now.
    I started life in a working family living in a virtual slum with no bathroom and a loo at the bottom of the yard. But I won a place at a Grammar School eventually got a Masters Degree and worked my !!!! off to eventually become a Regional Manager in the NHS. Now in retirement I sit on a variety of National Committees .... But my income has dropped back to not far off the average wage.
    I do own a nice 300 year old cottage in a hilltop village in the Ribble Valley two cars and most of the material possessions most people might ever want. The only thing I don't have much of is good health.

    So I suppose I started off as Working Class ...... but even with an income reduced in retirement I guess most people would place me as Middle Class.

    It's all a bit too subjective really!

    :think:
    Mark
  • stevemcol
    stevemcol Posts: 1,666 Forumite
    Options
    geri1965 wrote: »
    Funny kind of socialist, sending your kids to an independent school.

    That's like saying a tory voter can never hold a trades union membership or a labour clause 4 supporter could never travel on a privatised railway.
    Apparently I'm 10 years old on MSE. Happy birthday to me...etc
  • geri1965_2
    geri1965_2 Posts: 8,736 Forumite
    Options
    stevemcol wrote: »
    That's like saying a tory voter can never hold a trades union membership or a labour clause 4 supporter could never travel on a privatised railway.

    No it isn't. Union membership is for the benefit of the workers, regardless of their political views, and it would be pretty difficult for anyone to travel on a railway which isn't privatised, since there aren't any.

    Sending your children to an independent school is an active choice. Essentially you are saying I can afford the best for my children, sod the rest of you. It is the antithesis of socialism.
  • stevemcol
    stevemcol Posts: 1,666 Forumite
    Options
    geri1965 wrote: »
    No it isn't. Union membership is for the benefit of the workers, regardless of their political views, and it would be pretty difficult for anyone to travel on a railway which isn't privatised, since there aren't any.

    Sending your children to an independent school is an active choice. Essentially you are saying I can afford the best for my children, sod the rest of you. It is the antithesis of socialism.

    I disagree. A socialist sending their kids to private school might demonstrate a slight lack political of conviction and perhaps a little human fallibility. It doesn't actually do any harm to the state sector though. Every kid that goes to a private or independent school actually relieves some burden on the state, assuming the parents continue to pay their taxes. I'm a socialist (but fallible) and have no problem with the concept of earnings providing choice. What I do strongly believe is that nationally provided education (and health) should be of the highest standard possible so as to make the independent options almost irrelevant and level the playing field for kids of different backgrounds.
    It would be wrong to make choices for your own kids just to validate your political beliefs. The child probably hasn't decided its own politics yet so the last thing it needs is its parents' foisted on him or her. If parents have spare cash, better to spend it on a private education for the kids than a month in the Caribbean and a new people carrier every year.
    Personally I wouldn't send my kids to a private school but that's my choice.
    Apparently I'm 10 years old on MSE. Happy birthday to me...etc
  • johncolescarr
    johncolescarr Posts: 294 Forumite
    edited 9 May 2013 at 1:47PM
    Options
    Class nowadays seems to be about how much money you have, be it inherited/earned or borrowed. However, I consider your views and actions to define your class.

    I consider vulgar consumption of huge newly built £m's american style mansion type residence with 3 gas guzzling range rover sports on the driveway to be underclass or non class. This is usually people who have acquired huge wealth and do nothing with it than satisfy their egos. None of the money gets put to good use helping the community or your family.

    Class is generally defined by interest and views.

    Working class:
    Hobbies are generally sports, mainly football, going to be pub, working club, bookies. Holidays taken are either local seaside resorts such as Blackpool or package euro sun holidays such as Benidorm, with little cultural interaction when on holiday. Newspapers read will be daily mail, sun, mirror or star. Political views either far right or Labour dependent on background. Most will have a sky/virgin account and have many expensive gadgets. working class can be very wealthy or very poor.

    Middle class is generally an aspiring class and ironically is heavily influenced by fashion and trends, despite many middle class people pretending to be the exact opposite. An example is many middle class people are fashionably doing the austerity thing, not through necessity but because it is seen as the thing to do. Middle class lifestyle is assisted by, not not dependent on a reasonably high income. holidaying will be off the beaten track holidays, such as safari in Africa, treking in Peru, mountain biking in the lakes as budget allows. All will be highly cultural, ie immersing oneself in the local culture. Papers read will be the Times, Telegraph, Guardian and Independent. Political views will be centre left or centre right and green party dependent on background but political allegiance will be closely guarded except green party. Hobbies are food, wine, travel, gardening, opera/theatre. Radio will be R4 or classic FM. House will generally be Victorian/Georgian/1930s in a good neigbourhood with access to good state or independant schools. Car choice very important, not too flash but with just the right image, posh estate cars feature highly, but best to be 5-10 years old so as not to seem too expensive. Alternatively a toyota prius for the greens. Typical job white collar, eg banker, doctor, solicitor, engineer. Many business start ups to service the middle class, such as fancy coffee shops.

    Upper class is inherited wealth or people from that background. Whether they actually have money or not is irrelevant. Upper class strongly believe in social superiority. Upper class don't care about image and enjoy having unpopular hobbies, such as fox hunting. All will aspire to a country pile, sending children to public school and partying with royal/nobility. I have met many upper class living on council estates.
    Holidays will be south of france, scotland etc, and will want to indulge in upper class culture only.
    Cars can be anything from 30 year old landrover to aston martin or Bentley. Upper class do not work in convectional sense, ie are financially independent based on inheritance or rental income from inherited property/land or manage an estate. wannabe upper class work for the upper classes but hold the same views.

    Ultimately class classifications are ridiculous as is my descriptions of them above!!
    Mortgage £120K, monthly overpayment £600, 18 years and £100K saved
  • stevemcol
    stevemcol Posts: 1,666 Forumite
    Options
    johncolescarr

    The thanks button isn't sufficient recognition for that exceptionally entertaining post. So good I read it twice!
    Apparently I'm 10 years old on MSE. Happy birthday to me...etc
  • MrsE_2
    MrsE_2 Posts: 24,162 Forumite
    Combo Breaker First Post
    Options
    I have met many upper class living on council estates
    Rubbish - I'm happy to accept you get the odd middle class person fallen on hard times, but MANY upper class (landed gentry) no way.
    Perhaps the odd junkie/ex-junkie who's been thrown out of the inheritance I'm happy to believe.

    According to your description I'm a confused mix of working (I have sky & gadgets) & middle class. I'm working class I just have some middle class ideals I've picked up along the way :-)
  • johncolescarr
    johncolescarr Posts: 294 Forumite
    Options
    MrsE wrote: »
    Rubbish - I'm happy to accept you get the odd middle class person fallen on hard times, but MANY upper class (landed gentry) no way.
    Perhaps the odd junkie/ex-junkie who's been thrown out of the inheritance I'm happy to believe.

    According to your description I'm a confused mix of working (I have sky & gadgets) & middle class. I'm working class I just have some middle class ideals I've picked up along the way :-)

    Ok, I concede I have not met many so called upper class on council estates, but I have met a few. I recall a family who were in poverty but still lusted after the nearby manor house where they were staff after the family left.

    My last paragraph sums up my views, I came from a background of living on benefits and a family where I was one of the first to go to university, went to state school yet I speak with an accent some might consider RP, I am in group A in the socioeconomic classification simply owing to my job (although simply knowing this displays my vanity and obsession with class). I only wear church shoes but buy them off of ebay 2nd hand and I let people think they were £300. I am by my own definition desperately middle class, but I know I am and laugh and and ridicule myself.

    Class is desperately outdated and a bit silly, but the majority are hopelessly obsessed with classifying themselves, we're all guilty of it.
    Mortgage £120K, monthly overpayment £600, 18 years and £100K saved
This discussion has been closed.
Meet your Ambassadors

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 343.2K Banking & Borrowing
  • 250.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 449.7K Spending & Discounts
  • 235.3K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 608.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 173.1K Life & Family
  • 247.9K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 15.9K Discuss & Feedback
  • 15.1K Coronavirus Support Boards